4 ms·
Interesting, why doesn't Fly offer their own managed services and move up-market like DigitalOcean and others (and of course, the big cloud players)? I haven't
by satvikpendem 3y ago
Interesting, why doesn't Fly offer their own managed services and move up-market like DigitalOcean and others (and of course, the big cloud players)? I haven't heard of other companies coming in to collaborate on managing the hosted version of other companies' unhosted service.
- KRAKRISMOTT 3y agoThey lack the institutional DNA and culture for site reliability engineering. They have amazing system engineers and this is rather obvious from their blogposts. However their uptime numbers are frankly horrifying and in their support forums they spend a lot of time making customers do the work for them. They don't have the institutional culture to be running modern cloud infrastructure. Good engineers, terrible operators.
- cultofmetatron 3y ago> However their uptime numbers are frankly horrifying and in their support forums they spend a lot of time making customers do the work for them I really hope this improves. I love what they are doing but there's a reason my company elected to build out a custon deployment on aws. reliability is KING when you have paying customers. Until they bring those numbers up, they are only going to be good for hobby projects
- biorach 3y agoI think you're being unfairly harsh. Looks to me like they're improving.
- tptacek 3y agoThey're related but distinct problem spaces. Craig Kerstiens is somewhere else on this thread talking about the work that went into Heroku's Postgres. Paul Copplestone can give you an earful about how hard Supabase was to build. We can talk your ears off about orchestration and Anycast networking. These are all big problems; they're not just features. I vividly remember hanging out on my back porch with Kurt as we were plotting out attached storage (we didn't even start out with storage!) and him telling me how hard it would be to replicate the kind of work Craig and Paul had done --- he'd know, after doing Compose.io! We had no illusions that we were going to provide that. Instead, we charted out a halfway point: "automated" but not "managed" Postgres, which is almost (not quite) just an application you deploy on top of Fly.io. You can see from my sibling comment how well that went. A managed database practice monitors and intervenes with database clusters in ways a fire-and-forget automated system doesn't. If you don't do all that work --- a whole (huge) company's worth of work --- you break peoples expectations, and they question your pedigree on message boards. :)
- swyx 3y agojust here to say i love how well you take criticism. increases trust a lot because you are self aware yet provide a lot of competency proof points. you dont need it but thank you for what you do.
- tptacek 3y agoThank you! The team here gives us a lot to work with. Also: people dunking on us aren't wrong! We've made bets that represent particular spots on all sorts of reliability/predictability/performance/complexity axes. They are what they are, and it would be freaky if all of them paid off. We're wrong about some of this stuff. All we can do is be honest about what we're going for, and how that's going.