5 ms·
I am not interested in any of the "we are in a bubble" posts as much as I am interested in "What the fuck will happen when this bubble bursts!" I have been in
by samstave 15y ago
I am not interested in any of the "we are in a bubble" posts as much as I am interested in "What the fuck will happen when this bubble bursts!"
I have been in tech in SV since 1997. I was here for the build, frenzy and pop of the last bubble.
In 2001 I had a BBQ at my place - 50 people came and we ate and drank by the pool. Of those 50 - all tech workers - 4 had jobs.
I was out of work for 18 months (6 of which I traveled the world) - and luckily I have more than just tech skills which I was able to fall back on.
On HN we are really focused on technical ability - but there are millions of employees in all our tech companies that are not technical: think of any department outside of IT and Development == Sales, Facilities, HR, Marketing, Finance (although this is the class of people most responsible for this problem), etc...
ALL of these people are at the greatest risk - what will happen if this bubble bursts. We will be FUCKED.
What will it look like
- damoncali 15y agoI don't expect the same level of carnage. THE bubble, the late 1990s, was so enormous that I have trouble explaining it to my younger peers who did not live through it as an adult. They just can't grasp what was going on because it was so damn crazy.
- ktizo 15y agoBoo.com spending almost 200 million in 6 months on marketing without really sorting out product. Or even thinking that they needed to.
- stretchwithme 15y agoOf more concern to me is the bursting of valuation bubble for the United States. Currently, people are undervaluing the risk of lending money to it. What happens when they realize its future revenues won't cover all of its commitments?
- comicjk 15y agoIf the US had European tax rates, it could support its current commitments and more. The risk is political: that the US will default on debts which it has the ability to pay.
- _delirium 15y agoIn fact it doesn't even have to go to European tax rates to pay off its debt. All levels of government in the U.S. currently take in a combined 27% of GDP in taxes. In Germany, it's 41% (not to mention Denmark at 49%), which leaves quite a lot of fiscal headroom for the U.S. to raise additional revenue while still remaining a relatively low-tax country.
- ericd 15y agoUS Gross debt is currently around 16.4 trillion, its GDP in a given year is around 14.6 trillion, and its operating budget is around 2.5 trillion with a 1 trillion deficit. It seems within its capabilities to repay its debts, though it has opened up the throttle a good amount in the past couple years, and there seems to be no political will to raise taxes right now.
- fennecfoxen 15y agoBy "operating budget" I assume you mean revenues. For reference, the US spent $2.73 trillion in 2007 and $2.9 trillion in 2008. It plans on spending $3.8 trillion in 2012 and about the same in 2013. When you say "opened up the throttle a good amount" that amount is in the vicinity of ~35%. (These numbers are not adjusted for inflation. Sorry.)
- ericd 15y agoRight, that's the revenue they have to play with, and yep, that's what I meant by opening up the throttle :-)
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- stretchwithme 15y ago"The political expression of altruism is collectivism or statism, which holds that man’s life and work belong to the state—to society, to the group, the gang, the race, the nation—and that the state may dispose of him in any way it pleases for the sake of whatever it deems to be its own tribal, collective good." Ayn Rand
- ericd 15y agoI don't see how that applies here? That communism doesn't work well or is inherently unfair doesn't generalize into the idea that the less communistic a society is, the better. In general, I think Rand is overly reductionistic and shouldn't constitute a significant portion of anyone's worldview.
- stretchwithme 15y agoAnd by commitments, I don't just mean its budget and its 16 trillion in debt. I include all the debt we took over from the banks and the bottomless pit of AIG. I include all the private pension funds that are insured by the government. The President of the Dallas Federal Reserve, Richard W. Fisher, painted a rather bleak picture of what our liabilities actually are when he spoke to the Commonwealth Club. Fisher said back in 2008, before the collapse of AIG, that our liabilities exceed $99 trillion. His speech is here: http://www.dallasfed.org/news/speeches/fisher/2008/fs080528.cfm Of course, we can walk away from these things or inflate our way out, but those are just different endings to the same bubble. Confidence that the bubble will not collapse is the only thing keeping this bubble from collapsing.
- jpdoctor 15y ago> What will it look like It depends on how much leverage gets into the system before the burst. Witness the difference between the tech and housing bubble bursts: People were buying tech stocks with the 1:1 margin requirements (because dude! tech stocks only go up!) vs housing which were leveraged by the home buyers at 5:1 - 10:1 (because dude! home prices only go up!) and by the hedge funds at 30:1 (because dude! national home prices never go down!) I haven't heard a lot of people buying GRPN/ZNGA/LNKD on margin yet. FB might well change the tone though.
- sidman 15y ago> ALL of these people are at the greatest risk - what will happen if this bubble bursts. We will be FUCKED I have the same thoughts exactly. I was a junior at university when the last bubble burst so i have no idea what it was like. Currently i have been running my startup after quitting my job for almost a year and we are doing OK but this talk of bubble worries me because i dont know what to expect. Will it only effect startups that are social types that dont exactly generate revenue but through capital injection( which i assume is what will evaporate the fastest during a pop) have the potential to become massive such as instagram etc or will it also effect the startups that actually do turn up a profit every month so that the founders can eat and re-invest their money back in the business. When i try to draw parallels from 2000 from a technology stand point, i assume the bubble pop killed the tech industry because getting a startup of the ground required tons of cash, it didnt matter whether you could charge from day one or it was a great idea but needed to get to scale before you could make money, you still needed to buy servers, hosting and your development team was larger because there were no frameworks etc .. basically there was alot to spend before you could turn a profit, so when capital dried up so did the ability to start a new company or even continue to run an existing one. As a founder, unless you were already wealthy you could not bootstrap Now with amazon, great frameworks that cut down development time many times over and other things of the like, founders can take savings of 10-15k and start a business that can return that investment maybe after 4-5 months and start making profit soon after. The question is, do these kinds of startups still survive, could this be the differentiating factor this time if the bubble pops. Maybe after the bubble pops we wont get those massive social startups that require millions of dollars worth of injection for a while but instead get many smaller bootstrapped business types that take a small investment and return a profit monthly that eventually grow into large business. Its slower but similar to more traditional businesses. If this is the case then i feel its OK, at least if we find an area there people still have a need and technology solves that need we can still make a living doing our own startup and work on things we love. Im also interested because we are bootstrapped and we have managed to get our small startup to give us back about 60% of our salary that we used to get at our 9-5. its enough to live of and not make us wonder where we are going to get our next dinner, however we are thinking of starting something new because we feel there is a ceiling to what we can achieve with our current startup and its important for us to decide what startup to do next if we actually are heading into a bubble that may pop midway through our next project, 1,2 maybe 3 years down the line What do you guys think the tech scene will look like in the valley and possibly around the world if such an event would occur again ? Sorry for the long post but i thought it important to get ideas from the HN community on this topic.
- paulsutter 15y agoPeople didn't die in the last collapse, my goodness. Many of them went back to banking (B2B) or back to Cleveland (B2C). Nobody was F*'d, although there was a lot of self-centered melodrama. The same thing will happen again and again. Areas of the economy will get overheated, and subsequently get overcooled. Fortunes will be made, fortunes will be lost. And in the end it's just life as usual.
- capsule_toy 15y agoI don't think it'll be as bad. There is much more adoption of technology in every business today than back then. I know plenty of profitable small businesses looking for developers and having no luck. I can't imagine all these jobs in unrelated industries not being there just because the SoLoMo bubble pops.