5 ms·
Children born, raised during lockdown developing language skills at slower rate
- oopsthrowpass 3y ago[flagged]
- ragestorm 3y agoIf my Spanish translator is correct, roughly a little over half of the n=150ish participants developed at a slower rate.
- nostrademons 3y agoIsn't that roughly what you would expect anyway? 50% of the population is below the median. Take a separate population and measure them against the overall median, and simply through statistical chance, a good number of those samples will have an average slower than the median.
- doublemint2203 3y agoover half developed in a statistically significant way that is lower than the expected "bottom half"
- micromacrofoot 3y agothey were out doing whatever their parents were doing and/or people were visiting... they missed almost a whole year of that, and even "post-pandemic" people are sometimes more hesitant about being inside public or crowded spaces like they were previously (especially say, if you have an unvaccinated 5 month old)
- dang 3y ago"Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith." "Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something." "Don't be snarky." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- tweedledot 3y ago[flagged]
- mlinhares 3y ago[flagged]
- tweedledot 3y agoI don’t follow - why?
- dang 3y agoPlease don't cross into personal attack.
- smokeydoe 3y agoI saw a lot of babies playing with a smartphone pre-covid
- tweedledot 3y agoAt least where I live (UK) I didn’t. I didn’t realise my observation would be so controversial.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoMany parents use tablets/phones as pacifiers at restaurants / similar venues. If you weren't judging them for using technological pacifier, you'd probably be judging them for bringing a noisy kid into a restaurant. It's quite possible that the kid rarely gets to use a phone at home where it's acceptable to act like a kid.
- tweedledot 3y agoI don’t think that a parent’s desire to go to a particular restaurant at a particular time justifies using mind-numbing pacifiers on their kids. I say this as a parent of young children. We solve this by taking our kids to appropriate venues at appropriate times.
- purrcat259 3y agoMy first was six weeks old when lockdown hit. She spent nearly the first two years of her life with just my wife and I. We always resolved to speak to her as an adult would and only used YouTube videos which encouraged speech and some signing (look up Miss Rachel to get an idea). She's now way ahead of most of her peers in terms of speech. I'm sometimes still surprised with how she manages to communicate with us. Just my n=1 experience.
- ejb999 3y agothat is great (no sarcasm) - but I also don't think it is unusual for a <2 year old to spend almost all time with just one or both of the parents. I think the kids that had already in school that were the most affected.
- diogenescynic 3y agoVery similar experience here. My daughter got a ton of 1:1 time during lockdowns and now speaks a lot more articulately than other kids her age (sometimes even a few years older). I suspect this study is more about how people used the lockdown to either spend more or less time with their kids.
- wakkawakkawakka 3y agoMy daughter was born 6 months into the lockdowns. At her 15 months checkup, the doctors were seriously concerned that she wasn't speaking at least 5 words (she had 3 down). They believed that she might have trouble hearing and wanted to refer her for more testing. I told them that her hearing was just fine and that testing wasn't necessary. "How could you be sure?", they argued. I told them that she has no problem paying attention and reacting to her dad and I when spoken to. I told them that she has favourite songs that she loved to dance to and that she could hear them when the music was being played in different rooms, let alone different floors in our house. They weren't convinced and started gaslighting me into enrolling her into testing, telling me that the wait to see any specialist was at least 3 months and the longer I waited the worst the issue would be and that my daughters ability to hear properly was solely resting on my decision to not to refer her. I then asked the doctor and nurse if they had children (which I knew they didn't, just by observing how they interacted with my daughter). They confirmed that they didn't and I proceeded to tell them that my parental instinct trumps their authority on the issue. Long story short, she doesn't shut up now. She's leaps and bounds ahead of her peers when it comes to vocabulary and she loves music and dancing.
- 0xy 3y agoWhile obvious at the time to anyone with a brain, it's now beyond obvious that lockdowns were an abject disaster. Massive economic damage that's continuing to linger, irreversible damage to children and an entire lost generation raised during the lockdowns. How could anyone but the most hysterical hypochondriacs still support them?
- doublemint2203 3y agothey empirically saved lives and were based on the best available scientific recommendations at the time. Their factual basis is not a matter of opinion. Whether the opportunity cost of risking lives outweighed the cost of re-opening, second lockdowns, etc. is a whole different topic, but if you're speaking to the first "two week lockdown" then it is no question.
- Mountain_Skies 3y ago>were based on the best available scientific recommendations at the time That's a statement of faith. >Their factual basis is not a matter of opinion. Another statement of faith.
- bodhi_mind 3y ago>That's a statement of faith. Aren’t all decisions based on probability and statistics (science and medicine) “faith” based?
- wyager 3y ago> were based on the best available scientific recommendations at the time "Best" is doing a lot of heavy lifting in this sentence. A more objective description might be "most widely expressed".
- doublemint2203 3y agofurther, if your last question is not rhetorical, I support them in retrospect because I view things from an apolitical lens and think it was the best attempt at a societal cooperation to save lives. Yes, there were negative results, but there were also overflowing hospitals in 99.9% of the country
- k__ 3y agoI know a middle school teacher. He said they got a bunch of kids from elementary school that don't know anything. Especially from poorer families, that have several kids but didn't have enough rooms for pandemic remote schooling.
- tweedledot 3y agoThe statistics for where I live (Wales, UK) show a horrifying post-COVID gap in school attendance for socioeconomically deprived families. We have probably lost the cultural norm that all kids at least attend school.
- alphabettsy 3y agoIs it more than usual?
- k__ 3y agoQuite so.
- jgalt212 3y agoYep, the investor class got $5 trillion, but regular people in the aggregate got a raw deal. If the Fed hadn't printed all this money, the investor class would have fought harder to open up the schools and restore Western society. But they were just fine sitting sitting at home counting their non universal generational income. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WALCL https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WALCL
- thoughtstheseus 3y agoIt’s weird thinking the public policy measures enacted during the pandemic were designed to make wealthy people more wealthy and increase consumption of goods and services. We had a chance to use the pandemic to fortify our society against future challenges. Instead we’ve made our communities more fragile and more vulnerable to future shocks.
- tweedledot 3y agoIndeed. No conspiracy theory is needed - people took every opportunity to acquire power and wealth, and the already powerful and wealthy were the most equipped to do so.
- jgalt212 3y agonever let a good crisis go to waste was a mantra of many groups during the pandemic.
- amanaplanacanal 3y agoUnfortunately, due to the way this study is designed, there is no way to separate the effects of lockdown from the effects of the pandemic itself. It would be interested to compare areas with mandatory lockdown policies to areas without, but that’s not what they did here.
- helsinki 3y agoI have a lockdown baby, whom is 3.5 years old, now. Her language skills are great. However, they seemed to experience exponential growth, roughly one month after she started going to public school.
- black_13 3y ago[dead]