4 ms·
When people are suffering physically from the effects of lack of iodine, isn't it rather Western to consider raised intelligence the most talkworthy improvement
by petercooper 18y ago
When people are suffering physically from the effects of lack of iodine, isn't it rather Western to consider raised intelligence the most talkworthy improvement!? Iodized water should be used to make people's lives better and reduce their pain - not to increase their intelligence by some token amount. Increasing intelligence is a weird motivation to help people in dire straits - how about helping people because it's the decent, human thing to do?
An educated guess is that iodine deficiency results in a
needless loss of more than 1 billion I.Q. points around
the world.
The prevalence of TV and gossip magazines in our culture are responsible for a lot more than that. I don't see a big crusade to fix that.
The point this article makes is as meaningless as Shirky's assertions that our "cognitive surplus" equates to a million Wikipedias we haven't written or whatever. If billions of people in the developing world gain some intelligence, great, but I doubt it'll be as much use as making their lives better and more pain free so they can use the plentiful intelligence they already have (I don't subscribe to the argument that the poor are any less intelligent - they just have fewer opportunities).
- _h4xr 18y agoisn't it rather Western to consider raised intelligence the most talkworthy improvement!? I assume you're using "Western" to mean something very racist and vile, like "analyzing the data rationally and coming to the most sensible conclusion." You are unfairly assuming that only Europeans can look at the correlation between IQ and income, or IQ and crime, or whatever. Obviously, the Japanese (IQ 105, crime 5% to 10% of that in the US) or South Koreans (IQ 106, crime rate about 15% of what it is in the US) can look at these data, too, and hope that the rest of the world catches up. The prevalence of TV and gossip magazines in our culture are responsible for a lot more than that. I don't see a big crusade to fix that. Probably because you haven't read about how hard it is to change IQ. Nutrition is one of the only things that can measurably affect IQ in the long run. The other one -- the big one, accounting for 40-80% of all IQ variation -- is genetics. On the other hand, stupid but happy people are probably easier to control.
- petercooper 18y agoI assume you're using "Western" to mean something very racist and vile, like "analyzing the data rationally and coming to the most sensible conclusion." You are unfairly assuming that only Europeans can look at the correlation between IQ and income, or IQ and crime, or whatever. You assume wrong. I did not make the assertions or assumptions you assume. How is "Western" racist? People of all races (except for, perhaps, those of certain indigenous peoples) make up the West and hold Western opinions. And since when were all Western people "European"? It's disturbing that HN has gotten to the point where people are unfairly assumed to be making "racist and vile" statements with nothing to back it up. Shame on you.
- _h4xr 18y agoI'm sorry my sarcasm was not more apparent. My point was that raising IQ would do a lot of good for those people -- more than reducing their pain, in the long term. High IQ groups tend to create stable states and nice places to live, and they're also responsible for a lot of technological advancement. My sub-point was that often the same people uncomfortable with this kind of talk are down on Western culture in particular.
- petercooper 18y agoMy point was that raising IQ would do a lot of good for those people -- more than reducing their pain, in the long term. Would you argue, then, that instead of sending food and medical aid to poor countries, we should send teachers? I'm not buying your argument. Raised IQ does correlate with improved quality of life but the poorest people in the world have more serious problems we could be helping with first such as actually staying alive. And accusing someone of holding racist and vile views is sarcasm - the lowest form of wit? I wish I could call that a good defense.
- _h4xr 18y agoWould you argue, then, that instead of sending food and medical aid to poor countries, we should send teachers? Teachers do not raise IQ. Proper nutrition does. And accusing someone of holding racist and vile views is sarcasm - the lowest form of wit? Okay, read through the comment I made. I am sorry this is unclear, but I am being very sarcastic. I know you are saying that it is Western to want to raise IQ rather than reduce pain; I am saying that this is, in fact the right thing to do and thus that you are using "Western" to mean "logical and sensible" -- and then I say what I'm guessing you would say to someone who said "His views are very Western -- that is, logical, and sensible, and not driven by emotion or ignorance." That is the joke: that you accidentally said something nice about Western culture, and that had someone else said that to you and meant it, you would likely have been annoyed. I am sorry about that. Frog dissection, etc.
- newsycaccount 18y agoBecause having higher I.Q.'s via Iodine couldn't possibly allow them to get more doctors per capita and reduce pain and suffering that way. Let me guess, you didn't get much Iodine as a kid.
- Prrometheus 18y agoIt may be that social institutions are shaped by the intelligence of the people who form them and control them. All else being equal, having a higher IQ population is probably a good thing. It probably leads to more long-term planning, capital investment, and other good things. Helping people in most ways are not mutually exclusive.
- randomwalker 18y agoIf only you'd spent half the time RTFA'ing as you did arguing. The goal is to prevent mental retardation, not create Einsteins. They're measuring success in terms of increase in IQ. Or are you actually claiming that preventing mental retardation is not important?
- MikeCapone 18y agoIf you want to help, here's the Canadian non-profit he talks about: http://www.micronutrient.org/english/view.asp?x=1 http://www.micronutrient.org/english/view.asp?x=1
- cabalamat 18y ago> The goal is to prevent mental retardation, not create Einsteins. I think it will do both, because iodine deficiency probably works across the board: Someone who would otherwise be a genius may be reduced, by iodine deficiency, to being merely quite bright. Someone who would be quite bright is reduced to merely average. And someone who would be a bit thick is reduced to being retarded. So by preventing mental retardation, they're also creating Einsteins. A win-win situation.
- MikeCapone 18y agoThat's a good point. What if Einstein's mother had be deficient in folic acid and iodine while pregnant?
- nazgulnarsil 18y agobecause raising overall intelligence is the only long term solution to the problems of the world.
- nazgulnarsil 18y agoIt is the only time that violating the prime directive is good because raising intelligence is a universal good. there is no way for raising intelligence to backfire that I can think of....I guess the atomic bomb would be one argument, but we already have those.
- MikeCapone 18y agoWhy is this even controversial? Fetuses, babies, and children need certain nutrients to grow healthy. Vitamin A, Zinc, Iron, Folic Acid, etc.. Iodine has to do with good brain development, vit A with eyes (among other things), etc. What's the problem? It's elitist and western to think that people should have a chance to grow up healthy? And to think that this will lead to better outcomes on average?
- cabalamat 18y ago> When people are suffering physically from the effects of lack of iodine, isn't it rather Western to consider raised intelligence the most talkworthy improvement!? Iodized water should be used to make people's lives better and reduce their pain - not to increase their intelligence by some token amount If it was just a "token amount" I'd agree with you. But it isn't. Half a billion people in India suffer from Iodine deficiency (source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iodine_deficiency#Local_impact http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iodine_deficiency#Local_impact ) If half a country's population have reduced intelligence of about 10 IQ points because of this, then obviously that country's economy will suffer. If India had had no iodine deficiency since independence in 1948 it might be as rich as South Korea today -- it would certainly be richer than it is. People in poor countries have IQ scores (as callibrated using Western norms) of 70 or so. (source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IQ_and_race#Worldwide http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IQ_and_race#Worldwide ) Partly this is due to social differences, i.e. growing up in an environment where there are less problems like IQ tests. But partly also it is genuinely due to lower intelligence. If in those countries you ended chronic undernutrition, ended lack of micronutrients, ended cousin marriages, improved sewers, hygeine and basic healthcare, these people would grow up with IQs similar to those in the western world. This would lead to their economies becoming richer. So it isn't just a "token amount" it's a big fucking deal.
- sethg 18y agoI'm sure there is at least one imam who read that article and thought, "If the Muslims of the Third World didn't have such nutritional deficiencies, then they could learn more of the Quran."