5 ms·
IBM has a fondness for complexity that makes the current situation with cloud offerings look like children's toys. Their Global Services division could be summ
by hinkley 3y ago
IBM has a fondness for complexity that makes the current situation with cloud offerings look like children's toys.
Their Global Services division could be summarized as a War on Kernighan's Law. Find clever people, and have them strain themselves to stand up a system so complex that you not only need to keep paying GS to show up and maintain it, but in fact you probably need to hire two more people just to keep the wheels on.
That has made them many enemies on the technical side of things. People like me go out of our ways to sabotage any inroads they try to make because we know what will happen if we don't. Presentations of systems so complex you get a headache trying to wrap your mind around it.
If we talk about it, it's not for long and with as few ears to overhear as possible. It's like guerilla warfare. Targeted attacks against a foe who could crush you like a bug if they knew where to find you.
Oracle sniffing around is merely an irritation compared to the spectre of IBM GS getting their hooks into your CTO.
- gtirloni 3y agoMaking thing simpler is hard. Any technical excellence at IBM is probably an island and definitely doesn't represent the rest of the company. In my time there, only one thing mattered: head count (or more precisely, body count). It didn't matter if those heads could think. It was all about closing outsourcing contracts and making a profit. With the occasional sprinkle of Watson propaganda sprinkled on top to make it look like you were at the pinnacle of computing. I'm surprised IBM still exists. I can't remember a single company that I worked for where IBM would have helped anything.
- hinkley 3y agoIBM isn’t just accidentally leaving things complex, they sell tools that fix problems almost nobody has. What’s that XML RPC gateway they were peddling years ago? Jesus Christ just use nginx and learn to manage certs.
- saiya-jin 3y ago'Fond' memories for monstrosities like Websphere or MQ servers. Take trivial JMS or less-trivial-but-grokkable J2EE spec, add 10x more ultra-proprietary stuff that is very complex to grok compared to original spec, solves little on top in real world, makes you utterly vendor-locked in for every app until complete rewrite. You need additional Eclipse-based apps to work with it at all, and IIRC they were costly as hell too. Rinse and repeat. Then there was Weblogic, that worked as well and mostly by standards. Devs I met everywhere loved it.
- meepmorp 3y ago> Take trivial JMS or less-trivial-but-grokkable J2EE spec, MQSeries predates Java itself and started out on MVS; it was already the way it is when the JMS spec was developed. There's no real excuse for WebSphere, though.
- twisteriffic 3y agoFrom painful personal experience there are about 3 people in all of IBM who understand PKI well enough to configure a server.
- hinkley 3y agoMaybe it's because I have very good spatial intelligence, but I always found PKI to be a lot simpler than most people made it out to be. People treating me like some sort of priest of the church of crypto when generating and signing keys is really not that hard. PKI is like a kitchen knife. The hard part is not getting one, or picking it up, it's using it without cutting yourself. But people treat the 'knife' like all aspects are magical.
- bbkane 3y agoI've found it ok to understand maybe 70% of PKI, but that I always need to review that last 30% (OSCP stapling, cross signing certs, whatever the heck the formats are, different extensions, more that I'm forgetting). I've put my favorite learning resources and tools into https://www.bbkane.com/blog/learn-ssl/ https://www.bbkane.com/blog/learn-ssl/
- eropple 3y agoI was at IBM for about five months, a few years ago. It took from ~2 weeks after my start date until ~1 week before my last day to get a vSphere cluster provisioned for my development work. PKI? Sounds hard, by comparison.
- twisteriffic 3y agoProbably outsourced internal dev environments to Kyndryl too?
- eropple 3y agoSurprisingly no, not for this project. It was an acquisition, and the developers had come with - so had their data center. I was hired to try to help move it out of their on-prem location. They'd hired me specifically saying it was going to AWS; then they went "whoops! all IBM Cloud" a couple weeks in, and they never actually got me a fully working environment to build against in the few months I was there. (The one nice thing I'd say is that teams from all over IBM were incredibly helpful; some externally-facing consultants actually volunteered a couple hours to try to help undo whatever Softlayer had open-palm slammed onto my virtual machines. They too were confused.)
- gregw134 3y agoLLMs are sure going to make the Watson advertising look outdated.
- nnurmanov 3y agoIBM is offering a Cobol to Java migration service and it is based on LLM (watsonx). Will it save them?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- internet101010 3y ago> Find clever people, and have them strain themselves to stand up a system so complex that you not only need to keep paying GS to show up and maintain it, but in fact you probably need to hire two more people just to keep the wheels on. AS/400 can still be found in the checkout line at Costco. I don't think it is the main POS system but is used for things like looking up customer information. IIRC Oracle is taking a lot of that retailer backend business now.
- wharvle 3y agoYou point out Oracle as akin (but less entirely awful). I'd throw Palantir on the pile. Sell management on bullshit, then, once they've got their hooks in, it turns out they'll need to be way up your ass (and billing the whole time) to make any of it happen, and the entire process will be miserable. Another candidate for "begin insurgent activities as soon as the name is overheard" responses.
- ido 3y agoWho would be a good name to suggest? I can’t imagine SAP would do a good job at it either.
- btian 3y agoAWS I suppose
- wharvle 3y agoVersus Palantir, I think was the intent of the question. IDK, from what I've seen they can't really do much more out-of-the-box than lots of other less-bullshitty data platforms, they're just far more aggressive about selling "consulting" services to get you all the features they told you they could do (and they can—with a bunch of custom development, just like any other platform)
- eadmund 3y agoI wouldn’t suggest a competitor in that line of business, because it’s not a line of business which should exist: fundamentally, it represents a firm wanting to bring in another firm to engage in its core line of business for it, because it no longer knows how to. Well, if the firm doesn’t know how to engage in its core business, just fire the employees, close the offices, take the names off the buildings and return the capital to the owners!
- hinkley 3y agoHow could anyone who has read or seen The Lord of the Rings think that a Palantir was anything but an existential threat? Not all of the lost seeing stones have been accounted for. We don’t know who else may be listening.
- cmrdporcupine 3y agoThe worst quality software I ever worked on as a software developer was an unholy mess of baldy indented, copy & pasted PL/SQL, spaghetti code JSPs, and dubious code generally ... written by IBM contractors (around Y2K timeframe). Luckily the CTO was smart enough to hire our own team to build and maintain it (and eventually rewrite it) rather than have IBM maintain it for $$$$. I once saw the original architecture document and it was actually very nice -- though perhaps unorthodox. The implementation was like an encyclopedia of Worst Practices. I also worked a summer for IBM Global Services doing some sysadmin and security work back in 1997... I'd characterize the whole thing as... mediocrity. Another time, I worked a contract in another part of IBM and saw other parts and got to attend presentations and lectures there and see the patents on the walls, and be exposed to some of the really smart people and history there, and that product side of the organization (people who worked on DB2, etc.) seemed much better.
- hinkley 3y agoI’m old enough to have encountered Netscape contractors. The kid they sent to us, at $250/hr (that’s $470 inflation adjusted) no less, had the manual open in his lap. I’m pretty sure they were taught never to get caught doing that. If memory serves I helped our IT guy replace the whole mess with Apache, so we’d never have to talk to them again. I used to compete with Netscape so there was no small amusement in costing them contractor hours.
- bluGill 3y ago> I’m pretty sure they were taught never to get caught doing that. I've long ago learned that people misremember all the time. I trust the person who quickly looks up the correct answer in the manual over the person who thinks they din't need the manual and uses what they think is right. Sure often the second person gets things right, but when they get it wrong they waste a lot of time trying to figure out which thing is wrong.
- ghaff 3y agoYeah. It's one thing if they obviously don't have the slightest clue. But if someone sort of knows how to do something or even thinks they know how, I'm not going to begrudge them checking a manual.
- latchkey 3y agoMy last CEO was ex-IBM. He was pissed when we (his technical team), nixed his attempt to do a storage related deal with IBM. We went through endless meetings with dozens of people on the calls. They wanted to bring in some giant complex product and we just wanted boxes with disks. They couldn't understand that we didn't need all the striping tools they had, because our storage was just using full multiple copies across servers/disks. It was a total square peg / round hole situation and their sales team tactics were to try to discredit people individually with what amounted to as being complete lies. It really put a bad taste in my mouth to ever deal with those type of people again.
- Deprecate9151 3y agoI was at a company where that exec won. In this case it was the Infosphere suite to replace a fully mature Informatica/Teradata environment and fix all the "issues". Obviously the issues were all design and management, not technical. 3 years a tens of millions later the whole project is shut down with no value delivered except a single data store and a couple API endpoints. That exec went back to his IBM sales job. Last I heard they were still paying for and maintaining all of it because that endpoint was used in a key product offering.
- blastro 3y agoThis is like one of those "horror stories in 2 sentences" type things.
- sys_64738 3y agoMost ex-IBMers want to "go home" in some form. It's some bizarre rationale about returning to the mothership when they were actually jettisoned. Don't get me wrong, working at IBM in the 90s was fascinating but a lot of them only had careers there.
- ghaff 3y agoI've known and know a not insignificant number of IBMers who were there on the order of 30 years. I've tended to stay in most jobs a fairly long time (decade plus or minus) but nothing like that. A former manager at another fairly old-line company, it will presumably be the only company he will have ever worked for--albeit through a couple acquisitions and some stuff during dot-bomb.
- jghn 3y agoYears ago I worked for IBM, and have dealt with them in various contexts since. The thing I've found that best captures the essence of IBM is how they love bringing *everyone* to every meeting, and then insist on full introductions. Every time. I've been on a few different projects where we would routinely chew up 20 minutes of a 30 minute call hearing every last one of them announce their name and role. Thanks folks, I already know who you are. Can we talk about the project now?
- hinkley 3y agoOn the clock of course. My last interaction with them, I remember they kept claiming the sky was falling (aka schedule slip) if we didn’t rework the library to do exactly the API they worked out before any line of code was written and with no input from the four other teams that needed to consume it. This culminated in 2 of our leads sitting in a room with a giant table, in a meeting of what had to be ten people at least, for three hours one afternoon while we dictated pseudocode and sequence diagrams for their next three months’ of work (if you can describe a month of work in an hour, it’s really not as complex as people are making it out to be) So we paid six or seven of them to listen while we did half of their job for them, with our two most expensive employees.
- pram 3y agoThis made me laugh hard. When I worked at Oracle they’d do this in internal meetings if it was outside your immediate team! A dozen people saying “I am a System Analyst II for Managed Services” like goddamn who fucking cares
- hinkley 3y agoI had a boss who was making giving me a lead position into a bigger deal than it needed to be. Like he wanted me and one of my peers to be secret leads before he announced it formally. The entire situation was odd. I told him I didn't care what he called me, what mattered is whether people would listen to me when I asked them to do stuff, like use a better solution to a problem. If you want to be a lead, you have to do a lot of that yourself. But I was young (1st lead position) and his lack of backing that up were making it all more complicated than it needed to be. Made all the weirder by the fact that he was good at selling people on ideas, to a fault (it took me 3 tries to quit that job, he was such a smooth talker)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hnthrowaway0315 3y agoI have a feeling that IBM, including all those pre-80 behemoths, are more like civil servants -- they always remind me of Sir Humphrey with tons of formality, planning and such. Maybe it's because they hired from academies heavily and actually did work on a lot of government projects? Since this is the real "engineering" spirit that HNs love, I'm not going to argue. But I definitely prefer SpaceX' run and break things spirit.