7 ms·
How museum items go missing
- bradley13 3y agoHistory happened. The British Empire was. In the historical context of the time, the objects were legitimate acquisitions. It's much like the historical fact of nations going to war and conquering and enslaving each other. If someone wants to return parts of the US to the Cherokee, then we should also return much of Europe to the Picts. How far back do you go? Somehow, though, we only have this existential anguish about the last couple of rounds of conquest. History happened. Let it be. If conquest doesn't match our modern values, then we can choose to avoid starting any new wars of conquest. Sadly, human nature doesn't seem to have actually changed: Wikipedia currently lists 56 ongoing armed conflicts.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- yard2010 3y agoI think you're missing the point - the reasons to return stuff like these are not practical but symbolic
- rbanffy 3y agoThis is not about land ownership, but historical artifacts. Acts of good will can go a long way towards strengthening the friendly relationships between two peoples.
- GaryNumanVevo 3y agoShould ISIS not give back all the historical Christian artifacts that they looted?
- defrost 3y agoISIS largely destroyed artifacts with explosives and bulldozers and the Christian sites were almost the least of it; In 2014, media reported destruction of multiple religious buildings belonging to both Sunni and Shia sects throughout areas captured by IS. Among them were the tomb of Ibn al-Athir, Imam Abbas Mosque in Mosul, the Sheikh Jawad Al-Sadiq Mosque, Tomb of Sayyid Ar-Mamut Baba, Qaddo Mosque, Martyrs' Mosque, Saad Ibn Aqeel Shrine in Tal Afar, the Sufi Ahmed al-Rifai Shrine and Sheikh Ibrahim's shrine in Mahlabiya District. Very old pre Christian sites were also destroyed, but more often looted to sell to collectors to raise money: In May 2014, IS members smashed a 3,000-year-old neo-Assyrian statue from Tel Ajaja. Later reports indicated that over 40% of the artifacts at Tel Ajaja (Saddikanni) were looted by IS. There's a pretty sizable list of what they destroyed and looted in: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Destruction_of_cultural_heritage_by_the_Islamic_State https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Destruction_of_cultural_herita... the group released photos of militants rigging the 1,900-year-old Temple of Baalshamin with explosives and blowing it up. It was one of Palmyra’s best-preserved buildings, originally dedicated to a Phoenician storm god. Now it is nothing but rubble. https://www.nationalgeographic.co.uk/history-and-civilisation/2017/11/ancient-sites-damaged-and-destroyed-by-isis https://www.nationalgeographic.co.uk/history-and-civilisatio...
- amiga386 3y agoSo, the question is, if some usurper takes over a region and becomes de-facto government in that region... and you have artifacts _from_ that region that you took with the legal authority of the previous government... would you hand the artifacts over to the usurpers?
- defrost 3y ago> In the historical context of the time, the objects were legitimate acquisitions. Nonsense. Many of the historic aquisitions by "collectors" were as sketchy AF in the context of the times. The Elgin marbles, for example, were removed from Greece by an English lord and an Italian painter while Greece was under Ottoman rule .. The legality of this was questionable at best and a House of Commons Select Committee held public hearings on whether Elgin had acted within the law - many considered he had not. Given this hearing ocuurred well after the fact, the damage was done, and the booty was now in England being sold for a song it was all rather swept under the carpet. A thief is a thief ... unless they are a Lord. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elgin_Marbles#Acquisition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elgin_Marbles#Acquisition The Benin Bronzes and other related artifacts were straight up targeted theft as a by product of war - if might makes right then they were legitimate, otherwise they're on the same footing as objects stolen by armed invaders that kill half your family and set your house on fire. https://www.nationalgeographic.co.uk/travel/2022/09/benin-bronzes-return-to-nigeria https://www.nationalgeographic.co.uk/travel/2022/09/benin-br...
- karencarits 3y agoAccording to the Wikipedia article, he did get approval from state officials although it is hard to interpret if he went beyond the approval. However, the Committee you mentioned > cleared Elgin of all allegations that he had acquired the marbles illegally or had misused his powers as ambassador
- defrost 3y agoAs I said, the legality was sketchy AF. Dodgy enough that a pubic inquiry was held, and sketchy in that a British Lord and ambassador was cleared when anybody else would be facing punishment.
- sandworm101 3y ago>> Thief is a thief ... unless they are a Lord. So he wasnt a thief. The laws of the time ebbed and flowed based on the social standing of the alleged perpetrators. That was the then accepted rule. It is less true today but not absolutely. Who are we to ignore the actions of a past select committee? Are we to revisit every not-guilty decisison on the basis that a modern investigation would have acted differently? By way of example, women were in the past treated very badly. Revisiting every historic legal determination that stripped a woman of her propery would render all modern property rights suspect.
- karencarits 3y agoAlso, should protestant countries return "stolen" goods back to the Catholic church? Art, churches, monasteries, land, cathedrals, relics, ...
- truculent 3y ago> If someone wants to return parts of the US to the Cherokee, then we should also return much of Europe to the Picts 1. Land is not an object held in a museum 2. There are over 300,000 enrolled tribal members of the Cherokee Nation (per Wikipedia). There are ~0 Picts, as far as I know. Obviously the effects of more recent rounds of conquest are more apparent and felt more keenly by those suffering as a result. > History happened. Let it be. Sure, but if someone wants to let it be, how long before we let the present turn into history? It's just raising the same question you dismissed!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- AussieWog93 3y ago>2. There are over 300,000 enrolled tribal members of the Cherokee Nation (per Wikipedia). There are ~0 Picts, as far as I know. Be careful with that logic! If we agree as a species that surviving conquered people have a right to reclaim their land and assets, but extinct ones don't, then the obvious course of action for the conquering force is to simply exterminate every native mercilessly.
- sarchertech 3y ago>There are over 300,000 enrolled tribal members of the Cherokee Nation (per Wikipedia). There are ~0 Picts, as far as I know. So what part of the US do we return to the Cherokee? The parts the US gave them when they forced them out of the South East? Or their original territory? My hometown was originally populated by a separate tribe. The Cherokee came later. How do we split the land between the Eastern and Western bands of Cherokee? To a large extent, the borders of the various tribes that are still existent today are a result of their interactions with the European colonial powers. So the "political map" of the US in 1794, looks vastly different than it did in 1720. The current map is entirely arbitrary and unfairly benefits some groups over others. But picking any other historical map is also entirely arbitrary. There's no way to go back and pick the "correct" one.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rmason 3y agoOne of the saddest stories I ever heard happened in Detroit. Ernie Harwell was the legendary play by play announcer for the Detroit Tigers. He started his announcing career in Georgia and began collecting baseball memorabilia in the forties when no one much was interested in it. He became the guy to call when a retired player needed money or the one the widow called when a player passed away. He amassed a huge collection, second only to the Baseball Hall of Fame. At the end of his life he faced with what to do with his collection. His favorite nephew worked for the Detroit Public library and convinced him to leave it to them in his will so he did. At the time he passed away the library had closed most of its branches and was terribly understaffed. They made the collection viewable by appointment only. In the first six months one or more of those viewers walked out the door with the most valuable items and sold them on the black market to willing collectors. Did the library hire a private detective to try and find out who did the thefts and attempt to recover the items? The answer is no they didn't. The thefts were reported to the even more understaffed Detroit police who took the report and did not conduct any investigation. There should be a public museum near Tiger stadium that would be a huge tourist attraction but there is not. Currently I do not think you can even get a reservation to view the collection. https://www.nbcsports.com/mlb/news/ernie-harwells-memorabilia-collection-is-at-risk https://www.nbcsports.com/mlb/news/ernie-harwells-memorabili... https://www.liveauctioneers.com/news/top-news/collectiblesandpopculture/late-broadcasters-baseball-collection-languishes-at-library/ https://www.liveauctioneers.com/news/top-news/collectiblesan...
- caminante 3y ago> A former librarian said many boxes of artifacts are stored — but uncatalogued — in the basement, meaning it is difficult to know if items have been removed. [0] Well, if the donor isn't going to inventory the goods, then expectations should be low. Did his nephew not have a clue? This is like never checking the data backup. Either it's not that valuable, or you're negligent. [0] https://www.mlive.com/news/detroit/2011/06/report_ernie_harwell_collectio.html https://www.mlive.com/news/detroit/2011/06/report_ernie_harw...
- crazygringo 3y agoI think you're supposed to assume that it's the library that will do the cataloguing. But at the same time, you're supposed to do your research to make sure the institution you want to donate your collection to has the capability and capacity to properly care for it and make it both secure and accessible. Just because it's a local library doesn't mean they can.
- xchip 3y ago[flagged]
- xchip 3y ago[flagged]
- guessmyname 3y agoI did not downvote your post, but I think the person who did may want to discourage using ChatGPT for summarizing articles. Instead, they might be encouraging others to read the stories themselves and form their own summaries and opinions based on their understanding.
- xchip 3y agoI never realized summarizing an article could be so offensive.
- pvg 3y agoIt's not offensive but generated comments are not allowed on HN because they doesn't fit its purpose. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=by%3Adang%20%22generated%20comments%22&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
- Aurornis 3y agoThe article isn’t really about how museum items go missing - There’s only a brief mention of one curator who stole objects. That anecdote is used as a bridge to the author’s real motivation, which is arguing that museums shouldn’t hold items from other countries or cultures or locations. It’s a concept similar to “cultural appropriation” applied to the existence of museums based on their location. The author thinks the story of a single museum staff thief undermines the entire concept of museums holding items from other countries or cultures: > The irony here is palpable: An institution infamous for displaying looted colonial artifacts had objects stolen by a staff member. > One of the principal justifications museums often give for denying the restitution and repatriation of cultural objects is the purported need to safeguard the material within the institutions. The recent thefts contradict this argument I have some friends with history degrees who have spent their careers in museums and museum curation. There is a lot of consensus that museum items with obvious history such as art stolen by Nazis should be returned to right those historical wrongs. That’s not a hard argument to make. However, some people take the argument much further like this author hints at, believing that museums need to return everything that doesn’t match the historic and cultural heritage of their location. The only items allowed to remain would be perfectly documented acquisitions that nobody could find issue with. So dismantle the Louvre and other museums and send everything back to countries it came from, preferring to right some historical injustice over preserving history in a museum. If someone wants to see the history of that country, they’d have to go there themselves and travel to each museum (assuming it exists). It’s not a realistic goal, which has created a stalemate where the proponents of this idea are more about discussing these injustices and making them the central issue of museums, often equating high profile cases like art stolen by Nazis as morally equivalent to a display of 1000 year old pottery fragments. It’s tiring and detracts from the real work that museum staff do.
- ytdytvhxgydvhh 3y agoThere’s an interesting one of these brewing regarding a gold-laden shipwreck: > A US salvage company argue they first found the wreck in 1981 and made a deal with the Colombia government so they could have half of the treasure when it was recovered. But there have been other claims to the treasure including Spain and Bolivia's indigenous Qhara Qhara nation, which say the Spanish took the wealth from their people. https://www.bbc.co.uk/newsround/67342273 https://www.bbc.co.uk/newsround/67342273
- beebeepka 3y agoSometimes I fantasize about breaking into the fancy UK and US museums just to give it back to counties it was stolen from.
- ooterness 3y agoThere's a game just for you: "It belongs in an ancient ruin" https://games.digipen.edu/games/it-belongs-in-an-ancient-ruin https://games.digipen.edu/games/it-belongs-in-an-ancient-rui... The protagonist must break into museums (guarded by robots and alarms), steal artifacts, and return them to ancient ruins (protected by monsters and traps).
- wredcoll 3y agoAre you also going to give back all the iron we bought that was originally dug up in another country?
- beebeepka 3y agoI said stolen artifacs. How is that the same as buying iron from another country.
- DiscourseFan 3y agoI think, as others have mentioned, there is an implicit ethnonationalism here in linking various governments, specifically post-colonial states (say Nigeria) with the tribes that live in them. Now, its important to note two things here. 1) many of these tribes, before colonialism, before the establishment of the contemporary west-african states, were in fact slave empires, and the reason they had such rich cultural products was for the same reason that western nations, at the time, did. So the moral status of those objects is ambiguous at best, which leads to point 2) that these objects should be stored in whatever facility can host them best. We all admit Nigeria is not as wealthy as the UK, so its entirely possible that the UK after returning perhaps, thousands of precious artifacts, worth an uncountable sum, a desperate government might, given the right circumstances, sell them, whereas the UK probably will not (at least not in the near future). Call me conservative if you like, but culturally important objects are often only designated as such the moment they are placed in a museum. Who knows if the former slave empire tribes of west Africa would've valued all the pieces so highly had they not been put on display. By "getting them back," these ethnic groups are merely reproducing the same order that they oppose, in fact they have completed, in a way, the colonial circuit, by becoming a mirror of the power that created them.
- throwawaytwit9 3y agoThis is an absurd argument. It reads as a self serving rationalization of cultural appropriation. They didn’t value what they had and can’t be trusted with it today. As if the only option is to give objects back to poor or corrupt governments. Even if true that doesn’t mean people are undeserving of their past. How about strengthening local non-governmental institutions to care for these objects?
- jterrys 3y ago>As if the only option is to give objects back to poor or corrupt governments. Even if true that doesn’t mean people are undeserving of their past. How about strengthening local non-governmental institutions to care for these objects? Right, and if that doesn't work, or until that works, is it morally objectionable to hold on to those objects? Is it truly the right thing to return items to governments that can't guarantee their safety or don't hold those items to the same values? What's the better choice here? Preserving anthropological history of mankind or respecting the wishes of hereditary descendants? What if they don't give a shit about their past? Does the rest of the world need to be deprived of the history of humanity because the current, local, inhabitants don't care for their own? Your solution is to teach them to care, which is hilariously just as colonialist and culturally "appropriatiative" as the person you're replying to.
- fridacasper 3y ago[dead]
- mynameisnoone 3y agoThe Catacombs of Paris has/had a bag at the exit on the exterior with a modest guilt suggestion to return the bones of people rather than absconding with some unfortunate long-dead person's remains.