5 ms·
I can certainly see how you could argue that the APIs should be covered by copyright, but I'm not sure how you could say that invoking them in your code is ok b
by Symmetry 15y ago
I can certainly see how you could argue that the APIs should be covered by copyright, but I'm not sure how you could say that invoking them in your code is ok but that implementing them isn't - at least baring specific language in some contract the user signed.
- amalag 15y agoI can see that argument if you consider the API design to be a significant intellectual contribution which Oracle can prove considering the popularity of Java and it's ecosystem.
- Symmetry 15y agoI'm not sure I see what you mean there. If the API design is a significant intellectual contribution, and I'm inclined to say it is, that would be that the API is copyrighted. But that would mean that the API is copyrighted, not that its copyrighted for some purposes and not for others. Oracle seems to be saying that the API is only copyrighted for the purposes of implementing them, not invoking them, and I can't see what basis they're using to make that distinction. There may be something I'm missing, though.
- wmf 15y agoI think that argues more for patentability of APIs, though.
- vilhelm_s 15y agoOne of Oracle's slides quotes the licence statement in the Java Specification (http://docs.oracle.com/javase/specs/jls/se7/html/jls-0-legal.html http://docs.oracle.com/javase/specs/jls/se7/html/jls-0-legal...). It states that you are allowed to use it for developing applications, but not for developing "non-compliant" implementations. So I guess their position is that Google's implementation is an infringing copy of part of the specification (namely the type signatures).
- VikingCoder 15y agoI could have a line in my license statement for my book that it's legal for you to buy my book, but not loan it to a friend. That doesn't mean that any court would find fault with you, if you bought my book and then loaned it to a friend. That's totally fair use. Just an analogy to show that just because a company tries to make you believe they have the right to limit what you can legally do, doesn't mean you are legally limited.
- fpgeek 15y agoAs long as the book in question isn't an ebook, sadly. In that case, the book is licensed, not sold, and the license agreement has teeth.
- VikingCoder 15y ago...so I loan you my whole Kindle. :)