3 ms·
Suburbs are not that badly suited to mass transit. It costs more per person than in denser cities, but most suburbs are dense enough to support great mass tran
by bluGill 3y ago
Suburbs are not that badly suited to mass transit. It costs more per person than in denser cities, but most suburbs are dense enough to support great mass transit, and it would be cheaper than the cost of cars.
However great is key. This means you need great operations: including worse case waiting time everyone should be 15 minutes or less from a place where they can find plenty things to do in the community (stores, parks, schools); and a transfer to express service to elsewhere. If you don't have great transit: people in the suburbs can afford a car, and traffic isn't a problem so they will just drive. Note that this is a higher level of service than many downtowns get.
The above is very very expensive. However cars are very very very expensive.
- standardUser 3y agoWhen I think of the hilly suburbs of California, I cannot imagine a system that could convince even a fraction of those people to give up cars, no matter how elaborate or well-designed. But the design of those streets and the terrain make them extremely well-suited for cars. So instead of devising some radical and expensive re-design of the thousands of suburbs in America, autonomous cars seem to solve the problem quite elegantly. And there's nothing stopping people from tacking their autonomous car or taxi to a train station for more urban-oriented travel.
- JAlexoid 3y agoIt's probably going to be financials... The most common argument against suburbs is that they aren't self sustaining at paying for the services/infrastructure/utilities they consume.
- bluGill 3y agoThat is the most common argument, but they have been successfully doing it for more than 100 years. It is time to kill the argument, when you dig in you discover they are using some really weird definitions of self sustaining. (they don't count money that comes in from other sources even though everyone gets it all the time)