4 ms·
What really bugs me about all this: not only were they designed to break down, they messed that up to the point that the trains could have broken down while in
by jacquesm 3y ago
What really bugs me about all this: not only were they designed to break down, they messed that up to the point that the trains could have broken down while in service. The fact that a manufacturer would risk the lives of the passengers of the trains should result in personal liability for all of the execs of that company.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38641289 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38641289
I'd love to see that angle researched more because I think it changes the game from something commercial to a far more important level.
- game_the0ry 3y ago[flagged]
- SR2Z 3y agoThe article describes Polish trains.
- stephenitis 3y agoRead the article. Wrong country
- HumblyTossed 3y agoWhen bad things happen, the execs don't know it happened because they tell other people to go off and do stuff. When good things happen, execs take all the credit because the told people to go off and do stuff.
- usea 3y agoWhen my wife was in business school, the teacher of her management class used this idea as an unironic definition of management. They had to memorize the definition, which was essentially "taking credit for the work of other people." Not as a joke.
- jacquesm 3y agoThat's painful. But I totally believe it.
- Symbiote 3y agoA train breaking down or otherwise stopping causes no risk of injury or death.
- SpaghettiJimmy 3y agoWrong. Trains generally stopping at intersections already pose a real risk by blocking emergency vehicles, resulting in cases of loss of property and life that could otherwise have been avoided. Having an unplanned shutdown that cannot be easily remedied only further exacerbates that potential.
- Symbiote 3y agoOk, I hadn't thought of that. In most of Europe level crossings are rare enough that this would be very unlikely. It's also something the driver would easily avoid if they still have any control over the train, e.g. braking force.
- jacquesm 3y agoIn Poland level crossings are pretty normal. > It's also something the driver would easily avoid if they still have any control over the train, e.g. braking force. Yes, but: it would be much harder to test whether bricking this thing selectively does what it should do and for all we know right now you'd have a runaway on your hands. So this isn't just for shits and giggles. And even a stopped train on a live track can under the right circumstances be extremely risky.
- sweeter 3y agoThe issue started back when highways were being built across the US. Subsequently the US deregulated the Rail industry so that it could compete with long-haul trucking. Its been a steady spiral since then. John Oliver did an amazing and informative piece on trains. Since then, workers get no days off, they reduced the amount of workers on a train to 2 and are trying to get it down to 1 as we speak. They increased the length of trans by literal miles, and these trains have killed multiple people by blocking roadways / ambulances and have run over children who have had to crawl underneath the trains to get to school. This happens multiple times a week where the road is blocked for almost a day. These conductors have to walk the length of 4 miles to "inspect" the train, and deregulation has pushed the inspection time down to mere minutes instead of an entire checklist. They have taken all the power from the single regulation body and allow trains to run with brakes built in the early 1900s. We have many multiple "accidents" a year with chemical spills, all for profit seeking behavior. These workers are consistently over-worked and cannot take any sick days unless they are scheduled 2-3 months in advance. Train accidents are inevitable at this point, the next one may be more disastrous than Palestine Ohio. This is the direct result to profit seeking by corporations (who pull in billions a year) and deregulation. It sucks because trains are f*cking awesome and could help society in a million ways.