4 ms·
You will always have pure analog electronics and other bespoke things that basically don't benefit from anything finer than these nodes. Even for digital chips
by zozbot234 3y ago
You will always have pure analog electronics and other bespoke things that basically don't benefit from anything finer than these nodes. Even for digital chips, it makes no sense to use leading edge nodes for very simple logic where a lot of the area is just contact pads.
- janekm 3y agoBut you can only really make those profitably for a few industries (military, medical, seismic come to mind). The EU does have the chip fabs for those industries, of course...
- phkahler 3y ago>> But you can only really make those profitably for a few industries I think it's more like they're only profitable if the equipment is already paid for. And even then the margins may be low.
- eternauta3k 3y agoPower electronics are a mainstream, very profitable market.
- jacquesm 3y agoIt's not about what you can do or can't do. It is about what you can do profitably and that's a completely different thing.
- voakbasda 3y agoI have to wonder if the ability to profit depends entirely on the established cartel of semiconductor manufacturers. They determine the current prices of chips in the marketplace. If entering that marketplace requires competing with them, then I am not sure anyone that is not already in the market can ever win. The margins are too low and the startup costs are too high. Government intervention seems to be the only possible solution, and that option hardly sounds viable when considering that cartel’s collective lobbying power.
- jacquesm 3y agoThe capital expense on a new fab is crazy. There may be a cartel factor but that usually would work to the advantage of the manufacturers, so that doesn't seem to be the case here.
- mardifoufs 3y agoThere's no real cartel for older nodes. It's not even really possible considering how many fabs exist and how many players are operating those older fabs.
- cf1241290841 3y agoNumber of producers of these fabs is still quite limited though.
- cduzz 3y agoI don't think this is a "cartel of semiconductor manufacturers" so much as it's been a "shambolic cluster of organizations running crappy old fabs into the ground producing cheap chips that were subsidized by a prior decade's worth of very expensive products." I can afford to sell gazillions of chips at $0.08 per chip if I'm running a fab I didn't pay to build. I'm only (barely) paying for the inputs. When Stan, the last guy who understands how to run the widget verifier, or Elaine, the last lady to understands how to run the polishing machine retire, I'll have to close up shop. Those $0.08 per chip devices have been absurdly subsidized in that a replacement infrastructure to make them would require that they cost $10 per device, and the ecosystem of things built on $0.08 chips isn't viable in a $10 per chip world. In order to have a fab make $0.03 per unit devices, you first have to have the fab spend 10 years making $300 per unit devices, regardless of the underlying node size of those $300 per unit devices. Likely you couldn't even go back and make a fab that makes large volumes of 60nm-90nm node sizes at all, for any amount of money, because the equipment to do this (new) hasn't been made in 2 decades and no company is willing to invest the money to make new crappy old equipment. It's not a nefarious oligopoly as much as a synchronized "run the asset to failure" lifecycle of the infrastructure. How much does it cost to make a 300 year old tree?
- cf1241290841 3y agoRelevant to mention MEMS (micro-electromechanical systems) in this context, which use much older nm tech. Be it digital micro mirror devices¹ or gyros². Or photo/laser diodes. Given the physical limitations, as well as the problems we have with code base security it might be time to aim for cheaper production of something in the region of 180nm instead. Looking at how old much of the standard weaponry used today is (TOW 50 years with an actual physical gyroscope, Javelin still 25 years³), the demand from the military alone should cover the initial cost. Especially if you look at the ludicrous prices western countries payed for even dumb artillery shells. ¹ Texas Instruments DMD from a DLP projector from @AppliedScience https://youtu.be/9nb8mM3uEIc?t=428 https://youtu.be/9nb8mM3uEIc?t=428 ² Explanation of MPU-6050 from @BreakingTaps https://youtu.be/9X4frIQo7x0?t=664 https://youtu.be/9X4frIQo7x0?t=664 ³ Teardown of both from @lelabodemichel5162 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s7-6hgX7-zQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s7-6hgX7-zQ Sorry for late edits