4 ms·
We don't really need anything new in this space, though. We need a free/open Photoshop clone. We need a direct, one-to-one monkey copy of Adobe's product. We
by angersock 15y ago
We don't really need anything new in this space, though.
We need a free/open Photoshop clone. We need a direct, one-to-one monkey copy of Adobe's product.
We don't need flights of fancy, we don't need to retrain existing users of image manipulation programs, we don't need to experiment. Adobe already has all the legwork done for us--the answer looks a hell of a lot like Photoshop and its interface.
There is zero--ZERO--reason to try to come up with a new interface when there is a perfectly good one in existence that just happens to be poorly distributed.
The place where GIMP has screwed up (and Blender and the like along with them) is in not parroting exactly the common tools in the ecosystem.
There are weird programs (Wings 3D, Paint.NET, etc.) that are able to significantly depart from conventions, mostly because they have very narrowly-defined functionality (something I don't believe anyone would ever accuse the GIMP of).
The GIMP developers should either focus on making a monkey copy (and ignoring everything else until feature/UX parity is achieved), or stop working on the project entirely so they can do something else for a while. Once the monkey copy is done, then innovate. Until then, stop wasting time with things nobody cares about.
I used the GIMP as my primary art asset creation tool for several years. It was miserable. The filters and procedural image generation stuff was awesome, but everything else was at best hard to use. Eventually I switched to Photoshop because it was a (comparatively) clean, tight tool with all the bullshit removed.
- billpatrianakos 15y agoYeah, I back you up on this 100%. I never use GIMP on my Linux box because it's not enough like Photoshop. I know, ridiculous sentence, I sound like a blasphemer, my apologies. There's nothing wrong with saying Photoshop has got things right. Sure it's nowhere near open, and incredibly overpriced but that's exactly why I want to love GIMP. I've been wishing for a Photoshop clone minus the bad parts of Photoshop plus some innovations but what I've gotten so far is just falling short. It feels to me like MS Paint on steroids. UI is decent but the functionality kills me in that any time I try to do something like I would in Photoshop like, say adding a simple stroke to a shape or adding a gradient or shadow, in GIMP it doesn't come out looking like its even in the same ballpark as Photoshop no matter how long I spend tweaking knobs and sliders. GIMP may not be for us though. I was under the impression it was a Photoshop alternative but maybe I took that too literally. If I'm the minority then so be it, I'll keep searching for a better fit but I do hope GIMP grants some of my wishes. I open it and I feel like I could use it but then u start using it and it disappoints me.
- frou_dh 15y agoGood shout with Wings 3D! It's definitely weird and awesome. For starters, it's a desktop app written in Erlang. I recommend people bookmark it if they think they will ever need an intuitive way to do basic-intermediate 3D modelling. http://www.wings3d.com/ http://www.wings3d.com/
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- pmarin 15y agoThe author explained in this thread why he used Erlang: http://nendowingsmirai.yuku.com/topic/6327/FAQ-Why-Erlang#.T5Bib86ZaHc http://nendowingsmirai.yuku.com/topic/6327/FAQ-Why-Erlang#.T...
- angersock 15y agoI've used Wings3D to do static meshes for over five years. It's very, very, very good at the type of modeling that it does--and miserable for anything else. But for UV pelt mapping, for box modeling, for those sorts of tasks? It shines like a diamond. It's got probably the most minimal interface I've ever seen on a modeling program and, despite a few oddities, probably the most discoverable/fastest.
- wslh 15y agoI upvoted your comment but what is weird on Paint.NET? I am very happy with it where I always felt that GIMP was the VI of image manipulation.
- Joeri 15y agoSorry, but no. Photoshop's interface is not particularly easy to use (discoverability issues), nor is it efficient (too much modifier key usage). Photoshop users are overtrained on a suboptimal way of working. What we need is something with photoshop's engine (which is very powerful), but a better UI. Gimp is not that though, and it never will be (good UI must be designed like a cathedral, and gimp will always remain a bazaar of features).
- angersock 15y agoI agree that GIMP will always be a bizarre of features. The thing is that, while Photoshop may not be the pinnacle of UX, it's familiar to everyone in the space. It has issues in the UI, but nothing that can't be overcome fairly quickly and nothing that is a gamebreaker. For design wanks, yeah, you could probably improve it. You then lose the overtraining, though. You also might screw up. You end up trying to develop a moving target. For a productivity tool, I don't want imagination. I want excellent execution of a proven design. Only in magical fairy pixie land does it pay to reinvent the wheel to be slightly rounder on a tool everyone already knows well. As I mentioned elsewhere: don't let the best be the enemy of the good-enough.
- skore 15y ago>> gimp will always remain a bazaar of features > I agree that GIMP will always be a bizarre of features > For design wanks... > Only in magical fairy pixie land... Sorry, but need to ask - are you trying to troll here? I've used The GIMP for about a decade now and it fits perfectly into the UNIX methodology: A sharp tool that does its frigging job. There is no reinvention of the wheel and people who say that without pointing to anything but the single-window/multi-windows difference should really find better use for their time. Actually, in your original post, you didn't even mention that. Your verdict was: "The filters and procedural image generation stuff was awesome, but everything else was at best hard to use. Eventually I switched to Photoshop because it was a (comparatively) clean, tight tool with all the bullshit removed.". Any software has a learning curve, The GIMPs curve not being much different from Photoshop, just in a slightly different direction. I don't find any of the tools hard to use and that was from within a month of using it - not just because I've gotten used to it over the years. Actually, if anybody argues GIMP vs. Photoshop with me, they mostly try to convince me that GIMP lacks features, so I really have no clue whatsoever what you mean by "all the bullshit" that is supposedly in there.
- mtts 15y ago> I used the GIMP as my primary art asset creation tool for several years. It was miserable. I used the Gimp for < spam > http://rommelhok.com/en http://rommelhok.com/en < / spam > (48 pages worth of old fashioned adventure comics). Not for the drawing itself, but for the cleaning up, the coloring and the lettering. It was fine. Everything worked without a hitch, once I got used to some new shortcuts (which can easily be set to the Photoshop equivalents if you want) and some minor differences from Photoshop, some of which were, in fact, improvements (the color selection tool is much nicer in Gimp than the color range selection box in Photoshop, for example). The only area where Gimp definitely falls short is type setting. In Photoshop, you can tweak kerning, spacing and font size within a text layer for every character individually. In Gimp, you can only do that for the layer as a whole. This wasn't much of a problem for me, however, since computer lettering is already inferior to hand lettering (IMHO) and using Photoshop's superior tools wouldn't have decreased the suckiness of the lettering all that significantly. The other main shortcoming of Gimp, of course, is that it can't do CMYK colors but that will only become a problem when someone decides to publish my comic, in which case having to redo the colors will be a nice problem to have. I made one printed copy of it for myself at the local copy shop using the RGB Gimp files and that turned out beautifully.
- jberryman 15y agoLoved what I read of the comic. good luck with it!
- mtts 15y agoThanks for the compliment!
- nicubunu 15y agoi had used myself Inkscape when i ran my own comic and found it a better tool for the task, including for the type setting part
- mtts 15y agoFor drawing Inkscape is a better tool, yes, but I did the drawing, both pencils and inks, on paper and then scanned the result for further processing which was mostly removing smudges and correcting mistakes: pixel based operations.