3 ms·
Wouldn't that be fraudulent? As in, you've got goods in hand, and just deprived the retailer of the price of the item (plus a little more)?
by Karunamon 15y ago
Wouldn't that be fraudulent? As in, you've got goods in hand, and just deprived the retailer of the price of the item (plus a little more)?
- dangrossman 15y agoThere are a number of chargeback codes for things like item-not-as-described. If there is fraud on the part of the merchant, they can be deprived of the money and the goods, as far as Visa/MasterCard's Operating Regulations are concerned. If the merchant loses their dispute of the chargeback, their remaining recourse is to take the customer to court.
- Karunamon 15y agoexport devilsadvocate="1" But in this instance, the "description" was what you saw right in front of you. It's not fraud to sell you something from a glass case right in front of you. From a CS perspective I can see why it would be the right thing to accept a return, but not so much a legal issue.
- wpietri 15y agoIf you've offered to send the thing back, I don't think it's fraud at all.
- Karunamon 15y agoBreaking into a store and taking something is still wrong, even if you give it back later or leave the money on the counter.
- wpietri 15y agoTrue, but irrelevant. We're talking about commerce, not armed robbery. Trying to return something to a store is not fraud. This guy in particular always intended to pay for a case like his wife's. If he didn't get what he expected, then returning the product for a refund is reasonable and legal. If he sends them a note saying, "I am returning the product and canceling my payment; where should I send it?" then no fraud has been committed.
- Karunamon 15y agoWhen the terms explicitly state no refunds though, "returning the product and canceling the payment" is not an option. You bought it, you own it, and the store is under no obligation to either take the item or give you your money back. I'd fully expect to be sued for fraud and lose if I attempted what's being described here.
- wpietri 15y agoFraud is "intentional deception made for personal gain". By attempting to return, he would make no deception. Also, the stuff printed on a dot-matrix receipt does not have the force of law. A store's policies describe what they normally do. That's just where you begin the negotiation.
- Karunamon 15y ago>By attempting to return, he would make no deception. Turn it around a bit. Let's say you buy something from your average big box store, like a piece of software. You are informed both by signs in the store, on your reciept, and let's say you're extra cautious and ask the checker what the return policy is. That policy is always some variation on "Opened software will not be accepted for refund, only exchange of the same item". You buy the item anyways. Later, you decide you don't like it - not because it's defective, because that's an entirely separate category of law (and you could always do an exchange anyways), but that you simply decide you don't want it anymore. You take it to the front counter and attempt to do a refund. Denied - the clerk and manager both point at the sign on the wall and the text on your reciept with the same refund policy text from earlier. You go home, call your card company, and attempt to do a chargeback. How is what you did not fraudulent? Did you not accept the terms by purchasing something from a company that said they won't take $item back? You are basically forcing the company to give you money against their will - all while you still have the item. There's no obligation in law that entitles you to a refund. I don't mean this to be offensive, but people like you are what scare me in the business world. If you don't like a retailer's posted policies, you should shop elsewhere.