2 ms·
> I think sometimes, growing up in the West, we accept the dogma of separation of state and religion without really asking how true that really is. In reality,
by graemep 3y ago
> I think sometimes, growing up in the West, we accept the dogma of separation of state and religion without really asking how true that really is. In reality, Christianity is deeply intertwined with most European constitutions and state apparatuses.
I disagree. It is not complete, nor does anyone pretend it is, but it is far greater and fairer than in western countries than in the rest of the world (such as the examples I gave). Can you imagine the reaction if a British Prime Minister said that the Prime Minister should be a Christian? Or if we started arresting people for belonging to a non-state approved religion? Or parliament passed laws banning religious conversion? Or turned a bling eye to mod attacks on religious minorities?
The first and third in Germany would not bother me as they are opt-in. The second seems entirely wrong.
In the UK I do not find state schools being run by Christian organisations a problem, because it is not discriminatory - there are state schools run by other religions too. Collective worship is a weird law but compliance is not monitored and most schools do not actually do it, singing is not really a act of worship, parents can opt children out, older children can opt themselves out, and in religious schools it is their religion (actually, these are the ones which will have an actual act of worship).
I do agree we should have greater separation between the state and the church of England. On the other hand there are benefits to it. I think C of E bishops in the House of Lords broadens representation in politics beyond the political class (they have a good track record of speaking up for the poor), and even more so as representatives of other denominations religions are included (e.g. two of the last three Chief Rabbis) although not enough IMO.