6 ms·
This reads like advertising copy for Google Cloud. "Come and host with us, so you get the advantage of pre-disclosure protection against issues that we discover
by jacquesm 3y ago
This reads like advertising copy for Google Cloud. "Come and host with us, so you get the advantage of pre-disclosure protection against issues that we discover.".
I wonder to what extent the security industry is self-reinforcing and how many of these vulnerabilities would be discovered by 'the bad guys' taking into account that none of them have these kind of resources. But now the rest of the world has to deal with the fall-out of the disclosure that Google got a head start on and can relatively easily deploy across their cloud. It feels a bit like the hero model to me: only we can keep you safe from the problems that we create.
- callalex 3y agoIf you were emperor of Google Security what would you have them do differently?
- Dah00n 3y agoRelease the information to the rest of Google in the same timeframe and in the same way as Amazon, Intel, Linux, BSD, Microsoft, etc.
- rvba 3y agoThis reads more like an advertisement for the person who wrote the post - as they did not even discover the bug, just led security response.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- resolutebat 3y agoYou may have missed this part: > From there, Google partnered and collaborated with Intel to securely share the vulnerability mitigation information with other large industry players to ensure they too could respond and protect all users globally (not only Google users). So while the blog post of course is marketing, Google does not gain any direct competitive advantage from the vulnerability, all the large clouds are more or less on the same starting line.
- l33t7332273 3y agoWell as long as you’re large industry player you’re on the same starting line.
- sahila 3y agoIs your solution that these things shouldn’t be looked into by Google and let’s just hope no bad actors find and make use of it? Really seems like there’s no winning for Google in the public narrative!
- kernal 3y agoGoogle really needs to be more like Apple and close source everything, keep all innovations to themselves and stop giving away software. Apple has shown that locked down operating systems and ecosystems are the most profitable and legal friendly courses of action.
- Laremere 3y ago> 'the bad guys' taking into account that none of them have these kind of resources State actors definitely have these resources. USA, China, Russia at a minimum. I definitely feel the angst against the effort it takes to protect against bad actors. For example the adoption of https/ssl had a lot of worry about how expensive it was to encrypt server traffic. There were people arguing that it just wasn't worth it because the risk felt low, but it turns out the compromising was happening in practice. The ability to not have to guard against bad actors would make implementing technology a radically simpler endeavor, we just simply don't live in that world.
- Dah00n 3y ago>State actors definitely have these resources. USA, China, Russia at a minimum Do they? Amazon and Google level knowledge, both from live systems with data like all of Google and Amazon, but also the developers and analysts to look through data from it and to comb through source code? I very much doubt Russia has this at least, but it is a widespread American point of view that Russia has, well, basically everything one day and nothing at all the next (IE. Ukraine war). I doubt anyone -except maybe the US- has this.
- Alpha3031 3y ago> Do they? Have the resources to develop zero days? Of course they do. Like, even Iran, North Korea, Uzbekistan, Vietnam, etc have the resources required to either make their own zero days, pay someone unscrupulous for it or acquire them some other way. It only costs a few million.
- hulitu 3y ago> I wonder to what extent the security industry is self-reinforcing Works wonders for Apple. ("look, we fixed the bug discovered by Citizenlab"). Security, unfortunately, has become theater. There are some things fixed when and if they are disvovered but, in general, the main issues were not adressed (fine grained permissions, web browser as remote code executor, etc).
- sulam 3y agoIt really feels like Google could announce the cure for cancer and HN would find a way to talk shit about it.
- nvy 3y agoThey'd just cease producing the pills in 18 months.
- spartanatreyu 3y agoThat's not even a joke. If Google had a magical cancer cure, they would absolutely stop supporting it. The manager in charge of that project got their promotion, and the new manager brought in won't get any credit for maintaining an existing project, they need a new project they can put their name on.
- ithkuil 3y agoThe striking similarity of this pattern with what real world politicians are doing is not a coincidence
- Rebelgecko 3y agoThe worst part is that you have to take the medication for 20 months before you're cured
- ithkuil 3y agoThey'd develop the cure in the open, all their researchers will end up working for a new startup starting off as a non profit but then spinning off a for profit company which will actually make a working cure and everybody will wonder why Google lost their lead at cancer research
- cvs268 3y agoHmmm... if the cure for cancer is offerred as a subscription model, that requires an active Google account, well...
- tptacek 3y agoI work for a startup that competes (in some sense) with Google Cloud. The resources Google can apply to identifying vulnerabilities are absolutely a competitive advantage they have over us. What's the point in complaining about it? It's a true fact, a very real reason to use GCP as opposed to other cloud platforms.
- Kwpolska 3y agoGoogle Cloud customers had their servers patched a month before the vulnerability was publicly announced. Your customers got the patch whenever your Linux distro pushed out the microcode update. But this doesn't mean that Azure and AWS also had to wait, I would expect Intel to provide the update to them some time before making it public. Also, how many vulnerabilities relevant to public clouds does Google detect in one year, and does that outweigh the lack of support and care you can expect from Google?
- Dah00n 3y ago>But this doesn't mean that Azure and AWS also had to wait The article says they didn't wait, but got informed.
- weinzierl 3y agoThis bothers me even more when it comes to web browsers. (Or should I say the browser?) I grew up in a world where everything was hackable. Chrome (and Firefox, but it really doesn't matter anymore) become less and less modifiable and adaptable. In theory and practice. I think the main reason there is no viable alternative browser is that it has become far too complicated and far to much effort to write and maintain one. But - and here comes the point - even if we could muster the resources to pull one off, we'd never gain enough trust that it is as secure as Chrome to make it even remotely popular. As long as things are as they are, it is a game we're never gonna win.
- Dalewyn 3y ago>we'd never gain enough trust that it is as secure as Chrome to make it even remotely popular. The vast majority of people do not care about security, privacy, etc. at all. Chrome achieved dominion simply because it's better to use than anything else, it also doesn't help that Firefox also Mozilla'd itself into irrelevance.
- jacquesm 3y agoChrome achieved dominion because it was pushed heavily by Google abusing their monopoly. If Chrome had been fielded by a small software company (assuming they could have) it would have maybe reached parity with FF but it would have never gotten to the dominant position that it has today. All of those 'download Chrome here' and all of those articles that happen to move to the top of your search results add up to a pretty big competitive advantage.
- charcircuit 3y agoChromium still seems to be plenty modifiable and adaptable. It's pretty modular and there are plenty of active forks of it: Edge, Brave, Opera, etc.
- herewulf 3y agoAnd those projects are dependent on Google's perpetual goodwill to keep Chromium open and up to date. What if Google one day yanks the rug out from under them?