3 ms·
> This would imply that the "space" between matter increases indefinitely as you approach the center, right? > Also, wouldn't this apply to the original star t
by lmm 3y ago
> This would imply that the "space" between matter increases indefinitely as you approach the center, right?
> Also, wouldn't this apply to the original star that's collapsing? Meaning the particles inside the star are getting ripped apart as the black hole forms and they're drawn toward the center at faster and faster speeds. Is it possible that the particles in the star are also ripped apart by tidal forces, never reaching each other?
In that model, yes. If you take GR literally (and personally I wouldn't), space itself is distorted and matter falling in falls infinitely far. (There is an argument that this itself prevents a true singularity from ever forming: there is an eternally collapsing pseudosingularity that is getting smaller and smaller and denser and denser, but the denser it is the more time-dilation it undergoes and so the collapse can never finish in finite time, at least for an outside observer).
> Also, does this also apply to photons in say a light ray? Do the photons nearer the center pull away from the photons further out? If not, why not? And if so, then how can this be possible if all photons travel at same speed C? Is it that space is expanding inside the event horizon, faster than the speed of light?
You can't really talk about photons in the context of GR, but yes, from the perspective of an infalling observer, light from an entity behind you gets increasingly redshifted and eventually the two of you are accelerating away from each other faster than light can reach, like a "big rip" in minature.
> But the idea of a singularity is that "everything is in a single point of infinite density".
> So how can matter be getting ripped apart at the same time it's getting squooshed together?
From the outside it's a point. But from the inside it's an infinitely large volume of space. (Again, if you take GR literally)
- lordfrito 3y ago> there is an eternally collapsing pseudosingularity that is getting smaller and smaller and denser and denser, but the denser it is the more time-dilation it undergoes and so the collapse can never finish in finite time, at least for an outside observer) > From the outside it's a point. If I understand what you're saying, it's that from the outside it wants to be a point, but can never quite get there in (our) finite time. So we just see a big red shifted "frozen in time" black hole event horizon. Evaporates maybe in the future, but point is we never actually get a singularity on our side of the horizon. > From the inside, it's an infinitely large volume. This makes sense to me, more than a singularity existing. On the inside everything is ripped apart as space infinitely expands. So doesn't this imply there is no singularity on either side of the event horizon then? It's as if the "wanting" to be a singularity on our side of the horizon is countered/balanced by frozen time. And on the other side of the horizon, from the particles point of view you can't freeze time. So instead the singularity is countered by infinitely expanding space to prevent just this sort of thing from happening. Is this some sort of relativistic time/space conservation law? It's like the extreme gravity trying to create a particle singularity just ends up expanding the space between the particles instead. Hmmm. We know that at relativistic speeds, trying to accelerate a particle to C leads to time slowing down. In this case too much gravity trying to create a singularity leads to space expansion instead? Are these just two sides to the same coin. Frozen time = infinite space depending on your relativistic point of view?? Sort of like the cosmic censorship hypothesis, just extended from "no naked singularities exist" on our side of the universe, to "no singularities exist" on the other side as well. Did I get that right, or did I butcher it?
- lmm 3y ago> If I understand what you're saying, it's that from the outside it wants to be a point, but can never quite get there in (our) finite time. Right. Bear in mind that's only one school of thought, and not the most mainstream one. > Is this some sort of relativistic time/space conservation law? > Are these just two sides to the same coin. Frozen time = infinite space depending on your relativistic point of view?? Separation is Lorentz invariant. But there's no general theorem here AFAIK, at least not a known one, though the behaviour certainly rhymes.
- GoblinSlayer 3y agoWhat do you mean not the mainstream one? When people say that black hole exists, they mean you can imagine a hypothetical situation, where black hole exists in its complete form. It's still mathematically accurate to say that black hole doesn't form for a distant observer during collapse, it freezes just before it approaches Schwarzschild radius.