5 ms·
> All the people who were cutting engineered stone with unsafe methods, are now just going to be cutting granite and other natural stone with the same safety pr
by defrost 3y ago
> All the people who were cutting engineered stone with unsafe methods, are now just going to be cutting granite and other natural stone with the same safety practices that led to this being banned.
> I really don't get it.
Before engineered stone took off like crazy people were already cutting natural stone, working as stone masons, working at BGC quarries (stone mining, crushing, grading, delivery).
After engineered stone became fashionable the rates of silicosis in under 35 year old tradespeople spiked in a sharply noticable way.
After the engineered stone ban things will likely return to previous levels of "it happens but it's acceptably rare".
For whatever reason ( . . . insert theory . . . ) engineered stone manufacture and cutting is much much much worse wrt health issues.
For whatever reason your desk bound rational rule of thumb doesn't track against the data.
- lostlogin 3y ago> For whatever reason ( . . . insert theory . . . ) engineered stone manufacture and cutting is much much much worse wrt health issues. My theory: engineered stone allowed us plebs to get stone benches. Previously we had stainless, Formica and other bench tops that were less toxic to work with.
- ShadowBanThis01 3y agoNot saying those figures aren't valid, but isn't it also possible that the increased affordability of man-made stone meant that these workers were doing more "stone" installations as opposed to tile or other options?
- amluto 3y agoHmm, this isn’t crazy. IIRC in the nineties and earlier, porcelain tile countertops were very common. Granite and marble were exotic. Porcelain is high in silicates, but not so high in silica. Glaze is (I think) amorphous, like glass. And your average tile installer cuts with a wet saw. Marble is mostly calcium carbonate. Granite contains lots of quartz.
- xupybd 3y agoEngineered stone is easy to cut on site. Real cheap to work with that's why it beat Porcelain. I don't think Porcelain is as dangerous.
- amluto 3y agoPorcelain is also easy to cut with a tile saw, and tile saws make very little dust. Porcelain tile doesn’t look fun to cut with a dremel or angle grinder.
- bsder 3y agoEdit to just link the article rather than my silly speculation about particle sizes and types: Reference: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1111/resp.14625 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1111/resp.14625 "The qualitative comparison of in vitro responses between the categories of particles we examined revealed some interesting patterns. Firstly, the ES dusts were the most potent stimulus in inducing cytotoxicity and pro-inflammatory responses in epithelial cells while the standard silica sample was particularly toxic to macrophages. All particles (ES, BM,NS and standard silica) showed some potential to promote IL-8 (CXCL8) and TNF-α production in macrophages, as well as IL-1β, with the exception of natural stone. These observations are consistent with our overarching hypothesis that particle characteristics are key drivers of the lung cell response and, therefore, the risk of disease. In more in-depth analyses with a focus on ES dusts, we found that the quartz concentration was significantly associated with the inflammatory response in macrophages. This is an important observation as there has been consistent rhetoric regarding the crystalline silica content of ES being the key driver of the high disease prevalence. 7,39Indeed, crystalline silica has been shown to be related to the dose-dependent macrophage accumulation response,40aggravated inflammatory cell infiltration, thickened alveolar walls and enhanced expression of collagens. 41However, the relationship between quartz and the macrophage inflammatory response was not the sole driver of the cellular responses we observed."
- AdamJacobMuller 3y agoPost hoc ergo propter hoc.
- defrost 3y agoCute but lacking depth. If you feel that way, take it up with: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/resp.14625 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/resp.14625 https://www.osha.gov/sites/default/files/publications/OSHA3768.pdf https://www.osha.gov/sites/default/files/publications/OSHA37... and the tradies getting physical reactions in their lungs from the dust.
- mattmaroon 3y agoOK, fair, and tragic, but is the only solution banning it entirely? What about requiring PPE? There are a whole lot of jobs that are safe when done properly and unsafe, when not done properly. It seems as if they are punishing an entire industry for not knowing what they didn’t know.
- yeeeloit 3y agoCutting stone and keeping 100% of it out of your lungs is nearly impossible, especially when you are working in uncontrolled environments like someone's kitchen that is being renovated. The PPE available for this sort of work is just not up to the job.
- cyberax 3y ago> Cutting stone and keeping 100% of it out of your lungs is nearly impossible, especially when you are working in uncontrolled environments like someone's kitchen that is being renovated. I'm building a house, and I have a stone countertop installed. None of the cutting was done on-site. All the work was done in a specialized workshop.
- mattmaroon 3y agoI believe it’s always done that way in the US when you order granite or other stone countertops. Cutting large heavy slabs on site isn’t efficient.
- mattmaroon 3y agoI think that’s simply untrue. You’re not cutting the stone in kitchens, it’s cut at the warehouse and transported to the kitchen. In the US we’ve regulated this and while our record isn’t 100% safety due to non-compliance (which is always the case) we’ve got a much lower rate than Australia despite presumably selling a lot more of it.
- DannyBee 3y agoPAPR is fine? and available?
- yeeeloit 3y agoExactly, silica is not the problem. Silica is everywhere, we don't wear PPE to drive down a dirt road. It's the silica plus the adhesive additives combined in your lungs that does the damage.
- cyberax 3y ago> Exactly, silica is not the problem It is. The air-driven rock drills were called "widowmakers" by miners because of silicosis that quickly reaped its operators. > Silica is everywhere, we don't wear PPE to drive down a dirt road. Silica down the road is not in the form of fine dust.
- maakk 3y agoMaybe. Or it's the dose, which sounds quite high when working with engineered stone.
- Reason077 3y agoOr the size of the particles. Cutting engineered stone has been shown to generate large quantities of extremely fine particles (< 1 µm). Cutting natural stone or driving on a dirt road, the typical particle sizes are much larger.
- simondotau 3y agoWhy isn’t it being cut wet? Surely if dust is the problem, water is the solution.
- pshc 3y agoIf done properly, probably. > In February 2021, a WorkSafe Inspector attended the workplace and observed an employee using a powered abrasive polishing tool to abrasively polish a slab of white coloured stone which was from the brand Stone Ambassador. The tool was being used without the required control measures in place. Instead, the employee was applying water to the stone from a bottle with a small hole in the lid when the tool was in use.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]