3 ms·
Why would anyone think "AI" would excel at innovation. Honest question. Innovation is defined as "introducing something new". "AI" is autocomplete and autos
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y ago
Why would anyone think "AI" would excel at innovation. Honest question.
Innovation is defined as "introducing something new".
"AI" is autocomplete and autoselection based on _past_ input.
"AI" is regurgitating, rehashing or recombining something that has come before. It might do this in a new (=yet untried) way, but it cannot "introduce something new". Only man can do that.
Make no mistake, recombining can be useful. With AI we can screen a large number of possible recombinations that would be practically infeasible without it.
But the only way something new can be "introduced" is for man to produce new data for "AI" to process. "AI" is always one step behind.
There is no way for "AI" to have "new thoughts". All "thinking" by AI is always just regurgitation, rehashing or recombination of man's past thoughts.
- hnfong 3y agoIn a deterministic physical world, all actions are based on the last state. So your actions are based on the state of the universe a split second prior. Why would you think anyone could innovate? (Ecclesiastes 1:9 - What has been will be again, what has been done will be done again; there is nothing new under the sun.) By now I'm quite surprised people haven't realized most of their arguments about fundamental limitations of AI apply to themselves as well.
- DrSiemer 3y agoThe current generation of language models is only rewarded for how well it can mimic human communication. There is no incentive for innovation. Give it a few generations and we'll add that. A current model could already run a chain of "what if" scenarios and grade the results for how unique and how beneficial they are. Supercharge that and you'll probably end up with something useful. Everything is a remix.