12 ms·
> I'm expecting a sobering year for AI in 2024 I expect a sobering year for illustrators [1], animators [2], musicians [3], game designers, publishers, and new
by echelon 3y ago
> I'm expecting a sobering year for AI in 2024
I expect a sobering year for illustrators [1], animators [2], musicians [3], game designers, publishers, and news outlets [4] as GenAI starts to make their fields accessible to everyone.
The prevailing opinion on HN is to sleep on this like crypto, which is baffling to me. The outputs are so good and are leading to entirely new classes of products, not to mention orders of magnitude reduction in time and cost structures.
This is the most exciting moment in tech of the last 30 years, yet there's so much "nobody would use Dropbox" and "old man yells at cloud" negative forecasting.
Entire industries are going to be disrupted by this. Y'all are sleeping on it.
[1] https://playgroundai.com/ https://playgroundai.com/
[2] https://pikalabs.org/showcase/ https://pikalabs.org/showcase/
[3] https://www.suno.ai/ https://www.suno.ai/
[4] https://www.channel1.ai/ https://www.channel1.ai/
- bossyTeacher 3y ago> I expect a sobering year for illustrators [1], animators [2], musicians [3], game designers, publishers, and news outlets [4] as GenAI starts to make their fields accessible to everyone. That's such a privileged and insensitive thing to say imo. The careers of all these people are at risk, and no, this is no industrial revolution, there is no replacement for those people unless they decide to become LLM researchers/devs and join the LLM train. I wonder if you said the same thing if your job got made redundant because it's not needed anymore and you need to spend +5 years retraining without having the funds or economical support to do so.
- mjr00 3y agoComparing generative AI favorably to crypto is an odd choice, given that crypto and blockchain are the poster children for "massively overhyped tech that led to absolutely nothing."
- echelon 3y agoI'm comparing HN attitudes. People dismiss AI as if it were crypto. > that led to absolutely nothing. This is the part most of you are completely blind to. It's astonishing to me that you don't see the step function changes happening. I guess that means less competition, though. By the end of the year, anyone will be able to make brand new Taylor Swift music that sounds good. The average child will be able to animate short films. This is insane. Both the fact that sci-fi possibilities are tangibly right ahead of us, and the fact that so many people are dismissing it outright.
- bossyTeacher 3y agoYou know you can make Taylor Swift music you know? Youtube has plenty of tutorials and the web has plenty of DAWs you can use that require no training that you cannot get on the internet. The sounds "good" bit has nothing to do with technology imo. If you have no skill, you won't be able to make good sounding Taylor Swift music but you will be able to make another entity make it for you. You don't need AI for this. You could contract the services of someone to do it, you could ask the Switfies communities to do it. You don't need AI for this. The only difference is that you will now be able to press a button and have something that resembles Swift music but I highly doubt you will be able to steer the output through the multidimensional output space towards something that falls within "good sounding Swift music* if you yourself have zero musical knowledge. You could still end up there randomly though. But what are the chances? Fairly low, I would say. Short films is the same. You are looking at music and films the same way a random biz manager looks at programmers when he says "I will give you a magical glove that enables you to type faster so you can complete your work much faster". What I think this tech will be good at is prototyping for people that already have the skills or knowledge of what the final product should look like
- mjr00 3y ago> By the end of the year, anyone will be able to make brand new Taylor Swift music that sounds good. The average child will be able to animate short films. But will I be able to listen to that music and watch those films in my fully autonomous vehicle which will be available in 2016... I mean 2020... I mean 2025... I mean 2040?
- echelon 3y ago> But will I be able to listen to that music and watch those films in my fully autonomous vehicle which will be available in 2016... I mean 2020... I mean 2025... I mean 2040? Despite Waymo's current state, I don't think autonomous cars will be solved or deployed widely anytime soon. I do think Hollywood is about to be toast. Movies, music, games (non-engine, non-gameplay aspects), narrative fiction, etc. These techniques will impact different fields in different ways. Some will be outright washed over and remade entirely.
- Gerlo 3y agoI've been shamed for using LLM's heavily despite my productivity being through the roof.
- mjr00 3y agoShamed by whom? And how can those people tell you're using LLMs? Is it possible that whatever output you're producing with LLMs isn't very good?
- Gerlo 3y agoSorry, "shamed" is a bit hyperbolic. But I was more or less told on one of the sysadmin subreddits that there is no pride to be taken in work accomplished with the assistance of LLM's, even if that work is good.
- daemonologist 3y agoI don't think HN is sleeping on generative AI - it's been fairly prevalent near the top of the front page. I agree that some creative fields are going to start feeling real impacts, not necessarily because models have gotten super creative, but they're becoming more practical for rote tasks which otherwise might "pay the bills." For example, Google's recent work on style alignment: https://style-aligned-gen.github.io/ https://style-aligned-gen.github.io/ .
- nbzso 3y agoI used similar workflow in a SD with Control Net/Depth mapping in the summer. The key factor will be creating a distinctive style. You will need an experienced artist for this. Limitation of the dataset. With this technology prevalent, designers and artist will stop sharing publicly their work due to fear of AI giants stealing it. I expect serious legislation in place for generative visual AI. Copyright, etc.
- nbzso 3y agoSince when accessible tools are prerequisite for quality? Everybody can buy a pen or brushes. As an artist, designer and developer, I am more aware of generative AI than the average "prompter" who the startups are using for fine-tuning of the models and pays a hefty price for the "privilege". A good illustrator with AI and knowledge of composition, color, anatomy and real drawing skills will kick the B out of "everyone" who is prompting aspect ratios and the names of artists which work is represented/stolen in the data set. The big names in the business will jump to this "novelty" out of hype and cost optimization, only to realize that the results are limited by the dataset and the shiny average of styles actually cannot give serious brand differentiation. But hey, keep prompting, sorry, creating. You are not a part of the biggest Dunning-Kruger experiment to date. You are an artist, designer, composer, programmer and business owner. Good Luck.:)
- bossyTeacher 3y agoI hope so because we as a society are nowhere ready for a fully capable AI
- bossyTeacher 3y agoimo what is likely to happen in the short-term is that the bottom-end of the people in that field will see their salaries significantly reduced as the GenAI can do most of it at a much cheaper price. Doesn't even have to be as good, especially when it doesn't need to sleep, have breaks or raises to perform to the same or better standard. Some will accept the lower salary and suffer in silence, others will leave the field only to see many other fields experiencing the same phenomenon and thus still ending up in a low paid role somewhere anyway, while others will skill up to basically get away from the rising tide, this will increase the supply of skilled workers and bring salaries down for them all as a result of this and the fact that GenAI has already eaten a chunk of their work. Summary: everyone apart from the 1 %ers gets lower salaries
- echelon 3y agoThis is, in my humble opinion, a view based in fear, jealousy, and/or gatekeeping. Gating on accessibility ignores so many rough edges people experience. Opportunity cost, activation energy, learning gradients, community. We should want for people to encounter fewer stumbling blocks. Life is already complicated enough. Not everyone has the luxury of being able to spend 10,000 hours to manipulate a graphite tip on paper. Everyone has a human experience. Everyone lives a life of joy and pain. Everyone daydreams. And everyone can communicate feelings to others. Art is just one playful encoding of that. A specialized encoding with difficult runes that take time to learn. Asking someone to stick to pen and brushes is like trying to keep reading as a priestly Church ceremony. Making art should be as easy as playing a video game or telling a story to friends. It doesn't matter how you made it. It only matters how it made someone feel. More than anything, I think the artist will be the biggest beneficiary of these tools. They'll be able to do more with a smaller budget and fewer people. They'll be able to learn and experiment faster, and take their work down entirely new paths that were previously blocked. Webcomic and fanfiction authors will be film directors. Just give it time.
- ben_w 3y agoWhen I first learned about Bitcoin, I thought "this is interesting, but the person telling me this is using a 'numbers go up' graph to try to convince me to buy. They specifically, irregardless of the technology, smell like scammers". (That was at $250/BTC, so of course I have a certain level of regret from that which may cloud my thinking…) AI? I've been interested in it since the late 90s when I first learned that ANNs were an actual thing one could program and which could learn for themselves, but that just means I'm disappointed by seeing obvious scammers and grifters trying to make a quick buck from what I regard as a legit tech — and because I can see the bad actors, I can sympathise with people who want to sit it out, even though I won't.