5 ms·
I would think it would be hard to find a reasonable person who takes anything Musk says seriously anymore and yet plenty seem to.
by JohnFen 3y ago
I would think it would be hard to find a reasonable person who takes anything Musk says seriously anymore and yet plenty seem to.
- The_Colonel 3y agoIf you're not following Musk every day, and maybe just know he's the Tesla/rocket guy, why wouldn't you take him seriously? Somehow, this sounds like shifting blame from the liar to others ...
- JohnFen 3y agoI wasn't assigning or shifting blame for anything. I was just expressing that I am baffled by the reality.
- medvezhenok 3y agoThe reason people follow Musk is that even though he over-promises and under-delivers; the under-delivered product is still better than the alternatives (or at least was for a while). People are not complete fools and can learn to discount over-the-top rhetoric; sure, some people are harmed by believing everything verbatim, but those people also fall for scams, etc, etc. His statements are parsed as statements of intent more so than actual timeline commitments. We'll have FSD in 6 months = FSD is our main priority at the moment. And sure it also makes for PR/free advertising. Is it scammy? Probably. But he likely got more out of people by pushing this false narrative than would have been otherwise accomplished.
- JohnFen 3y agoI have real trouble with "the ends justify the means" arguments. > Is it scammy? Probably. It's the behavior of a con artist. > But he likely got more out of people by pushing this false narrative than would have been otherwise accomplished. Even if that's the case, he could have had the same, or better, effect without the lying. The lying is clearly aimed at gaining investment money and preorders, though, not at some bizarre attempt at motivating engineers.
- czl 3y ago> The lying is clearly aimed at gaining investment money and preorders, though, not at some bizarre attempt at motivating engineers. It would be dumb to be caught "lying" over and over and Musk is not know to be dumb. Consider the possibility Musk is using reflexivity to accelerate progress. When people become convinced something is possible and work towards that goal their strong belief changes reality because there is a feedback loop between reality and beliefs.
- DonHopkins 3y agoIt would be dumb to be caught agreeing with anti semitic tweets, and telling advertisers to "go fuck yourself", yet here we are. Your argument is invalid.
- czl 3y agoIntelligent people have faults and make mistakes like the rest of us. What sets them apart is they are often better at seeing this and fixing things. Did Musk not make amends for that tweet? Do you think advertising should control social media? Do you genuinely believe Musk is dumb?
- rpy 3y agoNo, he did not make amends. He never even apologised for it.
- czl 3y agoWho is on stage in this clip and what they are saying? https://youtu.be/xHZ-Dvv2cN4?si=VdmfLrcEq6AFm-7W https://youtu.be/xHZ-Dvv2cN4?si=VdmfLrcEq6AFm-7W
- jcranmer 3y ago"Dumb" isn't the word I'd use; "incurious" is better. It's not that he's racist or antisemitic, I believe, but rather he doesn't have enough knowledge of history to recognize classic antisemitic tropes (or signs that someone is an outright Nazi) combined with some beliefs close enough to racist that he's liable to agree with antisemitic creeds without recognizing them as antisemitic tropes.
- DonHopkins 3y agoTell that to the disembodied pulverized head that was attached to somebody who took his claims at face value, and try explaining to his widow that her late husband was a complete fool to fall for it, so it's not Musk's fault. The final 11 seconds of a fatal Tesla Autopilot crash: A reconstruction of the wreck shows how human error and emerging technology can collide with deadly results https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/interactive/2023/tesla-autopilot-crash-analysis https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/interactive/2023/t...
- DonHopkins 3y agoAnd I think it's safe to say that sycophants bending over backwards to carry Musk's water like DoesntMatter22 aren't reasonable people, don't base their opinions on facts or reality, and shouldn't be taken seriously.
- DoesntMatter22 3y agoWhat I've said is completely factual. Surprisingly a lot of people like who won't actually prove that he said that. Because the fact is that he didn't.