4 ms·
Good article, great photos. I sympathize with folks worried about changing their neighborhood. At the same time there's really no magic solution to high housi
by duxup 3y ago
Good article, great photos.
I sympathize with folks worried about changing their neighborhood. At the same time there's really no magic solution to high housing costs outside increasing supply.
- thrawa8387336 3y agoYeah, doesn't mean it needs to be in Santa Cruz, could be outside it.
- epistasis 3y agoAs a resident of Santa Cruz, we need a looooot more housing in Santa Cruz. And elsewhere too. But my concern is for the future of Santa Cruz and having some place for my children to live in the future, in an environmentally sustainable way.
- standardUser 3y agoThis entire country once decided they could just build stuff outside of the city and it led to endless bland sprawl, nightmare commutes and environmental devastation. Transitionally, Santa Cruzians don't like any of those things.
- bcrosby95 3y ago"Not in my city, in that other city," says every city, everywhere. Hence NIMBY: they aren't saying "no", just Not In My BackYard. The problem is everyone is saying this. So you have nowhere to build. Santa Cruz should not get special treatment - it will be offered the same deal as everyone else: build what is required to house people in the way you want, or build what is required to house people in the ways other people want.
- umeshunni 3y agothat's a very long way to just say N I M B Y
- gen220 3y agoYou could limit over-consumption of the existing supply by differentially property-taxing nonresident homeowners. That would lower property values + rents real quick. According to this site [1] the percentage of renters in SC in 2017 was 60%. [1]: https://noplacelikehome.ucsc.edu/makings-of-a-crisis/ https://noplacelikehome.ucsc.edu/makings-of-a-crisis/
- jeffbee 3y agoThat's backwards because it would torpedo the economy of building and operating rental apartments. You really want the opposite: a special tax for owner-occupiers.
- gen220 3y agoFine, you could limit the tax to buildings identified as single and multi-family homes? Most of those 60% are not living in rental apartments. What it would do is reduce the property value of existing real estate supply (by making expected cash flow from renting far less profitable), effectively forcing nonresident owners to sell their buildings to would-be renters, who would now be able to afford a mortgage on their homes. My thesis, fwiw, is that there's actually a sufficient supply of housing, it's just cornered with artificially inflated prices by people who treat housing as an investment vehicle rather than, well, housing.
- scottyah 3y ago"Existing supply" has nothing to do with building the apartment rentals, though the apartment operations economy would get hit and they might have to actually do some work somewhere. I believe the parent comment is about how many houses are stagnant because the owners have long since moved out, don't want to do any upgrades, and just cash checks from the next generation that has nowhere to buy since all the houses are rented out. I'm a bit bitter because there's so much of this around where I live, and it's just sad they're systemically incentivized to keep the next generations renting forever.
- bluGill 3y ago
- hrkfmud50k 3y agowhy is housing cost a problem that needs to be solved? there are plenty of inexpensive houses, they just don't happen to be in this beach town.
- scottyah 3y agoThis is a very short sighted take, but also housing costs are rising dramatically in places other than Santa Cruz.
- toss_me_sc 3y agoThere aren't any magic solutions, but I think there are a lot of ideas that could incentivize affordable housing for people who actually live here. A number of my neighbors are Prop 13 'princelings'. Their parents snapped up a bunch of housing, have next to 0 annual cost, and extract fantastic wealth renting them out, all while receiving a huge tax subsidy. This position passes to the next generation, who essentially become absentee landlords and are heavily incentivized to prevent more housing. A number of places in Santa Cruz and the rest of the county are completely underutilized because these families prefer to do absolutely nothing and collect insane rents on dilapidated properties to the detriment of everybody else who lives here.
- yterdy 3y agoI have less sympathy for people afraid of neighborhood change after having been pushed out of a neighborhood that changed (gentrified) anyway. In any case, I tend to think that outlawing for-profit ownership of multiple SFHs or multifamily units would actually go a long way toward increasing supply and dropping costs without building. Reduced centralized ownership means lowered capacity to play pricing and vacancy games. The real enemy of affordable housing is that so many people benefit from housing being unaffordable. Tell them to kick rocks and find another source of income at the federal/constitutional level, please.