8 ms·
Dropbox: How to opt out of 3rd party AI partner access to your Dropbox
- mtmail 3y agoIt was switched-off for me (based in Europe). Edit: based on their help page "In countries with the preferred language set to English. Excluding Canada, the UK (United Kingdom), and countries within the EEA (European Economic Area)." https://help.dropbox.com/view-edit/privacy-settings-dropbox-ai https://help.dropbox.com/view-edit/privacy-settings-dropbox-...
- jotaen 3y agoThanks for posting that link, that sheds a lot of light on this topic. I’m also in the EU, and the button was switched off for me too.
- jeffbee 3y agoI think this should be switched off, and against the law, but the tweet is hyperbolic. It specifically states that the data is not for training.
- rchaud 3y agoSo? What is preventing the company from just using it anyway and paying a fine later? The culture of these growthmaxxing companies pretty much ensures a philosophy of "don't ask for permission, ask for forgiveness".
- accrual 3y agoI didn't see the setting in my Dropbox account. Maybe because I have "Early access" disabled? Either way, not a fan of an opt-in setting that shares your data when it's supposed to just be a place to store files. > Get access to products and features that Dropbox is still testing and evaluating, and give feedback to help our product teams build the best final product.
- bluetidepro 3y agoJust turned it off in my account, appreciate the heads up/post. I can't stand when companies turn this type of thing "on" by default. Apple pulled the same thing with advertising settings a few iOS versions back.
- chankstein38 3y agoRight? I "understand" it but I don't understand it. It just ends up being gross and shady feeling and giving me a negative impression of the company that did it. I use dropbox, pay for the upgraded storage, and have for years. I love it. But they added some AI and decided I automatically wanted it. Makes me question whether I want to continue to be loyal to them.
- schaefer 3y agoI didn’t hear about that one. How can I check the new settings in my Apple account?
- bluetidepro 3y agoIt was back in 2018 or 2019, I believe. I THINK it was maybe iOS 15? Here is an old Verge article I found that you can check your settings: https://www.theverge.com/22309965/block-ad-iphone-data-how-to-tracking https://www.theverge.com/22309965/block-ad-iphone-data-how-t... - It was turning off "Personalized Ads" in your settings. I believe today in iOS 17 it lives in `Settings > Privacy > Apple Advertising`
- schaefer 3y agoThank you.
- dylan604 3y agowhy do you trust that the setting does anything?
- tmpz22 3y ago> I can't stand when companies turn this type of thing "on" by default. If you force people to do something they are more likely to do it then if you don't force them. Especially if they don't consent to doing it.
- nh2 3y ago(How) Can I turn that off for the entire company account?
- nh2 3y agoChanging the setting redirects me to "https://www.dropbox.com/team/admin/settings/ai https://www.dropbox.com/team/admin/settings/ai" in the Admin Console so I assume this controls it for the entire team.
- vlovich123 3y agoI can’t seem to find this setting. Is it getting rolled out slowly?
- barbazoo 3y agoIn Canada, I also couldn't find this setting.
- bonestamp2 3y agoIn the US, not seeing this either. I do have a free account though, not sure if that makes a difference.
- uxjw 3y agoI'm in Canada and I had it. I'm on a paid account.
- barbazoo 3y agoI stopped paying a long time ago before actually deleting my account today. So maybe the setting was implicitly turned on for non-paying customers. Wouldn't surprise me.
- ahartman00 3y agoUS here, I can't see it either. I noticed the tweet mentions European Data Protection Supervisor (EDPS), is this EU only?
- AdamH12113 3y agoMy company is in the US. I just checked and found that we have the setting in our admin console and it was on by default. We do have a paid business account.
- rytor718 3y agoTry going to your account then from the menu go to Settings > Third-party AI Heres what the link looks like for me in the US: https://www.dropbox.com/account/ai https://www.dropbox.com/account/ai Paid subscribers can see it in US, not sure whether it depends on the subscription tier though.
- keyanp 3y agoThis tweet is sort of misleading, the docs suggest this is basically them using an API to provide AI features: https://help.dropbox.com/view-edit/privacy-settings-dropbox-ai#What-information-is-shared-with-third-party-partners https://help.dropbox.com/view-edit/privacy-settings-dropbox-... > Your files within Dropbox are sent to a third-party AI only when you chose to interact with AI powered features. For example, when you ask a question about a file.
- tosh 3y ago> chose to interact with AI powered features puts the burden on the user to understand what an "AI powered feature" is
- cyanydeez 3y agoyeah, some of these posts take a weird tact on privacy. the switch prevents access to files via openai's API, but for that to be relevant you need to engage the Dropbox AI. really, the trouble is Dropbox is outsourcing your private files to a third party and masking that via a optin (in the US) toggle. I don't think users should have to worry that their service negotiated a invasive privacy process with a third party and they aren't being forthright about how it leaves the premise.
- barbazoo 3y agoReminded me to finally delete my account of... 15 years!!! Good riddance.
- wildpeaks 3y agoDirect link to the setting: https://www.dropbox.com/account/ai https://www.dropbox.com/account/ai
- wormius 3y agojust routes to /account/general for me, no ai, and no ai options. strange.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 3y agoSame for me. Are you a free user too? Might be that only Premium users get built in AI.
- cyanydeez 3y agoit's not built in AI, it's outsourced AI. this is basically Dropbox authorization of a third party to scan your files.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 3y agoI can't believe this is true, they would expose themselves to huge lawsuits doing that. I store sensitive medical files there. What if someone stored their baby's bathing videos and those got leaked?
- ragebol 3y agoSame for me? I'm in Europe, maybe that makes a difference perhaps?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- fredgrott 3y agobad UI and company design...one should NEVER EVER cause any user of any service to take extra actions to respect their rights and data. It should be the reverse...if you want to use AI or have AI use your data then you need to take extra steps... This is dark patterns all over again
- rchaud 3y agoDropbox crossed the bad UI rubicon for me when it limited upload speed on my free account to sub-dial up rates. This was in 2012. I just put everything in Google Drive and a USB stick and have never looked at DB again.
- thejohnconway 3y agoLimited your upload speed on a free account? I'd hardly call that a dark pattern.
- rchaud 3y agoThe transfer speed is slower than using Bluetooth. Free users would have dumped the tool immediately. What DB did was throttle the speed only after I had uploaded a set of files, and then bug me to upgrade to paid.
- waynesonfire 3y agoIt's not at all strange to me that Dropbox deployed this dark pattern. What really stood out to me is that, this post was made by the CTO of Amazon. > did I agree to this somewhere? The CTO of Amazon uses Dropbox?!
- crop_rotation 3y agoAmazon has no competitive consumer product to dropbox, and he rightfully might want to separate his work and personal data. Can't really expect one to use S3 as a dropbox replacement.
- dylan604 3y agoDoes Dropbox not use S3 as its backend? I would not be shocked to learn that it does
- ishanjain28 3y agoperhaps you should be a little shocked to hear if they are using s3(they are not). s3 is awesome but it's not supposed to be used absolutely everywhere.
- crop_rotation 3y agoWhether dropbox uses S3 or not is irrelevant. Dropbox and equivalents are much higher level products not replaceable with an object store.
- temp_praneshp 3y agoabsolutely not: https://www.infoq.com/articles/dropbox-magic-pocket-exabyte-storage/ https://www.infoq.com/articles/dropbox-magic-pocket-exabyte-...
- waynesonfire 3y agoHe is the CTO. He is in charge of Amazon Drive. He has the authority to implement any missing feature for his use-case.
- autoexec 3y agoPeople should be encrypting their files before uploading them to the cloud. Then it won't matter who your data is shared with.
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[dupe] / Related: Dropbox is sharing your files with AI partners without opt-in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38627751 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38627751
- zffr 3y agoThis is the description on Dropbox's website > Use artificial intelligence (AI) from third-party partners so you can work faster in Dropbox. We only use technology partners we have vetted. Your data is never used to train their internal models, and is deleted from third-party servers within 30 days.
- AdamH12113 3y agoFor people who can't or won't access Twitter, the setting for individual accounts is here: https://www.dropbox.com/account/ai https://www.dropbox.com/account/ai and the setting for team accounts in the admin console is here: https://www.dropbox.com/team/admin/settings/ai https://www.dropbox.com/team/admin/settings/ai Ours (for a US business account) was on by default. The text for the setting is: > Let team members use artificial intelligence (AI) so they can work faster in Dropbox. We only use technology partners we have vetted. Your organization’s data is never used to train their internal models, and is deleted from third-party servers within 30 days. There's a "learn more" link that goes here: https://help.dropbox.com/view-edit/privacy-settings-dropbox-ai https://help.dropbox.com/view-edit/privacy-settings-dropbox-... Dropbox claims that they "won’t let our third-party partners train their models on our user data without consent". The page further claims that the participation option is on by default for teams "participating in the Dropbox AI alpha", but I don't think we signed up for any such thing and the option was still on for us. I checked the settings and we are not currently enrolled. I have zero confidence that "consent" to use our data for model training won't also default to opt-in. The page further states that Dropbox currently has one AI partner -- OpenAI.
- jkaplowitz 3y agoI see no such setting, for my free personal account which is currently overfull and not syncing due to having previously had some temporary promotional space above my current limit. Is this setting not present for everyone? If relevant, I am currently in Germany, although my account was created in either the US or Canada (I forget which).
- hedora 3y agoDoing this without opt-in should be illegal. We need blanket minimum privacy protections at a national level, and they should treat internal repurposing of data the same as third party sharing. Since all major players in our industry have shown they can’t be trusted to curate large collections of sensitive data, inclusion in such internal datasets should be opt in as well. Dropbox is a poster child for “this should be E2E encrypted”, so, yes, I’m arguing they should get your explicit opt-in before they are allowed to store unencrypted data or escrow keys on their end, and that the opt-in shouldn’t be required to use their services.
- VWWHFSfQ 3y ago> Dropbox is a poster child for “this should be E2E encrypted” how would you implement some very trivial features like even being able to search though
- rvnx 3y agoAt least basic encryption. Remember one day, Dropbox forgot in production to check passwords of users. So you only had to enter email to access the Dropbox of the user (an open "log as" feature).
- YetAnotherNick 3y agoWhat do you mean by "basic encryption". Either dropbox could access our files or it couldn't without authentication from us. If it couldn't how would search or indexing work.
- ginsbergjason 3y agoThats crazy, do you know if there's an article about Dropbox breaking auth? Don't remember hearing about it.
- rvnx 3y agohttps://www.cnet.com/news/privacy/dropbox-confirms-security-glitch-no-password-required/ https://www.cnet.com/news/privacy/dropbox-confirms-security-...
- _jplc 3y agoPaying customer here: Mine was disabled, for the record.
- veg 3y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong but this seems like a poorly messaged setting and an overreaction by users on X. Sounds like they will use a commercial AI when you use Dropbox AI to ask about a document.
- rchaud 3y agoIn that case your organization account should make the decision on enablinng this capability, Dropbox should not have carte blanche to scan your content ahead of time.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- cyanydeez 3y agothe cost of indexing with an AI would be absurd. it's more likely a one off Clippy type service where it's only sending it to openAI when the user requests. still should be optin universally, but it's unlikely they're wasting compute scanning before a user even wants the service.
- wrs 3y agoYes, specifically they use the OpenAI API to implement their alpha AI features. https://help.dropbox.com/view-edit/privacy-settings-dropbox-ai https://help.dropbox.com/view-edit/privacy-settings-dropbox-...
- amilich 3y agoIt's enough of other companies making money on our data. That's why I started Skiff (end-to-end encrypted email/docs/drive/calendar)! It's harder to build products E2EE but you get long-term trust from users.
- Imnimo 3y agoThe tweet seems to contradict the screenshot.
- ginsbergjason 3y ago[flagged]
- shapenamer 3y agoI would like to check it out but I'm physically unable to select any product from the product drop down list... Not the most confidence inspiring thing I've seen.
- ginsbergjason 3y agoWhich browser are you using? Having trouble reproducing.
- shapenamer 3y agoFirefox https://streamable.com/5omhv0 https://streamable.com/5omhv0 Maybe I'm an idiot but I literally can't navigate your website lol.
- rambambram 3y agoI rsync my files to a local drive and FTP it to something remote, so no need for this. But I gotta say, that's a beautiful website!
- mrngm 3y agoLogged into Dropbox to see (EU based). Setting wasn't there. Clicking through to the quoted tweet, they also report further on in their thread: I created the account when I was in the US, but now in the EU. (https://twitter.com/Werner/status/1734898806708166709 https://twitter.com/Werner/status/1734898806708166709) In the "What's new" part within the Dropbox environment, I did find a note dated October 10, 2023: Quickly find the content you need with Dropbox AI Dropbox AI for search helps you get the information you need without the hassle of manually searching through Dropbox. Ask a question about your Dropbox content and get a response within seconds. You can also find the files you need with everyday language instead of searching by keywords, and search results now come with a brief summary of each file. Then, once you’ve opened individual files, Dropbox AI for file previews now lets you save time and effort by summarizing your content, from long documents to lengthy videos, into a clear and concise explanation with the click of a button. Dropbox AI is currently in alpha and available in the US in EN only for Dropbox Pro, Standard, Advanced, Essentials, Business, and Business Plus. Some features may be available soon for eligible non-US customers to test.
- sgbeal 3y ago> Logged into Dropbox to see (EU based). Setting wasn't there. FWIW, just checked mine (EU-based "pro" account), and the setting is there but was OFF. i have never specifically engaged any features regarding AI in dropbox. i do recall seeing a popup in the web interface sometime in the past month about having AI summarize file content and i closed the popup without tapping anything which remotely appeared to be a consent button.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rchaud 3y agoNitter link: https://nitter.net/Werner/status/1734890651378975007 https://nitter.net/Werner/status/1734890651378975007 It took a while, but the arc of history is starting to bend in favour of that guy who said 'just use rsync' on Drobox's Show HN post in 2007.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- capableweb 3y ago> It took a while, but the arc of history is starting to bend in favour of that guy who said 'just use rsync' on Drobox's Show HN post in 2007. It be interesting to see a breakdown on "time spent" between the people who went with Dropbox and started syncing stuff right away VS the people who first setup their own infrastructure to do the same thing.
- tinyhouse 3y agoWhat are you talking about? They have almost 20M paying users for a reason. Good luck asking all people in your company to use rsync.
- jacquesm 3y agoHe's talking about the fact that those people don't need to worry about third parties accessing their files without their consent.
- SoftTalker 3y agoI guess that depends on where you are rsync-ing to?
- throwup238 3y agoIt was FTP [1]. If only he had said rsync, we wouldn't be here now /s [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9224 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9224
- 3y ago
- sneak 3y agoIf you care about your data being private and not shared, why would you use a non-end-to-end-encrypted service like Dropbox in the first place, where the provider can see all of your data and share it as they please? Make the choice once, up front, and then you can’t be surprised by things like this.
- cynicalsecurity 3y agoMega encrypts everything by design. Why use corporate crap and keep up with their lying to you when you can use products that don't steal your data. I'm surprised Dropbox is still in business. At some point their fancy product name won't save them from the consequences of their lying to the customers.
- jacquesm 3y agoIf you click the setting to 'off' you are making the assumption that your stated desire will be honored and that there won't be another move like that in the future. The better move would be to stop using Dropbox, that way you are really sure that your files won't be accessed by unauthorized parties. I really don't get what drives companies like Dropbox to throw their carefully built up reputation under the bus like this.
- sorokod 3y agoGreed.
- jacquesm 3y agoIf true: what does OpenAI pay dropbox for access to their customers' files? And what kind of guarantees are there that OpenAI stays within the lines, because all of these AI companies are looking for as much non-AI tainted data as they can get their grubby little fingers on for training purposes.
- rubberband 3y agoIt's possible OpenAI doesn't get any money; and they just provide whatever "AI service" is being requested of them, and returns the results to Dropbox. And, well, if OpenAI just happens to gain access to a trove of data by providing the service... ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- cyanydeez 3y agomeh, I agree, don't trust future Dropbox, but the way it's explained is this switch stops any team member from using the alpha OpenAI integration to search files you have in drop box And since that integration has to send OpenAI your data, this switch prevents it. again, don't trust future drop box but the hidden switch here is willfully interacting with dropboxs' openAi integration.
- SteveNuts 3y ago
- Gys 3y ago> Your data is never used to train their internal models, and is deleted from third-party servers within 30 days. Sure, because they paid you money for access and are very trustworthy people.
- Gys 3y agoSeems optional opt out is EU only…
- throwaway5959 3y agoWhat the fuck?! How is this not opt-in?!
- shapenamer 3y agoJust checked my account and this option was on. Turned it off but it's completely unacceptable that it was on in the first place. If anyone has any good alternatives please let me know. Preferably encrypted options.
- neonnomad 3y agoThere are some options: Mega.io Proton Drive Rclone to your own encrypted bucket Mountain Duck / Cloud Mounter to your own encrypted bucket
- butz 3y agoOh, Proton Drive. When will they release a client for Linux? And when they will start adding AI to all Proton products?
- caconym_ 3y agoI use a synology NAS on my home network with syncthing over a wireguard tunnel for dropbox-esque functionality from anywhere (only problem is poor iOS support). Nightly snapshotting to backblaze.
- shapenamer 3y agoI've been looking at options, and while mega seems good they also seem to happily hand over your data to authorities, which means it's not really encrypted, or might as well not be. I've seen skiff shilled a few times here and on the twitter thread but the website is too annoying for me lol. Currently thinking I'm going to mess with filen.io tonight. It has a linux client and is e2e encrypted. Still looking and open to suggestions though.
- ginsbergjason 3y ago:'(
- Zuiii 3y agosyncthing. Open source, e2ee, and doesn't rely on some morally compromised "venture".
- hosh 3y agoIs there something similar to this for Google Drive?
- Velofellow 3y agoI just checked my company's account. Third Party AI-Integrations were defaulted to "On" despite our company having a paid personal account. My free personal account (still for work) does not have any active third party integration.
- pwb25 3y agoWat? Shouldn't it be the opposite way, that you turn this on? those SV companies are getting hubris
- vlovich123 3y agoSo to anyone wondering, I’m getting the sense is that the option is only available for paid / business accounts. My hunch is that the reason free accounts don’t see it is that they don’t get to opt out & are forced in - it wouldn’t make sense that they opt-in paid/ENT but then exclude free accounts altogether vs free accounts are opt-in and can’t choose. Alternatively, may be it isn’t relevant to free accounts because they don’t have access to AI-related features: https://help.dropbox.com/view-edit/privacy-settings-dropbox-ai https://help.dropbox.com/view-edit/privacy-settings-dropbox-... The data isn’t used for training, only for inference & DropBox and OpenAI pinky promise to delete any data sent to them within 30 days.
- dbmikus 3y agoI'd actually guess that free accounts don't have the "toggle AI" option because they just disable AI inference for free users. LLM inference is pretty expensive.
- cyanydeez 3y agodefinitely. for a group of hackers, it's difficult to understand not seeing the play: Dropbox engaged OpenAI to process files a user requests to "understand" or search. then the files are sent. the switch would stop this. imagine the wasted compute if the AI just went and scanned everything. this is a adhoc service one-off. definitely turn it off if you don't want your files scanned by OpenAI. but the cost of moving everyones file to an AI would be absurd.
- pmags 3y agoI have a free account and this option was turned on by default (with the option to disable it). Talk about scummy....
- nathants 3y agothe best way to do this is with: https://cryptomator.org https://cryptomator.org
- edrxty 3y agoMETA: Why is this not on the front page? It has more points than almost every other story and less time than most.
- caconym_ 3y agoThe best way to opt out of Dropbox's abusive practices is to pull all your data out into a self-hosted or trustworthy e2e solution and close your account. You should need no more proof than this incident that Dropbox will not ask you before doing things with your data that you would have strenuously objected to if they had.
- millzlane 3y agoIs there any recourse for users?
- jay_kyburz 3y agoIt's weird that Dropbox would want to pay Open AI to do whatever it is they are doing on everyone’s files, without knowing if a use will ever use or see that feature. It sounds like a premium feature that you would want a user to have to manually enable.
- hungrigekatze 3y agoI have no doubt that this "feature" is a backroom deal worth millions because OpenAI is running out of public internet data with which to improve its models. (See this paper from researchers at MIT and a few other schools which predicts that high-quality text training data will be 'used up' by 2026: https://arxiv.org/abs/2211.04325 https://arxiv.org/abs/2211.04325 ) Think of all of the email, Google Docs, and other data that Alphabet has that it can use to train and improve its models. OpenAI has limited ways to get non-public text data unless Microsoft is giving them some data from Office users, Hotmail users. Just my two cents. And whatever Dropbox is doing with retrieval augmented generation (RAG) / "new+better search" with the OpenAI APIs: I'm certain it could be done with less latency and probably would cost less if the RAG 'feature' / 'new search' was built in house at Dropbox.
- blitzar 3y agoWhy dont OpenAI just deploy The Box (TM)?
- greyface- 3y agoI noped out of Dropbox when they started requiring the installation of a kext for the macOS client to function - it signaled a lack of respect for the boundary between my system/data and theirs. This news has me feeling vindicated in that decision.
- LeoPanthera 3y agoWhat could it possibly need a kext for? I use SyncThing to sync my files and it doesn't even need to be root!
- greyface- 3y agoThe stated reason was to implement a feature called "Dropbox Infinite" that downloaded files on demand when first accessed, rather than syncing everything ahead of time.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pmarreck 3y agoNever liked Dropbox from the get-go for some reason, and things like this keep proving my intuition right
- Havoc 3y agoThe fact that this is necessary or opt out for that matter blows my mind
- j45 3y agoI’m kind of surprised why paid users wouldn’t be default opted out? Am I missing something about being customer centric to force them to work for free for your software to manage it in addition to paying for it? I understand how this might be in Dropboxes to let third parties create “synthetic data” of users proprietary data. Using it “at my request” for my benefit is the first step. Maybe Dropbox could just opt put off their partners to not keep their customers information. I didn’t think this would be the thing that got me to cancel and move Dropbox to something slower like Sync.com, but here we go.
- rkagerer 3y agoIt was ON by default in my personal, paid Dropbox Plus account (in Canada). https://i.imgur.com/qUKdMcB.png https://i.imgur.com/qUKdMcB.png I'm incensed about this. I guarantee I never activated this setting or anything remotely like it, or ever used any features that would justify it. This really crosses a line for me.
- Zuiii 3y agoThis is why rsync or it's user-friendly counterpart syncthing better. Seems like that old comment did have a point after all. Glad I never gave in and used this nonesense.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rkagerer 3y agoSee also: Dropbox spooks users with new AI features that send data to OpenAI when used https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2023/12/dropbox-spooks-users-by-sending-data-to-openai-for-ai-search-features/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2023/12/dropb...
- derpiederpie 3y agoGoodbye Dropbox. You don't by default turn on customer-exploitative features. That's abusive.
- RagnarD 3y agoI stopped using Dropbox years ago after they had the gall to delete some of my files and email a warning that pirated files weren't permitted. Except that they weren't pirated files - they were MP3s ripped from my own CDs for my own personal use. That's when I realized that they actually scan your files and there was no privacy, completely unacceptable. For some years I've used Sync.com, which is vastly better, but sadly their software and systems are completely broken once you get beyond a certain total size of file data (probably around 1TB, but they're happy to take your money for much more space, which can't be used because of their system bugs.)