3 ms·
> It is baffling how many HNers in this thread don't understand what "test flight" means. I've been seeing parallels to this growing at an odd rate. Where con
by godelski 3y ago
> It is baffling how many HNers in this thread don't understand what "test flight" means.
I've been seeing parallels to this growing at an odd rate. Where context is removed and HN only cares about results at TRL ~7.5+. Its often quite baffling to see systems/models designed in academic spaces with minimal compute resources to systems/models with billions of parameters and millions of dollars in funding. Or to see TRL 2/3 projects be dismissed because they are not >TRL 6. I wonder how people that make these types of responses think research and development happens if you must catapult one's self from a theory to usable product in a realistic environment before it becomes of any interest. It seems rather anti-scientific tbh. Not what I'd really expect from a crowd dominated by developers, engineers, researchers, and scientists.
As for rockets, well... exploding rockets are expected during testing phases. Obviously you want to reduce this, but catastrophic failures, or any failure, serve as great learning opportunities due to the inability to formulate a complete model (combustion instability is a notoriously difficult problem).
I think also many are interested in the subject and so do watch videos and read other sources but that these are at high level discussions and often not getting into the low level nuance that is actually necessary for solving these types of problems. But that as humans we often conflate excitement and time with a subject with expertise in that subject (all time is not equal). Personally I wonder if this is an accurate and general phenomena and exacerbated by our growing information age combined with the large number of armchair science communicators. I think all nerds, including myself, have been guilty of asserting things as facts (or with stronger confidence than they should be), often in an effort to help inform others or simply wishing to participate.
On a side note: anyone feel like it's a bit weird how low (aerospace) engineers are paid in comparison to us in software? Like not bad wages overall but there is a large gap (not looking to get my pay decreased, but the other way around)
Blue Origin: 85k/119k/162k (bottom 10%/Median/Top 10%)(https://spacecrew.com/salaries/blue-origin-salary https://spacecrew.com/salaries/blue-origin-salary)
SpaceX: 69k/112k/178k (https://spacecrew.com/salaries/spacex-salary https://spacecrew.com/salaries/spacex-salary)
- itsoktocry 3y ago>On a side note: anyone feel like it's a bit weird how low (aerospace) engineers are paid in comparison to us in software? Software produces gobs of money, the likes of which the world has never seen. Aerospace as an industry may not ever be profitable. It's as easy as that.
- godelski 3y agoIt doesn't seem as simple as that considering revenues are above $700bn. Plus, it's not like the defense industry is considered small by any means. I'm willing to bet everyone you know (or nearly) has flown in an airplane. I'm definitely not an economist but googling around it doesn't seem like the difference in revenues is an order of magnitude. But I'm willing to believe I'm misinterpreting and/or didn't look hard enough (most certainly the latter is true). I definitely agree that software is more profitable, but the gap is a bit surprising, especially considering the high skills and training required.
- kevin_thibedeau 3y agoSoftware has almost zero overhead beyond base line business expenses. Anything that requires making real stuff depends on many more people to produce the product. They all need to be paid which means engineers and management need to take a smaller slice of the pie.
- godelski 3y agoSure but I always have a hard time comprehending these arguments tbh. Because I honestly can't tell the difference between someone who has a billion dollars and someone who has 200 billion dollars. There's essentially no difference other than a number. But while writing this I decided to check instead of making what I thought was a reasonable assumption. Apparently the net worth of the CEOs of Boeing, Lockheed, and Raytheon are under $100m? That's a bit surprising if the numbers I googled are accurate. That would make the net worth of the two primary shareholders of BMW 1000x their counterparts. Each! I scrolled through Forbes billionaires and I didn't find aerospace anywhere but I did find pig breeding, shipping, and Chick-fil-A, candy, soy sauce, videogames, legos, in-n-out, dental implants, "Star Wars", "Billboards", and even "drones". Especially considering that there's a lot of shipping on there and a drone billionaire. Really makes me think some of the other things are over priced tbh. Especially with how many crypto-bros are on that list. Edit: Wait! "762 Charles Edelstenne" is listed as "aviation" but he cofounded Dassault... Edit 2: "868 Neal Blue & family" is listed as "Defense" for General Atomics and "871 Eren Ozmen" as "Aerospace" for Sierra Nevada. "916 Fatih Ozmen" also for Sierra Nevada. So okay, maybe some are on this list but my intuition suggested defense and aerospace would have at least someone in the top 100. Surprised not even the top 500. All of them under $4bn btw
- dr-detroit 3y ago[dead]
- dotnet00 3y agoI think salaries aren't as crazy as software because the while there is high demand and limited supply, there is also a limited selection of places you can do that kind of work at, while computer people have a spot in basically everything.
- godelski 3y agoYeah I suspect the lack of competition and difficulty to enter the market as a new player make it difficult for employees to demand higher wages.
- nick222226 3y agoYes it's weird, but it has been that way for a long time. Since I reviewed the salary statistics for my college when choosing majors in ~2008 even.
- resolutebat 3y agoFor anybody else wondering, "TRL" is NASA's Technology Readiness Level, ranging from TRL 1 (pie in the sky) to TRL 9 (flight proven mission operations). https://www.nasa.gov/directorates/somd/space-communications-navigation-program/technology-readiness-levels/ https://www.nasa.gov/directorates/somd/space-communications-...