3 ms·
> all of us, eventually, will become the old, sick, boring option. And? As the french say: the young congregate in groups, older people in couples, and the eld
by 082349872349872 3y ago
> all of us, eventually, will become the old, sick, boring option.
And? As the french say: the young congregate in groups, older people in couples, and the elderly are solitary.
> ... high trust communities in which people felt safe leaving their doors unlocked and people really did look out for one another.
False dichotomy: you can have this and have small independent households (and have a high GNP). It just takes a culture (as opposed to Ms Perry's?) where people are, generally, considerate.
(If Ms Perry fears being lonely, I would suggest that avoiding making unsolicited comments about other peoples' life choices often makes one better company.)
- throw1234651234 3y agoNot by choice on the last point, nor is it good for them given the studies / anecdotal evidence of Japanese people with life-long friends being the happiest. I have aging parents and friends with aging parents, and they become isolated, lonely, and desperate, and this isn't by choice.
- 082349872349872 3y agoWhat interests do they have?
- throw1234651234 3y agoA ton - they are all active in every sense: Fitness, photography, coding, engineering, mechanics, etc.
- 082349872349872 3y agoFitness and photography both sound like it'd be easy to meet up with like-minded folks. (my village has several fitness circles of varying sorts, and I think I've seen photography classes being offered locally; they're definitely on offer 15 minutes away) Coding, engineering, and mechanics sound more difficult: how distant are their nearest makerspaces?
- mfoy_ 3y agoThe "considerate culture" you are advocating for is only possible when the material conditions for poverty are absent. You need a really strong social safety net. Poverty is more strongly correlated with criminality than any other factor. If you want a world where everyone can feel safe leaving their door unlocked then you need a world where no one is left behind. The problem with liberalism is that it is an individualistic ideology and the further we have gone down that road (now, neo-liberalism) with austerity and cost-cutting measures, the social safety net is bad and only getting worse. What we need is socialism.
- sumtechguy 3y ago> What we need is socialism. all in on monopolies. not good either.
- 082349872349872 3y agoWe do have a really strong social safety net. (as I said, Ms Perry's culture and mine are probably very opposed on this point)
- netbioserror 3y ago>False dichotomy: you can have this and have small independent households (and have a high GNP). It just takes a culture (as opposed to Ms Perry's?) where people are, generally, considerate. This is a prescriptive statement masquerading as a descriptive one. Saying a considerate society is high trust does not will into reality either considerateness or a high-trust social fabric, neither of which you've demonstrated to be mutually dependent.
- 082349872349872 3y agoExistence proof: my continental european society is high trust; my best guess as to why this is the case is considerateness. (but "education" here refers not only to strengthening technical and academic skills, "savoir-faire", but also to strengthening soft skills, "savoir-vivre"; ymmv) If you have more plausible mechanisms, I'm all ears. PS. I'm not attempting to will this into existence in the UK context; just pointing out that it does exist outside the UK context.