3 ms·
For music, that's just not true. AAC is widely supported and sounds transparent to me; I'm not sure if I could detect SBC at high bitrates either. For voice/HF
by lxgr 3y ago
For music, that's just not true. AAC is widely supported and sounds transparent to me; I'm not sure if I could detect SBC at high bitrates either.
For voice/HFP, I agree, and LC3 can't arrive soon enough. I'm actually really surprised Apple doesn't use anything proprietary/better than mSBC for their AirPods.
- Kirby64 3y agoI suspect the GP meant for voice. It’s just atrocious no matter what for any device, due to the HFP restriction.
- dgrcode 3y agoYes, with the A2DP profile (high quality music) things work good enough for me not to notice. Maybe you could hear some differences on a side to side comparison, but it's good enough. The real problem comes with the HFP profile. Lack of decent codecs, and bandwidth limitations of Bluetooth make it really hard to solve. Not to mention the vast majority of devices you own can't upgrade codecs, or just won't because there aren't incentives.
- lxgr 3y agoOpus provides excellent voice quality at 10 kbps (less than 1/6th of what PCM uses at 8 kHz), at a latency of 26.5 ms, so it's definitely not a technical problem for HFP either. There's always the risk of unknown patent claims, but the same is true for any other codec not older than 15 or so years.
- dgrcode 3y agoI actually didn't know about Opus, but having read a bit about it, how aren't we using that codec for all things audio? It's open source, has good platform support, quality seems to similar to AAC, it could be used for HPF. What's stopping the adoption of Opus in Bluetooth standards?
- lxgr 3y agoSupposedly Google's Pixel Buds support it! I can only suspect why it's still so rare, but my guess would be either a fear of unknown patent claims, a lack of readily available hardware implementations, or a combination of both.
- dgrcode 3y agoI have the pixel buds A-series, and using my pixel 7a I can feel the quality going down when on a call. It might be just the latest buds, or my pixel 7a not supporting the codec, or the HFP not being set to use it ¯\_(ツ)_/¯