6 ms·
Don't Mourn the Space Shuttle. Privatize Interstellar Exploration.
- bane 15y agoI flew in from New York last night and saw the Shuttle sitting on top of its 747 at the end of the taxiway. Awe inspiring and very sad for me to see. The entire plane literally jumped out of their seats to look out the windows on the side of the plane with the view (while the flight attendants hopelessly told us not to unbuckle). But then I read about the pending Dragon missions to the ISS and I suddenly feel more hopeful than ever before and even the sniff of an asteroid mining company in the news today has me ecstatic. I feel like a boy again, watching shuttle launches on TV and excited about the future of space. It's a great feeling to have after so many years of seeing it all get pissed away. I think Tyson is wrong here in a way http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3_F3pw5F_Pc http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3_F3pw5F_Pc, he needs to be spending his energies promoting commercial space development and just move on from the NASA model. It'll be better, 30 or 40 years from now, to look back at NASA like we look back on ARPANet today -- as an interesting high risk R&D project that lead to transformative technologies that revolutionized humanity.
- wlesieutre 15y agoOn the other hand, there are plenty of reasons that NASA could still be important moving forward. Commercial launch vehicles might be the way to go, but commercially funded space telescopes sound less likely. I don't see any organizations better suited to work on space research, and Tyson would be pretty disappointed if we stopped it.
- nkoren 15y agoJust so. NASA's truly great impact has been with the Hubble, Cassini, Voyager probes, Mars Exploration Rovers, etc. There's certainly no commercial interest in the foreseeable future for doing missions like that, and I certainly think its important that those kind of projects (and the primary R&D behind them) to continue (and proliferate!). That should be NASA's job. Where NASA went wrong, however, was in trying to build its identity around the frankly rather prosaic business of trucking stuff to and around space. That's what the private sector really ought to be doing, with NASA as its most mind-blowing customer. I'm very excited to see things heading in that direction.
- jaredsohn 15y agoWhile NASA's greatest impact from a scientific standpoint has been through those programs, its greatest impact from a "get people excited about space so that they'll fund NASA" standpoint has come from the shuttle program, which is why NASA has spent so much money and resources on it over the years. Edit: I referred to the shuttle program because it is the means through which we've gotten humans into space for awhile and I was contrasting it with the other list of programs.
- nkoren 15y agoAh, that's the "no Buck Rogers, no bucks" school of thought -- which, actually, I agree with. There are several reasons why humans in space are a good and necessary thing, but as you say, people just need to relate back to the human experience in order to get excited enough to fund the thing. The error you/NASA made is in believing that this excitement came from the shuttle program itself. No, it came from having humans in space, and the shuttle just happened to be the only way for Americans to do that. This doesn't mean that the excitement ever came from the shuttle. Commercial vehicles such as the CST-100, Dragon, Dream Chaser, etc., will also all take people to space -- not only the same sort of astronauts who flew on the shuttle, but a far greater diversity of private astronauts as well. I'm certain that this will only get people more excited about space.
- bane 15y ago"Commercial vehicles such as the CST-100, Dragon, Dream Chaser, etc., will also all take people to space -- not only the same sort of astronauts who flew on the shuttle, but a far greater diversity of private astronauts as well. I'm certain that this will only get people more excited about space." Yes exactly. Becoming an Astronaut has always been for a select, highly qualified few. And it comes with tremendous terrestrial sacrifices. Commercial travel suddenly makes is possible for anybody who can buy a ticket (and can sign the waiver forms) to go somewhere in space. More importantly, the kinds of jobs that we've been putting our astronauts to work on seem mostly like their terrestrial equivalents of "truck driver", "construction worker", "janitor" and now with asteroid mining "miner". Some of those are high risk jobs here on Earth, but there's never been a shortage of people willing to do them in the commercial sector. There's no reason that those job categories require the creme-de-la-creme from humanity...with multiple Masters and Phds, decades in the military with multiple medals for bravery. That model came from the 50's. Let's look for the guys that'll go to Afghanistan and drive a truck to deliver cigarettes to a remote Operating Base, or build whiskey bars in the Arctic. That's the new model for these kinds of space jobs. Hardy pioneer types with a healthy survival instinct and pants full of bravery.
- lutorm 15y agoYou hear much less about it, but NASA is still funding space telescopes. Big projects like JWST, LISA, WFIRST, and Constellation-X have a hard time these days, but the Explorer-class programs are pretty active.
- bane 15y agoAbsolutely agree, but imagine if the total dollars going into space were a thousand times what they are today, because commercial activity could generate that with mining operations, space hotels, pharma work, whatever. Then a 1% share of that going back into high risk R&D and exploration (which is really what NASA's profile is) would be 10 times what it is today -- and it wouldn't be sliced up into non-high risk R&D that NASA spends too much time and money on today, like better space toilets. And with a potentially large commercial infrastructure in place, assembling a NASA exploration gadget could be done at a fraction of the cost. NASA could in fact do many times the R&D in such an environment and make many Tysons very happy indeed.
- andrewfelix 15y agoI don't really understand the Space Shuttle nostalgia. As a kid growing up it was such a disappointment. It looked bad ass. It looked like it could take off and land under it's own power. It looked independent and manoeuvrable. In short it looked like a spaceship. But in reality it needed giant external boosters to get anywhere. It had to have most of it's shielding replaced and be delicately positioned vertically before every launch. When it came into land it was an unimpressive glide. The rockets and modules of past made so much more sense to me, they got people onto the moon. They got rovers onto mars and took photos of distant moons. I'm kind of glad the shuttle is gone. It was an expensive and disappointing distraction. I often wonder what NASA would look like today if it had gone in a different direction.
- rollypolly 15y agoDon't forget the political context of the cold war space race. A good looking spaceship made for great propaganda. Even the soviets tried to copy it.[1] [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buran_%28spacecraft%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buran_%28spacecraft%29
- hahainternet 15y agoThere's much debate about this issue, and it's hard to come down on one side or the other, but the Shuttle had unique capabilities that no other system has had. Imagine building the ISS without the shuttle, for example. Imagine servicing Hubble. Imagine returning large objects from orbit safely. The shuttle cost NASA a lot of money that's true, but it cost the US relatively little, and NASA did a bunch of truly amazing things with it. There's good reason to be nostalgic.
- redthrowaway 15y ago"Interstellar" travel will likely never happen. The distances involved are so vast as to boggle the mind. Private ventures offer the promise of opening up space, but they won't break physics. Like it or not, we as a species are stuck here, likely forever.
- ktizo 15y agoNever is a much longer time than the distances involved.
- FD3SA 15y agoAll well and good...assuming that human life spans cannot be extended significantly. Fortunately, there are some very smart people who disagree with that assumption [1][2]. 1. http://www.sens.org/ http://www.sens.org/ 2. http://halcyonmolecular.com/ http://halcyonmolecular.com/
- sien 15y agoWith known physics we could do interstellar travel: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Orion_(nuclear_propulsion)#Interstellar_missions http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Orion_(nuclear_propulsi... It would be unbelievably expensive right now however. But give it a century or two and things could well change. If a space elevator was built it would slash the cost.
- drewblaisdell 15y ago"Never happen" =/= "never in our lifetime"
- InclinedPlane 15y agoSuch pessimism has nothing to do with fundamental limitations. Once humanity has had perhaps centuries of experience with orbital habitats then the idea of a large "generational" starship won't seem so unlikely. With functional fusion power and highly efficient recycling systems the ability to have an interstellar city ship which spends hundreds or thousands of years isolated from the rest of civilization may not seem so unlikely. Also consider that interstellar space holds far more destinations than we have currently cataloged. Begin with a colony near a comet out in the deepths of the Oort cloud. Then make a hop to another comet, free roaming planet, brown dwarf, or red dwarf that is very likely to be within a single light year distant. At each destination repair, refuel, resupply and move on. In a time span of only a fraction of the age of human civilization significant populations of humans will spread out from our Solar System and diffuse through interstellar space.
- guelo 15y agoLibertarian triumphalism always strikes me as so naive. Does anyone think SpaceX would be possible without decades of taxpayer funded research? Or the freaking Web for that matter. Ground breaking research always seems to be funded by society at large and then spat upon as inefficient and stupid by the manly men who will now make a profit off of it.
- rrc 15y agoIt would happen if there was enough demand for it, just like the first power plant, the first radio, the first car, the first steam engine, etc. None of these items were developed in a vacuum; it's almost impossible to separate private and public contributions once you start talking about education and the public safety/infrastructure that created the right environment, but I don't think it's fair to imply SpaceX would never have happened without NASA or other public research. History, at least, has presented some counterexamples.
- nkoren 15y agoNobody is spitting on the ground-breaking research that NASA has done, and Elon Musk takes every opportunity he gets to thank NASA for doing that research and making their results available to him. For the Shuttle, however, that research occurred in the early 1970s. The $200B that has since been spent flying the shuttle did not constitute ground-breaking research in any respect. It's simply operating a tragically expensive space truck. I'm thrilled to see the back of it, and hope that this will allow NASA to return to its primary mission of doing ground-breaking research, while buying its space truck services far more cheaply on the open market.
- iRobot 15y agoWell said.
- iwwr 15y agoConsider that the same money could have paid several times over for a Mars Direct style program and permanent stay on Mars. The key to Mars (as opposed to the Moon) is being able to make your fuel from the Martian atmosphere, with an input of (solar?) power and some materials brought from Earth (5-25% of total mass). That means vastly cheaper upper stage, allowing for a for a continuous presence for a fraction of the Shuttle budget. More here http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uDWvsdEYSqg http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uDWvsdEYSqg Also, a presentation on Mars Direct http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T52-Qu78TjQ&feature=BFa&list=PLB6267A7EB77E4A89 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T52-Qu78TjQ&feature=BFa&#...
- rbanffy 15y ago"Interstellar"?! Aren't we feeling overly optimistic today? With current technology (and not inventing too much new physics) interstellar travel takes so long that, in order to be an effective investment, it would require an out of this world ROI. Say you can launch an expedition to the closest solar system for a billion dollars (NASA certainly can't, but we are talking privatization) and have it return to Earth in four (I want to keep my numbers round) hundred years. In order to be preferable to US Treasure bonds (generally considered a lame option, but we are thinking very long-term), our expedition would have to bring back about about 3.7 billion dollars worth of stuff. The billion dollar figure and the 400 years period are both ludicrously optimistic. In order to be back in 400 years, you'd have to fly at 0.02c meaning you'd have to spend 18,000,000,000 Joules per gram of spacecraft for each delta-v. That's 72 GJ, or 20 MWh per gram. And that's with a 100% energy efficient propulsion system (which would require some new - and very fancy - physics anyway).