3 ms·
Google’s Stock-Split Plan Would Replace Stewardship With Dictatorship
- waqf 15y agoSergey, Larry and Eric already have majority control of the company between them, so what difference does the stock split make? I can understand disapproving of the dual-class stock structure on principle, but I don't see why people are suddenly getting upset now.
- Zombieball 15y agoI am quite inexperienced in the world of stocks but out of curiosity is it possible to see the relative power of current shareholders somewhere (e.g. Larry owns 10%, Mr. X owns 3%, etc.)?
- jedberg 15y agoIt's not totally straightforward. You can start here: http://finance.yahoo.com/q/ir?s=GOOG+Insider+Roster http://finance.yahoo.com/q/ir?s=GOOG+Insider+Roster But if you look there you'll see that Sergey currently owns no shares, probably because they're all in a trust.
- dpark 15y agoThe split doesn't actually make a difference. What makes a difference is the stock they issue after the split. They want to create this new class specifically so that issuing new stock will not dilute their control (even though it will dilute everyone's ownership). Basically, they found that the current dual-class structure isn't sufficient to guarantee control if they keep diluting when they issue grants to employees or pay for acquisitions with new stock. So how do you fix that? Well, you could buy up stock equal to the new stock you issue, but that costs cash. Instead you could just stop issuing stock that come with voting rights, which is what they're doing. Keep issuing stock, but just don't grant voting rights with it. If the new stock works, that will be most or even all of what they issue going forward, guaranteeing that they will maintain majority control so long as they don't sell (too much).
- sirclueless 15y agoWhile I agree in principle with this article's point that non-voting stock makes more likely the possibility of an iron-clad grip by irresponsible dictators, I don't think it is unconscionable or "evil" in Google's case. Much of the innovation that I appreciate most coming from Google appears financially irresponsible from the outside looking in. When Google first went public my concern was that it would lose its ability to have its engineers working on hundreds of long-shot projects with no projected revenues, and a management that is open and accepting of innovation in all of its forms. If the decision-makers at Google were only interested in squeezing the most out of Google's bottom line, then there would be strong arguments to shut all of that down, which I think would be unconscionable: a massive waste of potential, on a scale that only a multi-billion dollar corporation can be capable of.
- sjwright 15y agoDictatorship is a pretty stupid word to use. You can sell your stock in Google at any time.
- sjwright 15y agoGoogle sold non-voting stock. People bought non-voting stock. What the fuck is the problem?
- tptacek 15y agoYet another Wired article optimized for rageviews. Also, someone should explain to Wong what the word "replace" means. It does not, for instance, mean "failure to adopt the policy decisions of a Sao Paolo stock exchange, or to adopt a corporate structure that presages 'current discussions in the UK about stewardship'". It means "removing what was previously there and putting something different in its place".