4 ms·
I was chatting with a studio manager at a post f/x house when he received a demo reel that immediately was relocated to the trash without viewing it. I called h
by dylan604 3y ago
I was chatting with a studio manager at a post f/x house when he received a demo reel that immediately was relocated to the trash without viewing it. I called him on it about not even looking at it before rejecting it. He had me take it out of the trash to play it. Before it stared, he told me exactly what would be on the tape and the order of the clips, which is exactly what was on the tape. He said it was the fall semester with such and such teacher at the school, and every submission was exactly the same. They were just the class assignments made into a demo reel.
Everyone of these generative AI demo pages feels exactly like that. Nothing new other than we've done the same thing as someone else type of releases.
Now, I'm willing to say I'm jaded, so if this represents something we haven't already seen umpteengillion times already, where did they bury the lede? It's all still uncanny valley. The wheels on do not look real. The wake from the viking's vacuum does not look real. I'm not sure what the corgi is walking on, but it doesn't look like the ground.
- echelon 3y agoThat studio manager will be out of a job in five years if he doesn't get on the bandwagon and evolve. This is the film to digital transition. It's going to be rough for a bit, then take over everything all at once. The upside for these editors is that they'll be able to be single-person studios and pursue their own vision without meddling from studios or massive capital, equipment, and personnel needs.
- dylan604 3y agoHa! I took a phone call back when I was in the shiny round disc business that said based on the prices we were quoting, that we'd be out of business in a year because Apple released DVD Studio Pro. Instead, we gained even more business from people that tried to have their projects done in DVDSP, but then ran into road blocks making it impossible to do the job. They'd then come back to us, and receive an even higher quote since now there is even less time before their deadlines. cie la vie. You say out of business. I say, mediocrity all the way down from here.
- echelon 3y ago> You say out of business. I say, mediocrity all the way down from here. Feels "Old man yells at cloud." There will be lots of garbage, for sure, but more people than ever before will have access to creation. Becoming a director means getting access to a very limited playing field. Very few domestic productions get greenlit per year due to the intense financial, logistical, and personnel requirements. Very few people are able to make the opportunity cost sacrifice to learn the tools and people network. For all the people that write fan fiction, web comics, or have a DeviantArt, Itch.io, or Newgrounds, this is going to give them access to their own personal Miyazaki/Scorsese tooling. It's going to be awesome seeing passionate people finally have access.
- dylan604 3y ago> Feels "Old man yells at cloud." It much more like, old man has sat through many a product demo and seen the brochures, but what's in the box rarely matches. If this is what's being demoed as the examples they've culled together, the tech is lacking.
- CyberDildonics 3y agoAnyone with a few hundred dollars can buy mics, steady cams, action cams and more off of amazon that would give them quality above the black and white or 16mm film that some directors started out on. Anyone could go and make their own clerks or reservoir dogs and some people are going out and trying. Where are all the incredible movies? Even forgetting the tools where are all the incredible scripts since everyone has access to books on script writing and a computer?
- echelon 3y agoWe always debate this topic, CyberDildonics. You were wrong last time you debated me on AI porn. It's here [1, 2]. Movies are next. > Anyone with a few hundred dollars can buy mics, steady cams, action cams and more off of amazon that would give them quality above the black and white or 16mm film that some directors started out on. I've been down this path, and frankly it sucks. The task: tell a visual story. The current process: script, edit, break down with AD, location scout, secure filming rights to a location, go to a rental house and get equipment, get insurance, find camera crew that can handle it, rent lights, get gels, go to a prop house, pick props, rent props, transport props to set, set dec, run electrical, light set, do blocking, rehearse, film, retake, film, reset, capture photons, smear pixels around with an editing package for three months. This ceremony freaking sucks. It's so far divorced from the objective at hand, it's more primitive than punch cards, and nothing is reusable. I absolutely hate it. And I've always hated it. It needs to die. These steps have nothing to do with storytelling. It's vestigial and is an artifact of our primitive technologies. The task is to convey visual stories. Not to play dress up, logistics, and awkward gridded photon capture. Anyway, movies are next. I'll eat my hat if they're not. The current filmmaking process is as dumb as bloodletting. And it feels about the same. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32711614 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32711614 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35523656 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35523656
- youssefabdelm 3y agoAgree... they'll definitely evolve and get better, we're in the floppy disk era, but so far they suck. Nothing but weird motion, a shitty echo of mainstream / stock footage. I also get the sense that in the early days where data curation matters, research teams need to hire curators that can siphon good from bad examples. E.g. don't train on shit stock footage, pick up a book on fine art photographers, train on that shit + good films and you'll get a pretty good model. In the future I suspect curation will matter less and less because in the limit you should train on literally the entire internet. I'm definitely excited for where it might go though. If it ever develops to a sophisticated point, which it most certainly will, we'll be able to do stuff with it that is just impossible by typical production means.
- Keyframe 3y agoStill a long way until clients will be able to play "pixel peeping" and "what's wrong with this shot" games with AI. Chores like matte/roto and matchmove are closer to danger. Distant mattes, procedural fill (even textures) will be supercharged with it though.
- dylan604 3y agoa lot of these examples look like bad photoshop examples to me though.
- golergka 3y ago> Everyone of these generative AI demo pages feels exactly like that. Except you don't have to hire anyone and you get results in two minutes, not two days later.
- chankstein38 3y agoTruth but, to be fair, you could've done that with the other countless AI Video Generator papers/techs/releases we've seen.
- yreg 3y agoSo what's the complaint here? That researchers research? These folks wanted to make their own thing so they made their own thing. Eventually someone will make a thing that's far better than anything we have today.
- chankstein38 3y agoTo add, the very first video, the parrot doesn't have an eye. A few videos down the line, the horse's legs meld together and split again as it's walking. Agreed, this is no more impressive than Stable Video or any of the other things like this we've seen.
- orbital-decay 3y agoI think this comment is a bit premature and better reserved for a finished product, not a research demo. :) Video generation is still in its infancy, it obviously has even longer way to go than the other types of generative AI. Other than that, these demos will eventually develop into tools. You get to decide what to make with the tools, they won't do it for you.