5 ms·
I read about a case once where a man was convicted of rape. The evidence was that the rape was done face-to-face with the victim, and the victim positively ID'd
by WalterBright 3y ago
I read about a case once where a man was convicted of rape. The evidence was that the rape was done face-to-face with the victim, and the victim positively ID'd him. How could she not, when she was face-to-face with him? It was a slam dunk.
After some years in prison, the convicted person managed to get a DNA test, which proved he was not the rapist. How could this be?
It turns out the DNA matched a convicted sex offender who had, in the meantime, died in prison. A picture of him showed that he looked just like the falsely convicted man.
The victim, to her credit, profusely apologized for mis-identifying him, but she acted in good faith.
- 10000truths 3y agoDo you have a link to the case details? At the very least, there has to have been some additional evidence to convict, even if circumstantial. I find it hard to believe that someone can be ruled guilty of a crime as serious as rape based solely on the plaintiff's testimony.
- tonyedgecombe 3y agoHere is an example: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-66513959 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-66513959
- 2devnull 3y ago>I find it hard to believe I find it hard to believe you find it hard to believe. :) There’s a cliche term for such cases, “he said/she said” and they are not at all uncommon.
- bawolff 3y agoI dont think this term applies here - usually that term is reserved for one or both parties misrepresenting the situation. Here we have mistaken identity, which i would consider different.
- 2devnull 3y agoMy point stands. These are not uncommon cases. The justice system has obvious flaws and frequently goes awry. Mistaken identity, false testimony, wrongful convictions should be common knowledge.
- cafard 3y agoWas this the case involving Alice Sebold? The man was cleared, but I don't remember whether DNA evidence was involved.
- DrunkOnPower 3y agoSounds like Steven Avery's rape conviction. He was convicted even though he had an alibi.
- WalterBright 3y agoNo. Sorry.
- graphe 3y agoThis indicates that the jury/judge also failed the innocent man. What would have saved him? Are these cases relics before dna? Would it happen again today?
- pc86 3y agoI think it depends on your definition of "failed." An eye witness said it was him. He likely didn't have an alibi that could have withstood an eye witness pointing at him and saying "he did this." Had he been at a convenience store on camera, or some other incontrovertible thing, it would have most likely turned out differently. I'm not sure how a reasonable judge or jury would have come to any other conclusion given what little we know about this third-person retelling of a case so I don't think they "failed" him at least in the way I typically think of that word being used in these contexts.
- michaelt 3y agoFor better or worse, a huge amount of our justice system depends on eyewitness statements. For example, if my crazy neighbour knocked on my door, pushed their way into my home when I answered then beat me up - the only evidence of who did it would be my eyewitness testimony. There would be incontrovertible evidence that someone had assaulted me, in the form of my bruise-covered face and body. But only eyewitness testimony as to who. With the current justice system, that would almost certainly be enough for a jury to convict. There are tragic miscarriages of justice from time to time, and certainly DNA evidence should be used whenever possible. But would I prefer to live in a world which rejects eyewitness testimony, where a crazy person can barge into my house and beat me up with no consequences? Or a world where I have to have CCTV in my own home? Not really to be honest.
- graphe 3y agoThe manpower involved could also be an issue, they can gather dna and evidence but more likely it’ll be ignored over other cases. For better or worst, we should accept that our justice system has holes and flaws, and we should do our best to avoid them. There isn’t much to help you and they might not have any suitable punishment or aid to give to the crazy person.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- P_I_Staker 3y agoLots of times victims never will. There was a famous case of a guy that just admits to random crimes and the victim refused to believe it.
- qingcharles 3y agoFalse suspect identification is historically one of the largest reasons for false convictions. Courts, thankfully, are slowly catching on to this and giving it lesser weight than they used to.