4 ms·
I believe, and I think the data supports, that the US prison population is due to the number of laws we have, and the harshness of our penalties. A false convi
by s1artibartfast 3y ago
I believe, and I think the data supports, that the US prison population is due to the number of laws we have, and the harshness of our penalties.
A false conviction rate of a few percent does not explain an order of magnitude level differences in incarceration between countries.
I think an interesting question is what portion of the US population would be incarcerated if the totality of our laws were applied to everyone
- graphe 3y agoUS law is applied unequally. It’s very harsh, sometimes random and I’ve heard all Americans break the law daily. We would all be in jail and sometimes prison. US crime is like driving across the only road that is covered in black ice with toll trolls on the way, you have to cross it, you know it’s there, and you can do it carefully but you never know what will happen or where you’ll slip up.
- qingcharles 3y agoOpinion of a criminal: I don't think there are too many criminal laws at the State level. That is definitely not the reason for high incarceration rates. The guys who are in prison didn't randomly trip over a law they didn't know existed. 99% of the laws are the same as they've been since pre-history: don't hurt someone, don't steal etc. Sentencing to prison is probably the key problem. Criminals need help. Outright punishment just hardens them. From my experience the bulk of crime has its origin in mental illnesses which are not being treated. The medical system in the USA almost certainly is the cause of this.
- pdonis 3y agoWhat about non-violent drug possession? AFAIK that all by itself accounts for a significant number of incarcerated people. Laws criminalizing that are a product of the war on drugs, not embodying something in statute that's been a common law crime throughout human history.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoMy understanding that this is largely a thing of the past. Simple possession doesn't result in time, although dealing can
- pdonis 3y agoNon-violent dealing (meaning possession for the purpose of sale instead of use) would still be non-violent possession. It is a valid question what fraction of dealing (as opposed to possession for personal use) is actually non-violent. But even the violence is largely a product of the war on drugs, just as the corresponding violence surrounding illegal alcohol dealing during Prohibition was a product of the war on alcohol. Take away the prohibition and the violence went away.
- graphe 3y agoHow many of those are without a weapon? Is intent to distribute fentanyl a non violent possession? If so could you ever make a case it’s non violent dealing? If you don’t see it as non violent dealing, a store advertising date rape drugs should be allowed to sell all their legal products.
- pdonis 3y ago> How many of those are without a weapon? Whatever the current fraction is, it's in a world with a war on drugs, so it can't tell you anything useful about what a world without a war on drugs would be like. > Is intent to distribute fentanyl a non violent possession? As long as the distribution is done by voluntary transactions, sure. > a store advertising date rape drugs should be allowed to sell all their legal products. Date rape is not the only use for fentanyl. One might as well say that liquor stores should be closed down because liquor can be used for date rape. The premise of the war on drugs is that if we make drugs illegal, people will stop using them, or at least use will be drastically curtailed. We already knew that was false because Prohibition did not stop people from using alcoholic beverages, or drastically curtail their use; it just created a lucrative black market in alcohol, plus an incentive to violence for the people who ran that market--since they were criminals already, adding violence to the mix wasn't a big step. The war on drugs has worked out the same way. The only way to drastically reduce drug use is for people to stop wanting to use drugs. Unfortunately nobody has a really good way to do that. But we know that criminalizing their use and creating a lucrative and violent black market for them does not work.