4 ms·
>although it is the will of the people who were happy to usher through these powers, out of fear, back in the 911 days. was right there with you until the very
by dylan604 3y ago
>although it is the will of the people who were happy to usher through these powers, out of fear, back in the 911 days.
was right there with you until the very end. people seem to confuse the fact that members of congress that are elected by the people do things on behalf of those people. this isn't a situation where the transitive property from math can be used. for example, if A elected B and B did C does not mean A wanted C
- blitzar 3y agoAlmost three-quarters of the public believe that it is right to give up civil liberties to improve our security against terrorist attacks. A Guardian/ICM poll published today shows that 73% of respondents back the trade-off, with only 17% rejecting it outright. Usual disclaimers, 2005, polls etc - https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2005/aug/22/july7.terrorism https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2005/aug/22/july7.terrorism - breakdown by party/class/gender/age and the support is the same (+/- tiny margin).
- naasking 3y agoIt's not news that people agree with vague statements that sound good on paper. When the specifics are explained to them, they change their minds.
- blitzar 3y agoQ.1 Tony Blair has announced a series of anti-terrorism measures following last month's London bombings, which some people say might mean the loss of some civil liberties. Do you think it is right or wrong to lose some civil liberties to improve our security against terrorist attacks? I dont think you really need further specifics - years later without bombs going off I expect, with no further explanation to those polled needed, that the 70/30 split would probably be the opposite direction.
- naasking 3y ago> "Do you think it is right or wrong to lose some civil liberties to improve our security against terrorist attacks?" That "some" is the problem. People who say they support the tradeoff often change their minds when the specifics are explained to them. This happens all of the time in polling and even rigorous studies. Subtle changes in phrasing and context completely change results. We're seeing that right now. There was a survey done on college campuses on the phrase "from the river to the sea". many endorsed it, until they were shown a map of the region such that the specific meaning became clearer, and then a lot of them changed their minds.
- dfxm12 3y agoI dont think you really need further specifics - years later without bombs going off I expect, with no further explanation to those polled needed, that the 70/30 split would probably be the opposite direction. This sounds more like manufactured consent than the will of the people. Plus, I don't know if this happened with Blair's measures, but across the pond, the Patriot was initially written to be sunset after 4 years (from 2001), but wasn't fully sunset until 2020! This was long after the majority of Americans in polls said they didn't want to trade civil liberties to fight terror. https://news.gallup.com/poll/183548/americans-say-liberties-trump-anti-terrorism.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/183548/americans-say-liberties-...