4 ms·
That's not a great answer. We need to know the counterfactual question of "How much would google's stock have rallied after a realistic demo was given?" I would
by godelski 3y ago
That's not a great answer. We need to know the counterfactual question of "How much would google's stock have rallied after a realistic demo was given?" I would not have been surprised if the answer was also 5%. Almost certainly Google's stock would have risen after announcing Gemini. There are other long term questions too like about how this feeds into growing dissent against Google and trust. But what the stock did is only a small part of a much bigger and far more important question.
Edit: Can someone explain the downvotes? Is there a error in my response? I'm glad to learn but I'd appreciate a bit better feedback signal so that I can do so better instead of guessing.
- nextworddev 3y agoBroad investor community was spooked by Gemini Ga being delayed to Q1 so this stunt was a good stop gap / distraction
- yellow_postit 3y agoAnd likely caused more long term harm since if they had to fake this they’re likely further behind
- pixl97 3y agoThat's tomorrows problem, not todays. They are hoping to solve the issue by then, or find a new way to fake it another quarter.
- nostrademons 3y agoAlso pretty critically it moves the reckoning past the Q4/Q1 boundary, where annual budgets and performance reviews are being decided. That could be the difference between layoffs vs. hiring in your department, between departures vs. high morale, or between re-orgs vs. continued productivity. If you can fake it for an extra couple weeks, it might mean getting another year of continued funding, and with an extra year of continued funding you might just deliver what you originally promised.
- nextworddev 3y agoHaha, this is the right Realpolitik interpretation for sure
- dkga 3y agoEconomist here who studies exactly this type of counterfactual analysis. You are completely right: the effect of Gemini can only be estimated if we factor in what the Alphabet stock price would have been in the same time but in a world without Gemini. This is actually very standard in financial economics. This type of effect can be calculated with econometric techniques that compare before/after for “treated” vs “untreated” units, but in instances such as these, where only one or a few units were affected, like Alphabet stock amongst hundreds of other companies, one could use techniques such as “synthetic controls”. The intuition is to use other companies’ data to estimate before Gemini how Alphabet stock prices move over time, and then use that relationship to estimate a post-Gemini version of no-Gemini Google. The difference between the actual stock price and that counterfactual is the effect of interest; whether it is a significant effect or just random noise can be established by a number of auxiliary statistical tests. For more info, see [0]. [0] Abadie, A. (2021). Using synthetic controls: Feasibility, data requirements, and methodological aspects. Journal of Economic Literature, 59(2), 391-425.
- godelski 3y agoWell I don't mean with/without Gemini, I mean without the deceptive marketing of Gemini vs had they counterfactually produced a non-deceptive marketing. Other than that nitpicking, I appreciate the backup and the source. Counterfactual testing is by no means easy, so good luck with your work! My gf is an economist but on the macro side. You guys have it tough. I'm a bit confused why people are disliking my comment but mostly that they are doing so without explanation lol.
- hnfong 3y ago> I would not have been surprised if the answer was also 5% Given the sensitivity of the market with any company perceived to be lagging behind AI developments, I wouldn't be surprised that their stock price would drop by a couple % if the demo underwhelmed. So the whole thing is basically a ethical question of "how far can we go with polishing our demo until it becomes an unacceptable fake?" In an ideal world you'd never want to be caught in such a dilemma.