5 ms·
> Would the UN kick Israel out if they continue the war despite a UNSC vote? Unlikely. Is there even a process for the UN to kick members out? What good would
by toast0 3y ago
> Would the UN kick Israel out if they continue the war despite a UNSC vote?
Unlikely. Is there even a process for the UN to kick members out? What good would it do anyway? At most, they get demoted to a non-voting member, but probably the US and UK won't both vote against them in the security council, so do they really need a general assembly vote?
> Would countries go to war with Israel specifically to uphold the UNSC vote?
No, but they might enact a no-fly zone, or do a peace keeping mission with lots of possible rules of engagement.
But the UN is really a means for the powerful countries to justify their extraterritorial actions, when there's enough concensus and the other powers don't care enough to turn away the rubber stamp. It does some other important stuff, but if the UN had significant power in the Israel/Palestine conflict, there's a series of adopted resolutions that could have been de facto enforced.
- _heimdall 3y ago> No, but they might enact a no-fly zone, or do a peace keeping mission with lots of possible rules of engagement I'm not sure how that would work here. Given that they are primarily Israeli jets in the air, UN member states would need to be willing to shoot down Israeli jets to enforce the no-fly zone. > if the UN had significant power in the Israel/Palestine conflict, there's a series of adopted resolutions that could have been de facto enforced Now you got me curious. What are those existing resolutions they could reach for? Is it mainly just enforcement related to economic sanctions and similar non-military actions?
- toast0 3y ago> I'm not sure how that would work here. Given that they are primarily Israeli jets in the air, UN member states would need to be willing to shoot down Israeli jets to enforce the no-fly zone. Sure, but enforcing a no-fly zone isn't going to war. And I'm sure they'd shoot down Hamas jets as well, so it's fair. > What are those existing resolutions they could reach for? There's a big list of resolutions [1], resolution 54 [2] from the security council in 1948 ordering everyone to desist from further military action is probably technically still in force and applicable. In the general assembly, you've got resolution 181 [3] which sets a partition plan for Mandatory Palestine of 1947 which didn't happen. And there's many years of annual calls for Israel to withdrawl from the occupied territories, etc, between about 1967 and about 1984. Unfortunately, many of the Wikipedia links to general council resolutions don't currently work, so I'm relying on titles. Anyway, if the UN orders a partition in 1947, and it hasn't happened by 2023, but they still say oh hey, do this thing... either the UN doesn't have much power or it isn't willing to use it. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_Nations_resolutions_concerning_Palestine https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_Nations_resol... [2] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations_Security_Council_Resolution_54 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations_Security_Coun... [3] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations_Partition_Plan_for_Palestine https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations_Partition_Pla...