12 ms·
as context for davies' new research, it's useful to know how bad we thought it was previously; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clathrate_gun_hypothesis#Current_ou
by kragen 3y ago
as context for davies' new research, it's useful to know how bad we thought it was previously; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clathrate_gun_hypothesis#Current_outlook https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clathrate_gun_hypothesis#Curre... explains:
> In 2018, a perspective piece devoted to tipping points in the climate system suggested that the climate change contribution from methane hydrates would be "negligible" by the end of the century, but could amount to 0.4–0.5 °C (0.72–0.90 °F) on the millennial timescales.[6] In 2021, the IPCC Sixth Assessment Report no longer included methane hydrates in the list of potential tipping points, and says that "it is very unlikely that CH4 emissions from clathrates will substantially warm the climate system over the next few centuries."[7] The report had also linked terrestrial hydrate deposites to gas emission craters discovered in the Yamal Peninsula in Siberia, Russia beginning in July 2014,[133] but noted that since terrestrial gas hydrates predominantly from at a depth below 200 metres, a substantial response within the next few centuries can be ruled out.[7] Likewise, a 2022 assessment of tipping points described methane hydrates as a "threshold-free feedback" rather than a tipping point.[134][135]
one of the reasons for this is that below 200 meters, the methane apparently goes into the ocean rather than the atmosphere. what happens to it there? i'm unclear on that. maybe it gets oxidized? by marine life? that seems like the only way it could 'cause the oceans to become more acidic', as davies says; methane isn't acidic!
the end of davies' article summarizes the results as follows:
> So during a warming world the volume of hydrate that will be vulnerable to leaking methane is more significant than previously thought.
> The positive outlook is that there are many natural barriers to this methane. But be warned, we expect that in some places on earth, as we warm the planet, methane from the deep will escape into our oceans.
it would be nice to have some clue in the 'conversation' article about whether the timescale he's talking about is months, years, centuries, millennia, tens of millennia, hundreds of millennia, millions of years, or what, but presumably if he disagreed with the ipcc's sixth assessment report that it would be at least millennia, he would have said so
has anyone read the nature geoscience paper?