5 ms·
The United Arab Emirates' takeover of African forests
- josh_fyi 3y agoThat's great! Liberia can't afford to protect its forest, and this deal allows that.
- __s 3y agoAgreed. This is the kind of agreements that are needed for Brazilian rain forests The Simple Economics of Saving the Amazon Rain Forest: https://freakonomics.com/podcast/the-simple-economics-of-saving-the-amazon-rain-forest-ep-428 https://freakonomics.com/podcast/the-simple-economics-of-sav... But it's a bit complicated because if you just buy plots then cattle farming will buy different plots. So you need to setup an incentive structure to pay dividends for sitting on undeveloped rain forest
- coffeebeqn 3y agoEasiest would be for Brazil to become more stable and act in its own long term interest
- givemeethekeys 3y agoNGO's hate it when a bigger player with more resources eats their cake. Their only recourse, it seems, is to complain about the semantics of how the new kid is punching wrong.
- darth_avocado 3y agoIm sorry but isn’t this actually good? As Africa, parts of Asia and South America become more populated and strive for better quality of life, the last of the big forests are already at risk. If these places are incentivized to protect them, it is a net good for everyone.
- mrpopo 3y agoIt's better than doing nothing, but the UAE has more than enough homework regarding carbon emissions reduction. Its per capita footprint is 25t CO2, 75% more than the USA, which itself is 2.5x that of the EU. https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/co-emissions-per-capita?tab=chart&country=ARE~USA~European+Union+%2828%29 https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/co-emissions-per-capita?t... Plus the UAE is ~10% citizens, 90% migrant foreigners. I'm not sure how per capita footprint of the UAE accounts for that (is a UAE citizen carbon footprint actually 250t CO2...?)
- fakedang 3y ago> Plus the UAE is ~10% citizens, 90% migrant foreigners. I'm not sure how per capita footprint of the UAE accounts for that (is a UAE citizen carbon footprint actually 250t CO2...?) It's close. Electricity is practically free for citizens, which is why their large homes are key peretualy cool and thoroughly well-lit, like what you'd see in a real estate marketing brochure.
- coffeebeqn 3y agoSomehow I doubt the migrant workers live in excessively AC’d mansions
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> Somehow I doubt the migrant workers live in excessively AC’d mansions Your suspicions might be true: https://duckduckgo.com/?hps=1&q=%22united+arab+emirates%22+migrant+workers+housing+conditions&iax=images&ia=images https://duckduckgo.com/?hps=1&q=%22united+arab+emirates%22+m...
- fakedang 3y agoCITIZENS Migrants aren't citizens, last I checked.
- uluyol 3y agoThese stats can be misleading for other reasons as well. The US and EU have a lot of existing infrastructure, construction of which required enormous amounts of CO2 emissions. Countries that are still building out their infrastructure should be expected to expend more CO2 per capita to catch up. (Modern equipment is more effecient, but still).
- cat_plus_plus 3y agoThat's how we tell the difference between rational environmentalists concerned about future human well being and zealots who just hate the idea of human succeeding above other animals or currently wealthy countries succeeding above other countries. Because if you are the former, you are absolutely in favor of carbon credits, sequestration, geoengineering, nuclear power plants, migrating from coal/oil to natural gas etc. Of course, you would want evidence of safety and effectiveness, but not "it's colonialism" knee jerk reactions. It could well be that the other alternative for these forests was logging or slash and burn agriculture, in which case the program is working exactly as intended. Or if not, we can criticize it for being ineffective without woke moralizing. Someone needs to make a bid to preserve the forest, and this company made a bid that is apparently higher than alternatives. As carbon credit economy takes off, there will be competition and prices will rise, in turn exposing the limits of carbon offsets and forcing reductions in actual emissions.
- OfSanguineFire 3y agoWhen I first saw reporting of these UAE ventures some days ago, it was about suspicion that the owners would eventually exploit the forest or the minerals underneath. It is a frequent phenomenon in sub-Saharan Africa and Madagascar that land is first restricted and named a protected reserve, but after ribbon-cutting ceremonies are over and attention moves elsewhere, logging is done with wood being sold to e.g. China’s furniture industry, or the local population’s slash-and-burn practices encroach regardless.
- hulitu 3y agoI bet you didn't heard about Norvegians cutting forrests in the Amazonas. /s
- Barrin92 3y agoThis completely misses the point, intentionally I suppose given this sentence: " or currently wealthy countries succeeding above other countries" This isn't about protecting forests. It's about a rich country offsetting its emissions by buying another countries industrial capacity in the form of carbon credits. It's taking a bribe from another country to stay poor. It's as if the United States started to pay China to turn factories off so they can turn more on. It's not just metaphorically colonial, it's literally the colonial economic model, capturing a resource, bringing the industry home (to Paris/London/Moscow in the olden days) and selling the produce back to the periphery. The only difference is the resource and land captured here is synthetic ("green credits"). There is nothing environmental about this, the emissions are constant. The planet does not care if you produce oil in Nigeria or Saudi Arabia.
- tru3_power 3y agoThis is good. Eventually doing this will probably be too expensive and most players probably will have to find ways to lower emissions (I assume?) and forest remaining forest will become more valuable than the timer that can be extracted from them.
- mahmoudhossam 3y agoIt's a bit hypocritical from Le Monde to talk about African forests as if the French haven't colonized and looted Africa for the better part of a century.
- micwag 3y agoNone of the countries in the article were ever colonized by France.
- mahmoudhossam 3y agoTrue, but they're highlighting the NGOs calling colonialism on what the UAE is doing (admittedly a horrible regime) as if France never engaged (and probably still is) in such behavior.
- tarkin2 3y agoIrrelevant to the subject at hand.
- mardifoufs 3y agoWould you read a Russian newspaper article about bad treatment of Ukrainians in the west? I mean, sure but I hope you wouldn't actually give it any credibility. To me this is similar, considering how blatant France is about 'Franceafrique' and how unapologetic it is about wanting Africa to be its own little backyard.
- catlover76 3y agoThey aren't acting "as if" French colonialism never happened. Are you saying that because someone was born in country X, which committed Y misdeeds ~100 years ago, then that person is not free to draw attention to current misdeeds that are like Y happening now by the hand of others? That's absurd and ungrounded in any real system of ethics or morality--and also untenable, given that every country/religion/group/whatever has at some point done pretty fucked up shit.
- 3y ago
- treprinum 3y agoNext: Look at how much of Eastern European forests was clear-cut in the past 5 years due to "battling insects"... Satellite imagery is showing Brazil-like deforestation.
- zdragnar 3y agoNo need for the sarcastic scare quotes. The trees were dead or dying and a fire hazard. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-centraleurope-environment-barkbeetle/climate-change-to-blame-as-bark-beetles-ravage-central-europes-forests-idUSKCN1S21LA/ https://www.reuters.com/article/us-centraleurope-environment... The studies I saw didn't agree with the climate change angle, but bark beetles of various species are absolutely brutal to trees. What's more, depending on the species, the wood is useless for anything but biomass. The larvae can and will burrow tunnels deep into the trunk which makes the wood unappealing for most uses... So it's not like it is a convenient excuse for loggers to go in and clear cut.
- friend_and_foe 3y agoIsn't this just rainforest conservation done right? I fail to see the problem here.
- situationista 3y agoRainforest conservation can hardly be described as being "done right" when it is paid for by selling/burning more fossil fuels elsewhere.
- friend_and_foe 3y agoI don't really think so. I think they're separate issues. If anything, increased warmth, carbon dioxide and water vapor will increase the density of rainforests, ignoring any other emgstive consequences elsewhere around the world. Rainforest conservation and climate change are separate issues, though they overlap in specific ways and circumstances. Ignoring the source of the funds used for this conservation effort, actively incentivizing rainforest conservation so that real capital is used to that end is a fantastic thing.
- whatshisface 3y agoAbsolutely nothing that happens anywhere, to anyone, is paid for without selling or burning fossil fuels. Even solar plants reduce the price of electricity, which gives people buying fossil fuel energy the ability to buy more of it.
- gosub100 3y agoSo if an acre of rainforest were slated to be "developed" but burning, say, 1 55-gal drum of your favorite hydrocarbon would prevent it, and instead preserve that acre for 5 years, you would be against doing so, because it involves burning fossil fuels? If no, then your statement is untrue.
- yetanother12345 3y agoLet me get this right... You buy some piece of land, or (as per TFA) lease it for 30 years. Then, you do nothing with it. On the basis of you having the potential of doing something with it, you calculate a hypothetical difference in "potential scope of hypothetical activity" somehow denominated in the CO2 unit. The exact procedure for doing this is neither known, reproducible, nor audited? This purely fictional "measure" (for lack of a better term) is then renamed to "credits" and converted to some monetary unit, like, say USD. The exchange rate is then what? And why? Last, you sell - as in actually sell - this purely fictional nothingness to states and big corporations who all have multiple economists and/or scientists employed. Plus ample access to external specialists if their own capacities should somehow need a reality check... Is it me, or does this seem a bit weird (to put it politely)?
- Swizec 3y agoYes this is weird and also may be exactly what we need to do. Here’s a few politicians from various countries explaining, basically, ”Look we need to develop. If you need us not to cut down the jungle, you should pay. The economic activity needs to come from somewhere. We can’t live in poverty forever” https://time.com/6233998/brazil-indonesia-rainforests-climate-cop27/ https://time.com/6233998/brazil-indonesia-rainforests-climat... https://news.mongabay.com/2022/11/where-is-the-money-brazil-indonesia-and-congo-join-forces-in-push-for-rainforest-protection-cash/ https://news.mongabay.com/2022/11/where-is-the-money-brazil-... Think of it as money paid for conservation. Then it all makes sense.
- alistairSH 3y agoExcept the Western nations/companies who buy the credits no longer have to reduce their emissions. It’s great that Liberia has an incentive to conserve its forest. It’s not so great that doing so gives the rest of the world a license to pollute.
- MichaelZuo 3y agoAnd it's unclear who is even responsible for making the final decision on whether the 'licensed' forests have been degraded in any way 30 years from now, and what authority they have to do anything.
- smfjaw 3y agoCambridge did a great study on how 'real' these credits are https://www.cam.ac.uk/stories/carbon-credits-hot-air https://www.cam.ac.uk/stories/carbon-credits-hot-air
- situationista 3y agoJust to make sure it's clear to everyone who's commenting about how great this is - in return for UAE paying to protect Liberia's forests, it gets to burn more fossil fuels while claiming to be reducing its carbon output. Not sure whether this is bad news from a climate perspective, but it certainly isn't good news.
- politelemon 3y agoBasically a perfect example of Goodhart's Law taken to capitalist extremes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law
- Loughla 3y agoI mean, if the forest was going to be developed, and this stops that, it has to be worth something, correct?
- pyrale 3y ago> if the forest was going to be developed That's a nice euphemism.
- rldjbpin 3y agothis to me is a lazier way to buy credits. such kind of assistance should just come directly imo.