3 ms·
Humans evolved during a period of ice age. The earth (while it has hosted terrestrial life) has typically been much warmer. If we return to a Cretaceous period
by echelon 3y ago
Humans evolved during a period of ice age. The earth (while it has hosted terrestrial life) has typically been much warmer.
If we return to a Cretaceous period temperatures, can we and our crops survive?
I've read that if we wind up with a navigable north sea and arable north, that the earth would be net better for some (eg. Russia) despite the fact that other climates will suffer. (Some surmise that Russia could be catapulted back into superpower status.)
Could these runaway heating systems go beyond sustainable and turn earth into Venus?
- kiba 3y agoThere are levels of survival that humans must be prepared to tolerate as long as we do not work together to act in the interest of our species.
- huijzer 3y agoI agree. We have no idea. From a statistical standpoint, I‘d rather have humanity pollute less because the chance that humanity will thrive in a changed ecosystem is lower than in the current since humans have evolved in the current.
- gmuslera 3y agoIt could take from hundreds to thousands of years to reach to a new stable, that may be worse than Cretaceous period. But the problem is not just the final temperature, but the speed of change. Adaptation takes time, with things changing as fast as now few things will survive, and that may not include us.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoIt's the rate of change that is significant. If the change took place over tens or hundreds of thousands of years, climates and species would adapt, and the positive and negative changes could roughly balance. But it is happening on the decade scale, and negative shocks happen faster than positive ones.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- adrian_b 3y agoThe regions that are now good for humans will become bad and some regions that are bad now will become good. It is clear that the majority of the humans live in the regions that are good now and much fewer live in the bad regions. When the quality of the regions will change, this will be an undesirable change for much more humans than those for which the change will be favorable. The owners of the regions that will become good are unlikely to welcome those from the regions that become bad to relocate there. Therefore it would certainly be much better if the changes were prevented, instead of hoping to be among the few who could benefit from them. I am old enough to remember the cold and snowy winters that were normal in the past, where I live. For now, it is convenient for me that more than a decade has passed since the last time when I have used my winter clothes and my winter boots, but it is extremely scary to have witnessed such a climate change in much less than a human lifetime, without knowing where it would lead eventually.
- wongarsu 3y agoIt's quite possible that we reach a new "stable" state. There is a lot of land in Siberia, Canada and Greenland that might become well suited to agriculture as temperatures increase. Meanwhile the Northern shipping routes open up as the northern ice caps retreat, making these regions even more attractive. But this would come with monumental challenges, the kinds that have caused previous civilizations to collapse. Billions of people live in regions that will reach hostile temperatures or that will have population centers destroyed by sea level rise. Imagine a large portion of them moving North and South to more hospitable climates. Russia might have won the lottery in terms of future-proof land, but trying to control migration across its Southern border would be a near impossible challenge. Meanwhile the EU has a ... complicated relationship with border control right now, and will be faced with a lot worse.
- barbazoo 3y agoAnd that’s assuming borders have any meaning at all when it comes to the problems we’re facing. We’re all on this planet together and if land becomes uninhabitable those people need to go and live somewhere. Whether that somewhere is beyond a border is irrelevant. People will just go where they don’t starve, die or be persecuted etc and that’s their right to do so. The borders we have were made in the context that won’t exist 50 years from now. Everyone will have to adapt. No one will be untouched from climate change just because of their winning ticket at the lottery of birth.
- RandomLensman 3y agoThat is the optimistic scenario. Even possible that productivity and wealth growth increases in some scenario like that.
- netsharc 3y ago> We’re all on this planet together Too optimistic. The borders will become the lines in people's heads where people say "This is our territory, we own the food and water here, we don't have enough, so you stay out and here are the bullets to help us keep you out.". And the other side will say "We're dying of hunger and thirst, we will ignore the lines, and here are the bullets to help us.".