3 ms·
The problem is BYD's LFP battery energy density is only 150 Wh/kg. Compared to 260 in something like a Tesla.
by ksec 3y ago
The problem is BYD's LFP battery energy density is only 150 Wh/kg. Compared to 260 in something like a Tesla.
- reitzensteinm 3y agoAre you saying Tesla's LFP is 260 Wh/kg, or are you comparing across chemistries?
- gridder 3y agothe latter
- oittaa 3y agoEven LFPs are getting better all the time. Energy density in Cybertruck at the pack level is something like 170 Wh/kg with the latest 4680 cells.
- p1mrx 3y agoIsn't the Cybertruck using regular lithium ion? That shows how immature the 4680 production process is, if they can barely compete with LFP, though some of the weight is contributing to the structure of the vehicle.
- fiftyfifty 3y agoTesla is already using BYD’s blade batteries in the Model Y in Europe: https://insideevs.com/news/668659/tesla-model-y-batteries-byd-versus-catl/amp/ https://insideevs.com/news/668659/tesla-model-y-batteries-by...
- tooltalk 3y agoWith the pack level density of ~140Wh/kg. CATL is Tesla's primary LFP supplier -- BYD was added earlier this year. The key sellig point here is the cost.
- tzs 3y agoTesla switched to LFP for the standard range model 3 and Y a year or so ago.
- olex 3y agoLonger. My M3 RWD delivered in December 2022 has a third-gen LFP pack with 60 kWh capacity, in the years before they used first a 50 and then a 55 kWh packs before going to the current 60 kWh variant.
- thebruce87m 3y agoOne upside is that you can charge them to 100% daily, whereas NMC they recommend 80%.
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoThe lower energy density is a real factor, yes! But personally it just seems so worth it. LFP has far greater cycle count than Li-ion. That the battery is going to last 4x longer or more is a huge factor for me. The net-energy (across the usable battery lifetime)/$ is so much vastly better that I'm happy in most applications dealing with the weight.
- tooltalk 3y ago>> LFP has far greater cycle count than Li-ion. That the battery is going to last 4x longer or more is a huge factor for me. << Sure, that's true in individual cell studies in lab, or stationary energy storage (aka, ESS), but not necessarily in moving vehicles, ie, EVs. CATL's cheap, inferior LFP would probably make more sense in storage.