3 ms·
It's even worse than that: I render a service to yummyfajitas for $10M; say, sending a text message "you rock!" yummyfajitas renders similar service to me for
by beagle3 15y ago
It's even worse than that:
I render a service to yummyfajitas for $10M; say, sending a text message "you rock!"
yummyfajitas renders similar service to me for $10M; say, sending a text message "you sock!" back.
GDP = $20M+$0.20 (cost of text messages). Net change to economy: 0
You can (and indeed, countries do) inflate GDP for various reasons, such as GDP/debt requirements.
- astine 15y agoI'd argue that the economy was richer by two text messages, each valued at $10M by the recipients. Measuring the strength of an economy is a fundamentally hard thing to do because value itself is quite arbitrary.
- jshen 15y agoYou're assuming that prices don't reflect value. Isn't that a sketchy premise?
- beagle3 15y agoYou are assuming that prices do reflect value. Isn't that a sketchy premise? I just gave an example in which the GDP is 100,000,000 times larger then the observable transaction outside us two people ($20M vs. $0.20). It is perfectly ok from legal and tax perspectives (income and expenses cancel out; accounts were netted). Now, given how easy that is to do, why would you assume that prices properly reflect value? As an example, the GAP and Banana republic will sell you everything at 50% discount if you know what you are doing (there is a 40%-or-so discount window for "loyal customers" every week, and other coupons and rebates that stack up). What price should Banana Republic consider their inventory in? The higher price, or the lower price? Now, when they transfer this to Banana Republic UK, what are the prices (and values) they should use? This is all ripe for perversion, and it is this "flexibility" that allows Google and Microsoft and other multinational corps to pay 3% tax on one hand, and companies to present arbitrary GDP numbers on the other. Prices and values only reflect each other in efficient markets -- but those are almost nowhere to be found.
- jshen 15y agoI agree to some degree, i think most consumer prices are a decent proxy for value. I don't think we disagree as much as it would seem from our debate on HN.