3 ms·
The successors to the classical Roman Empire shaped the surviving narrative, from the linked article: By putting a stop to its use as a quarry for building
by defrost 3y ago
The successors to the classical Roman Empire shaped the surviving narrative, from the linked article:
By putting a stop to its use as a quarry for building materials, Benedict’s intervention rescued the Colosseum, as Edward Gibbon recognised.
Gibbon was somewhat sceptical about the centrality of the Colosseum, ‘a spot which persecution and fable had stained with the blood of so many Christian martyrs’, to early Christian history.
Despite the stories of Christians thrown to the lions so often repeated there is no solid evidence that any Christian martyr actually died in Rome’s Colosseum.
Or, putting it another way, there's a lot of writing from Roman times and not much evidence that Christians as a group were specifically singled out for persecution any more than any other group that was not the ruling elite.
- InTheArena 3y agoGibbon's writings are really not taken as gospel (hah!) truth anymore and are not really supported by any historical research more modern than the late 1800s. Gibbon's core thesis is that Christianity caused the downfall of the Roman Empire leads him to reject quite a lot of evidence that the Roman Empire was a nasty, nasty place well before the Huns sacked Rome.
- Aloha 3y agoThere is a good coherent argument that the conversion to Christianity added additional instability to a system that was already very unstable. It may not have been fatal, but it probably contributed to a process that was already happening. The Roman empire was already both politically and economically unstable by 150 AD - and was shrinking. I think attributing to Christianity as the sole cause of the downfall of the empire shows a lack of the complex (mostly, but not entirely) economic factors involved.
- InTheArena 3y agoIt certainly did add instability. The Roman Empire depended on god worship (Caeser's power as a religious leader in particular), depended on slavery, and was very ethnocentric - all anathema to early Christianity. Gibbon, on the other hand, had a thesis and let the thesis shape the facts, rather than the other way around. Mike Duncan's Roman history podcast is still an awesome way to see all of the forces involved.
- nyokodo 3y ago> there's a lot of writing from Roman times and not much evidence that Christians as a group were specifically singled out Especially if you arbitrarily exclude Christian sources. This is just bigoted historical revisionism.
- lo_zamoyski 3y ago> The successors to the classical Roman Empire shaped the surviving narrative The cynicism is unwarranted as it was never a commonly held Christian view that the Colosseum was a significant site of Christian martyrdom. The article reads: "In 1749, Pope Benedict XIV consecrated the Colosseum, ancient Rome’s most recognisable monument, as a shrine to Christian martyrs." That's quite recent and was contested by, e.g., clergy and scholars in the Church at the time. Here's more information about the Colosseum in the context of Christian martyrdom[0]. [0] https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/04101b.htm https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/04101b.htm