2 ms·
>The only entitlement I see here is the expectation by authors to have absolute control over their work Well they are the author or funder of said art. They sh
by johnnyanmac 3y ago
>The only entitlement I see here is the expectation by authors to have absolute control over their work
Well they are the author or funder of said art. They should feel entitled to how it's distributed. If they are working on a braille translation and someone else pops up, you can understand why they should have the power to make sure the latter can't make money off their IP, no?
But my point is that this is contrived because most people downloading a torrent are not doing transformative work. A few may make mods or fan translations or entire overhaul of the game, but well over 99.9% just want to consume as is. And well, those 0.1% can just buy the work?
>Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Article 27.
That article has 2 parts. The 2nd:
>Everyone has the right to the protection of the moral and material interests resulting from any scientific, literary or artistic production of which he is the author.
Pretty much defends copyright, so the goal here isn't to turn all of media into a commons. They acknowledge that art and science is something society benefits from, but also that the authors of such culture have some protection against being leeches upon.
>The right to participate in culture is infringed upon, for example, when essayists are unable to publish video essays about movies and illustrate their ideas with a few seconds from each movie, because they get caught in overzealous copyright protection.
I mean, they do? The overzealous one is YouTube in this case who has no legal incentive to push their luck, not the law which is why DMCA's aren't even more aggressive.
I get your point here, but that specific example is more a problem with the YouTube monopoly than the word of the law. I think we all agree that DMCA abusers should be punished, even if the question Of DMCA as a law us valid.