11 ms·
Maybe so, but please don't post unsubstantive comments to Hacker News.
by dang 3y ago
Maybe so, but please don't post unsubstantive comments to Hacker News.
- jessehattabaugh 3y ago[flagged]
- astrange 3y agoThat's literally his job.
- jessehattabaugh 3y ago[flagged]
- wredue 3y ago[flagged]
- zmgsabst 3y ago[flagged]
- llamaimperative 3y agoYou’re giving that “mainstream sentiment” way too much credit. 1) It’s not all that mainstream. 2) It has nothing to do with the opioid epidemic nor the replication crisis. 3) That is exactly the sentiment that was “generated” by the boogeymen (purposely nefarious or not). It’s mostly downstream of COVID and specifically the lies around COVID. And yes, those lies were indeed powered and mainstreamed by a combination of alt right and alt left looneytunes who just found a much larger audience for a variation of the old hobbyhorses, “vaccines cause autism” and “contrails turn frogs gay” type do-your-own-research research.
- zmgsabst 3y ago> It’s mostly downstream of COVID and specifically the lies around COVID. I agree it’s about the lies around COVID, but not in the way you meant: Over 40% of US adults would sue the vaccine manufacturers in a class action; about 25% know someone injured. Texas is suing Pfizer for fraud. How much more “mainstream” do you want? But the distrust in those communities stems back to opioids and replication failures — and you only became aware of that sentiment during COVID. You’re saying that sentiment was generated by Bad Men (TM), but you are ignoring the real devastation some communities faced from the opioid crisis and distrust caused by flagrantly non-scientific “science”. I think it speaks to a real lack of empathy on your part: you’re dismissing whole groups as “alt” without substantively addressing their claims.
- llamaimperative 3y agoAbout 25% of people claim to know someone who claims to have been injured. That’s a very different claim than the one you just made. And given that this sort of sleight of hand is so common among a certain sect of society, it’s not super shocking a high number would be willing to join a class action. “Would you like free money going after big bad pharma?” What a pitch! Anyway, I’m very curious for a source on that 40% figure — do you happen to have one? No, “replication failures” are not a mainstream concern. And they certainly weren’t some lurking concern within right wing circles for years before COVID. That’s a frankly ridiculous claim. It’s not mainstream concern within the left-wing either because it’s fundamentally not a mainstream concern. As far as the opioid crisis, it’s also ahistorical to suggest this was some longtime mainstream concern among a neglected section of society (the right, of course). The actual statistics are clear: Even today, blue-leaning people overwhelmingly blame pharmaceutical companies, doctors, and the FDA. Red-leaning people blame people addicted to opioids, then pharma companies, then “the government.” Having actually grown up in one of these deep red parts of the country, the idea that right wingers were always blaming pharma companies is hilarious. Everyone knows drug addiction is the drug addict’s fault. That’s why they don’t deserve any help! First on the list of blame for both sides are illegal drug dealers. https://today.yougov.com/health/articles/42574-blame-opioid-epidemic-pharmaceutical-companies https://today.yougov.com/health/articles/42574-blame-opioid-... I think it speaks to an extremely rose-colored view of these people and the information sphere in which they exist.
- zlg_codes 3y agoAre you so sure it's only conservatives? I lean left and a healthy dose of skepticism is needed in science. I've read too many abstracts and papers where the methodology sucked, the sample size was a rounding error, incorrect conclusions were made, etc. Let's not forget it was a hokey scientist who pushed the antivax shit. His license was revoked but the damage was done. Science needs to be good, proper science to be regarded as anything approaching the truth. That's why science is like medicine, a practice.
- wredue 3y agoYes I am sure. Because all of the accounts that JAQ off with idiotic shit like “how can we trust science!?” Are always new accounts, or accounts whos entire history is anti-science brigading or just outright bigotry. You can ignore the coup that the alt-right is attempting on HN all you want. The fact is that it’s happening.
- pvg 3y agoIf you have evidence of this you can just mail the mods but it's offtopic in just about all HN threads for straightforward reasons.