4 ms·
True but not that important in this case. These factors tend to make it hard to compare GDP across countries or across time frames large enough for societies t
by Symmetry 15y ago
True but not that important in this case. These factors tend to make it hard to compare GDP across countries or across time frames large enough for societies to change, but if a countries GDP suddenly falls by 5% it isn't because a bunch of people got married. In the long run GDP correlates with wealth, and in the short term it correlates quite well. And since it's easy to measure, we can legitimately use it in the way that the article uses it.
- yummyfajitas 15y ago...if a countries GDP suddenly falls by 5% it isn't because a bunch of people got married. True, but that's not the only pointless transaction one can make that would raise GDP. Here is another: taxing some people and using the proceeds to pay others to do valueless work (e.g., digging holes and filling them in). A well designed austerity measure will attempt to reduce such payments. This will reduce GDP, but not welfare. (That's not to say a poorly designed austerity measure can't be welfare reducing, I'm just pointing out that you need to dig deep into the specifics to make that determination.) If you want to argue against austerity, explain why it's welfare reducing. Pointing out that it might reduce GDP just doesn't cut it.
- CWuestefeld 15y agoKeynes would say that non-productive work is not valueless, because it still stimulates the economy by enabling those diggers to be consumers. Not that I subscribe to the theory, but there are many well-respected experts who do. I think that if they're intelligent in their austerity, then it'll be this non-productive stuff that gets cut. And what the big-government Keynesians so frequently miss is that the government spending crowds out the private sector. If the government frees up those resources (people, money, etc.), then the private sector can use it to produce something that people want to pay for. But even if Spain isn't so intelligent in their austerity, well, just because something needs to be done doesn't mean that it's the government that must do it. There will still be every opportunity for private industry, or even Spain's underground economy, to fill in the void.
- Symmetry 15y agoOh, I'm not arguing for classic Keynesianism here. Its good that governments keep their levels of expenditure more or less constant through cyclical fluctuations in their revenue, but only because firing and rehiring people is inefficient. Far better, I would say, would be to use monetary stimulus since that doesn't leave the government with a mountain of debt. There's always the danger of inflation if you apply too much, but that's equally true with fiscal stimulus. I generally agree with this: http://www.nationalaffairs.com/publications/detail/re-targeting-the-fed http://www.nationalaffairs.com/publications/detail/re-target... EDIT: Of course, the EU monetary authority doesn't have a dual mandate like the Fed, and it seems to be run according to the needs of northern rather than southern Europe anyways. A lot of economists who were saying that the Euro was doomed are saying "I told you so" now. I don't see this crisis ending without either more fiscal integration or the dissolution of the Euro, and I think the later is more likely.
- trevelyan 15y agoDigging up bags of buried fiat money is exactly the same as digging more gold out of a mine. You seem to want to mock Keynes by picking on him as advocating "valueless work", but what you don't understand is that Keynes picked that example to parody the classical economists who - like you - advocated doing nothing in the face of economic collapse. Digging up money is an obvious waste of time. In suggesting it, Keynes was making fun of people like Andrew Carnegie who advocated letting market forces "liquidate stocks, liquidate farmers, liquidate real estate... [and] purge the rottenness out of the system". Under market forces, deflation would have increased the value of gold, pushing the private sector to increase gold production and bring the economy back into equilibrium by paying people to... dig holes in the ground and produce more money. The point of the parable may be less obvious today since no-one seriously advocates the restoration of the gold standard anymore, but the core insight Keynes had remains as valid today as it was then: when you are in a liquidity trap marked by deflation and insufficient demand, there is a huge free lunch to be had simply by printing money and spending it to direct unemployed labor into productive activities. This brings the economy back into equilibrium and is the reason austerity is welfare reducing. Because you advocate forcing the private sector to undertake a senseless course of painful adjustment that could be avoided simply by printing enough money to avert deflation. And whatever you spent your newly-printed money building would be a net positive, and ideally something with practical economic value driving long-term growth: a high-speed national rail-line, new schools, hospitals, etc. Put more simply, Keynes' point was that the most senseless economic act you can imagine (paying people to dig holes in the ground) was still at worst merely equivalent to what the liquidationists were proposing in the 1930s.
- CWuestefeld 15y agoYou and I aren't going to resolve the macro debate here -- there are better minds working on the job, and haven't gotten to the bottom of it. But I wanted to take the opportunity to point out to other readers why they should be skeptical of the Keynesian prescription. First, Keynes oversimplifies the system by assuming that everything is one big commodity. Everything is considered in terms of aggregate demand. The thing is, we don't have an aggregate demand problem in this recession: in aggregate, we're doing fine, and have been for some time. The problem is that we've got over-investment in some areas (like housing), and the need to shed that excess, and redirect it into sectors that have greater demand, is painful in any case. But the government's efforts to prop up housing costs is actually interfering with that process. And putting people to work on infrastructure projects as a stimulus doesn't do anything to help. Keynes's model assumes that demand (again, let me remind you that his terminology is "aggregate demand") is one homogeneous thing. Second, inflation can't be used so effectively as a tool. Milton Friedman demonstrated pretty conclusively that such manipulations can't be effective, except in the very short term. The people aren't stupid, they can see that the government is inflating the currency, and then they take action to protect themselves from the losses that it would engender. The result is that the market will stymie the government's effort to benefit from inflation (not that the market will stop the inflation, but that it will interfere with any good that it might have done). Further, inflation turns out to be a vehicle for redistributing wealth -- in the wrong direction. Before the inflationary pressure is felt, the first ones who get their hands on the new specie will enjoy its full value. And those people are the bankers. Do we want to make the banking sector the beneficiary of all that extra buying power?