13 ms·
The article goes off the rails pretty early: What matters for a nation is its GDP. That's a country's equivalent of personal income. GDP is not income, it's a
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
The article goes off the rails pretty early: What matters for a nation is its GDP. That's a country's equivalent of personal income.
GDP is not income, it's a sum of flows. The classic illustrative example is a man marrying his maid:
Unmarried: Man earns $200k/year, pays his maid $25k/year. GDP = $225k.
Married: Man earns $200k/year, pays his wife $0. GDP = $200k.
In both cases, the ability of this pair of humans to service debt and purchase goods and services remains the same. Both couples are equally wealthy, you've just tweaked an accounting identity.
- Retric 15y agoActually case 2 probably pays less taxes and is therefore better off. In countries where tax evasion is high enough, the standard of living can be fairly high while the government is failing see Italy and Greece.
- DanielBMarkham 15y agoOne of the things I'm beginning to suspect is that the metrics are rigged. That is, most economic discussions are based on terms that aren't meaningful in any practical way. I see a lot of economists poking at the metrics with their pencils and talking theory while waving their arms around wildly. But I am simply an observer. I love watching smart people argue about stuff, so economics fascinates me. One thing is for sure, there is a ton of diverging opinions about the Euro and the sovereign debt crisis.
- beagle3 15y agoThe metrics, GDP being an example, are selected for political rather than merit. And then they are rigged. See e.g. http://www.shadowstats.com/ http://www.shadowstats.com/ for an attempt at an honest (or at the very least, consistent with 30 years ago) measurement of inflation and unemployment. The results are not pretty. My only surprise is that so many people are unaware of it. The government's income is indexed to the real inflation (by being an essentially constant proportion of salaries/profit), and expenditures are indexed to a computation the government is able to redefine at will. Is it a surprise that it is, in fact, redefined often, and that it always makes the government look better?
- jshen 15y agoI'm not sure what you mean by "honest". http://delong.typepad.com/sdj/2011/12/james-hamilton-on-shadowstats-and-niall-fergusons-claim-that-true-inflation-is-more-than-10-per-year.html http://delong.typepad.com/sdj/2011/12/james-hamilton-on-shad...
- beagle3 15y agoI will look into brad delong's blog later when I have time, but I did factcheck some of shadowstats numbers four years ago for work, and they were right on the money. E.g., the modern definition of unemployment is indeed very different from the definition of 40 years ago, which would yield something like 20%-25% today (compared to 12% or so today). And yet, everyone assumes it is the same statistic. Same with inflation. Personally, my 3 biggest expenses (rent, food, energy, in that order) have been going up at almost 10%/year over the last 3-4 years. I don't see a reason to doubt the shadowstats CPI metric. You're welcome to trust BLS data. Just be aware that you can't trust them when they are published [ http://www.zerohedge.com/article/visualizing-propaganda-error-term-behind-bureau-labor-statistics http://www.zerohedge.com/article/visualizing-propaganda-erro... ] and given that 90% of the values are revised to be worse within a month, their methodology cannot be considered statistically sound. edit: added "almost" to 10%. Just checked, and rent was "only" 8%/year.
- 15y ago
- mattobrien 15y agoI don't think that proves what you think it proves. You're missing what he would do with that $25k if he marries his maid. Maybe he would spend it on something else. Maybe he saves it and the bank loans it to someone else. In either case, it does matter what happens, because it gives us a clue into the velocity of money. GDP measures the value of all the stuff and services we produce. Which shows how much income we earned. So, you're wrong.
- aqme28 15y agoI think you're missing the point. Either way, it's 200k split between the two of them. Unmarried, he has 175k and she has 25k. Married, they both share 200k. He doesn't get to divert that 25k once they marry, because she will consume resources as well.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoIn the more detailed version of the hypothetical (i.e., the careful econ textbook version), it's explicitly stated that the wife continues spending the exact same amount as before, and she was already a live-in maid. Welfare has improved - the husband and wife have all the same goods and services as before (a house paid for by the man, which is cleaned by the woman), and they are now having sex (which is presumably welfare improving). Yet GDP has gone down $25k. GDP measures the value of all the stuff and services we produce. No, it doesn't. If you believe it does, I have a great stimulus package: ban joint bank accounts for married couples and require the higher income partner to pay a salary to the lower income partner. This will certainly increase GDP. Could you explain how this would have any effect on anything else?
- mattobrien 15y agoGDP is a flow. So is personal income. GDP is the dollar value of the stuff we sell. The flip side of that is that this is how much income we earned. You can dispute this, but it's what it means. http://bit.ly/HYokZe http://bit.ly/HYokZe Your example is flawed for the reasons I mentioned. You have to include the opportunity cost.
- streptomycin 15y agoThat doesn't really debunk the main thrust of the article, though. Yes, GDP isn't really like personal income, but less GDP growth is generally bad. And in this case, there are plenty of other economic metrics showing how bad the situation is, such as unemployment which was mentioned in the article.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoGDP is often positively correlated with welfare improvements, but it doesn't have to be. The focus on maximizing GDP rather than welfare is merely an example of gaming metrics. For a problem like unemployment, the question to ask is why the market isn't clearing. There might be a lack of demand for labor, but why haven't prices fallen until supply meets demand? The answer isn't as simple as "not enough GDP."
- frankydp 15y agoI do not think I would hire anyone in Spain if I was a business. There is a requirement to pay 6 months of unemployment for every 1 year of employment. So there is a negative incentive to keep old employees and not hire anyone new, due to the instant severance required at termination. It is kinda of like paying 150% for only 100% of a good. Employment policy has far more to due with unemployment than any other metric. The instant increase in youth UE was due to a huge percentage of youth workers being in the construction industry that took one of the hardest hits in the downturn, and the fact that replacement cost of any full time employee is to high to attempt fiscally.
- mattobrien 15y agoSpain has real structural problems in its labor markets. But those kind of generous policies aren't unique to Spain within Europe. And other European countries have far, far, far lower unemployment. Why? The answer is that employment policy does not have more to do with unemployment than any other metric. This is a story about a huge housing bubble and an awful currency union.
- jpdoctor 15y ago> Unmarried: Man earns $200k/year, pays his maid $25k/year. GDP = $225k. Married: Man earns $200k/year, pays his wife $0. GDP = $200k. At a 10% income tax rate: First case is $22.5K/yr, second case is $20K/yr. So yes: GDP is the same as income for the gov't for practical purposes.
- pyre 15y ago1. The government does not tax GDP. 2. IIRC, GDP includes government spending, which means that those tax dollars also go towards the GDP number (which are also less in the second case).
- theplatypus 15y ago1. GDP can either be viewed as the total income or total expenditure of an economy. The government taxes income. 2. The government taxes any money it spends and tax dollars do not increase GDP.
- pyre 15y agoIf government spending increases the GDP, then tax dollars indirectly do so. The government cannot spend tax dollars that it does not collect (without borrowing). Dollars that are not spent on taxes are not necessarily destined to be spent right away (vs. putting them in the bank / under the mattress).
- jpdoctor 15y agoYou're missing the point: You wrote that "The government does not tax GDP." It does. Also, anything that the gov't spends then counts as income for the other party = more income for the gov't. It is why debt-to-GDP is a very important ratio. It is also why the PIIGS were obvious candidates for financial meltdowns.
- zmj 15y agoIn the sense that flows are taxed to provide income for the government, GDP is analogous to income.
- yequalsx 15y agoTrue but in a country of 300 million people the measure is meaningful. There are not[1] a lot of such examples. It's not merely tweaking an accounting identity. It can be but in the aggregate, with a sufficiently large number of people, it isn't. [1] Added the important word "not".
- fleitz 15y agoA great example of GDP is government spending. A cut to government spending reduces GDP whether that money is productive or flushed down the toilet. Spain's GDP will shrink simply because the government spends less, the reduced spending should stimulate the local economy by transferring the money back to the people to spend.
- pyre 15y ago> reduced spending should [...] transferring the > money back to the people Only if there are tax cuts. If the government cuts spending without cutting taxes, then that does nothing for the people (other than putting a stop to digging the hole they are in). It doesn't put extra money in their pockets.
- hammock 15y agoCutting spending frees up cash to repay bonds, that money then makes its way back into the private economy.
- roc 15y agoActually paying the private economy the money you already owe them isn't exactly stimulative. I mean, one would hope the private economy already assumes the bonds it has coming due are going to be paid. Unless you're implying that investors worried that Spain my default before they personally get paid will pump money into Spain's private economy the moment their personal stake is clear. But panicky investors seem like the last people who would throw money into an economy with dodgy prospects. And in general, the private economy has shown no real desire to do anything with its money other than hand it to stable governments or sit on it, despite very little return in either case. So even as bonds mature, the money is not going into the private market at appreciable rates. And, in cases like Spain's, it also isn't likely to be handed directly back to the Spanish government keeping rates low. It's going to either demand higher rates, sustaining the problematic higher rates, or run screaming for safer harbor. In short, if investors had any intention of spending their money in Spain's private economy, there'd be no crisis. They would already be doing so, GDP prospects wouldn't be so awful and Spain's ability to meet its obligations wouldn't be in such doubt.
- loverobots 15y agoExactly. Or, I put in in savings you go out and buy crap. Just to be sure you also load up on credit cards. GDP goes nuts...for a while.
- Symmetry 15y agoTrue but not that important in this case. These factors tend to make it hard to compare GDP across countries or across time frames large enough for societies to change, but if a countries GDP suddenly falls by 5% it isn't because a bunch of people got married. In the long run GDP correlates with wealth, and in the short term it correlates quite well. And since it's easy to measure, we can legitimately use it in the way that the article uses it.
- yummyfajitas 15y ago...if a countries GDP suddenly falls by 5% it isn't because a bunch of people got married. True, but that's not the only pointless transaction one can make that would raise GDP. Here is another: taxing some people and using the proceeds to pay others to do valueless work (e.g., digging holes and filling them in). A well designed austerity measure will attempt to reduce such payments. This will reduce GDP, but not welfare. (That's not to say a poorly designed austerity measure can't be welfare reducing, I'm just pointing out that you need to dig deep into the specifics to make that determination.) If you want to argue against austerity, explain why it's welfare reducing. Pointing out that it might reduce GDP just doesn't cut it.
- CWuestefeld 15y agoKeynes would say that non-productive work is not valueless, because it still stimulates the economy by enabling those diggers to be consumers. Not that I subscribe to the theory, but there are many well-respected experts who do. I think that if they're intelligent in their austerity, then it'll be this non-productive stuff that gets cut. And what the big-government Keynesians so frequently miss is that the government spending crowds out the private sector. If the government frees up those resources (people, money, etc.), then the private sector can use it to produce something that people want to pay for. But even if Spain isn't so intelligent in their austerity, well, just because something needs to be done doesn't mean that it's the government that must do it. There will still be every opportunity for private industry, or even Spain's underground economy, to fill in the void.
- Symmetry 15y ago
- viandante 15y agoAre you sure of this example? It does look like GDP is 200k in both cases. The first case looks wrong, if he pulls 25k from his savings, there will be -25k in savings (or investments as they are the same) and +25k in spendings. Effect is 0...
- maratd 15y agoGross vs Net
- viandante 15y agoThe equation is Y=C+I+G. In the first case he has 175 of investments (I) and 25 of consume (C). In the second case he has 200 of investments. If some of the downvoters can please explain in those terms where I am wrong, it would be nice. Please, show me where the +25 come from in the 1st case.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoThe GDP being measured is that of the pair, not the man. Before marriage: 175 I + 50 of consume (the man consumes 25 in the form of a clean home, his maid consumes 25 to buy shoes) = 225. After marriage: 175I + 25 of consume (the 25 consumed by the wife to buy shoes) = 200. By the way, your question is good, and I really wish HN wouldn't reflexively downvote stuff they don't agree with.
- viandante 15y agoLet's say the man invests all his money in a socks business. In the first case his socks business will demand 25k less. The maid will demand 25k more. I still see effect 0. I think the problem is people are not considering savings in the equation...
- maratd 15y agoIn the first scenario, the income of the man is 200K and the income of the woman is 25K. For a total income of 225K. It doesn't matter where the money comes from or is going. That's the income both will write on the federal returns or whatever you want, for the sake of the example. When they get married, the man's income stays the same. The woman's income evaporates. She's not getting paid anymore. So their combined income is now 200K. But the situation is exactly the same! The same amount of work is being done. GDP works exactly the same way. It's an account of money flows, not production or actual economic activity.
- rauljara 15y agoThere are definitely problems with GDP, but you didn't just identify one of them. To keep things simple (at first) assume that in your example, all of the man's income otherwise goes under a mattress, doing nothing to improve the economy. The case of the man giving a job to maid is definitely worth more to the economy than the man who sticks it all under the mattress. In the real world, the money doesn't go under a mattress, of course. It gets spent, invested, etc. Your example doesn't represent reality at all, because both men, whether giving money to the maid or not, add way more than $200k to the economy, because by buying goods and services they are basically giving fractions of jobs to workers all across the economy. GDP tries to measure the economic activity of a nation. Saying it's a bad measure of individual wealth, while true, is completely beside the point. It was never meant to measure that. Someone who puts themselves into debt building a business will have a negative net wealth for quite a while. Doesn't mean they aren't adding value to the economy.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoThe case of the man giving a job to maid is definitely worth more to the economy than the man who sticks it all under the mattress. Why? If the man sticks money under the mattress, he reduces inflation (slightly) and increases the buying power of the rest of the world. In practical terms, a person who was a marginal purchaser of maid services is now able to have a clean home. I.e. for simplicity suppose there were 1000 people willing to buy maid service for $25k, 1 person willing to buy at $24,999 (the marginal purchaser) and 1000 maids. If the man becomes a miser, the price of maid service drops to $24,999 and the marginal purchaser has a clean home. Saying it's a bad measure of individual wealth, while true, is completely beside the point. It was never meant to measure that. Tell that to whoever wrote the article. You and I seem to be in complete agreement.
- rauljara 15y ago> Why? If the man sticks money under the mattress, he reduces inflation (slightly) and increases the buying power of the rest of the world. Because the money under the mattress doesn't produce a good or service. The maid does. By spending money you increase the number of goods and services available to the world. That's the way our economy tends to work. You spend money to get goods and services, which encourages the production of goods and services. Money in motion leads to more stuff. Money not in motion means people are sitting idle, not producing the goods and services they otherwise would. Whatever good the money under the mattress does for the inflation rate, it's more than counterbalanced by the fact that the world has less stuff to spend its money on.
- csomar 15y agoSo per my simple understanding of GDP, the GDP will remain the same. The next flaw in your example, is that if this person is in $25K/year deficit, marrying the maid will solve his problem.
- beagle3 15y agoIt's even worse than that: I render a service to yummyfajitas for $10M; say, sending a text message "you rock!" yummyfajitas renders similar service to me for $10M; say, sending a text message "you sock!" back. GDP = $20M+$0.20 (cost of text messages). Net change to economy: 0 You can (and indeed, countries do) inflate GDP for various reasons, such as GDP/debt requirements.
- astine 15y agoI'd argue that the economy was richer by two text messages, each valued at $10M by the recipients. Measuring the strength of an economy is a fundamentally hard thing to do because value itself is quite arbitrary.
- jshen 15y agoYou're assuming that prices don't reflect value. Isn't that a sketchy premise?
- beagle3 15y agoYou are assuming that prices do reflect value. Isn't that a sketchy premise? I just gave an example in which the GDP is 100,000,000 times larger then the observable transaction outside us two people ($20M vs. $0.20). It is perfectly ok from legal and tax perspectives (income and expenses cancel out; accounts were netted). Now, given how easy that is to do, why would you assume that prices properly reflect value? As an example, the GAP and Banana republic will sell you everything at 50% discount if you know what you are doing (there is a 40%-or-so discount window for "loyal customers" every week, and other coupons and rebates that stack up). What price should Banana Republic consider their inventory in? The higher price, or the lower price? Now, when they transfer this to Banana Republic UK, what are the prices (and values) they should use? This is all ripe for perversion, and it is this "flexibility" that allows Google and Microsoft and other multinational corps to pay 3% tax on one hand, and companies to present arbitrary GDP numbers on the other. Prices and values only reflect each other in efficient markets -- but those are almost nowhere to be found.
- 15y ago
- redthrowaway 15y agoThe specific analogy isn't particularly apt, but the general point of the article stands. When you have crushing unemployment and an income crisis, the solution is not to make further deep cuts in the misguided pursuit of austerity. You should be promoting growth, first and foremost. I know HN has a libertarian, small-government bent, but there's a reason public spending is included in GDP: it's expansionary. The government pays people to do things, then those people buy things. This spurs growth. As with many things, it's a spectrum and going too far in either direction (austerity v. public ownership of economy) is a bad thing. What is clear is that, when you have a quarter of your country out of work and fully half your future workforce untrained and non-contributing, you don't further reduce the consumptive power of your population. Unpopular an idea though it may be in these parts, Keynesian economics works in regards to recovering from recessions and depressions; disciples of the Austrian School have yet to show any ability to do so and their policies look set to spell the end of the Euro. The private sector is fundamentally better and healthier in the long run for a nation's economy than its public counterpart, but when the private sector is depressed and getting worse through negative feedback loops, the public sector has to step in. It's the growth driver of last resort.
- kazoolist 15y agoCounter-point. Public (gov't) spending "counts" in GDP, not because it's "expansionary", but because it's an expenditure on final goods and services. Even if government spending was contractionary, it would count towards GDP. That's just how GDP works. Likewise, there are reasonable arguments that government spending is/can-be contractionary. (I won't try to show that such spending _is_ contractionary, just that it may be). All that needs to happen for it to be contractionary is for each dollar of government spending to reduce (crowd out) private spending and/or investment by more than a dollar. Harvard economist Robert J. Barro has been arguing this is the case.
- redthrowaway 15y agoEven if I grant all of your points theoretically, there are no real-world examples to back them up. Libertarian (by way of Austrian) economics failed in this recession. Period. That's not to say that they don't lead to greater growth in the good times, but when the chips are down you want Keynes. You want large government intervention. Every successful recovery has rested on this principle, and every policy in opposition to it looks set to fail. A rational government would apply the appropriate models in the correct situations; we are, unfortunately, stuck with self-serving idiots.