4 ms·
I generally agree with this, but I think there are some issues with the reasoning: > What about AI personal assistants? Robot butlers? All those things! Even a
by kelnos 3y ago
I generally agree with this, but I think there are some issues with the reasoning:
> What about AI personal assistants? Robot butlers? All those things! Even assuming all that comes true sometime over the next decades: what is the market for personal assistants? What’s the market for butlers? Most people have neither of those things.
Sometimes making things dirt cheap means that people who couldn't afford them (or just didn't think the price was worth it) can now afford them. I don't have a personal assistant, and wouldn't think the cost of (a human) one would be justified, but if I could have a good AI personal assistant for a couple bucks a month, I might pay for that.
Overall, though, the goal isn't GPT-4. The goal is AGI. If anyone can actually crack that, assuming it doesn't murder us all, perhaps it could cheaply replace jobs in roles and markets where it could be quite lucrative.
Even if they can't crack AGI, maybe some future GPT-10 could be a suitable replacement for a lawyer in some contexts, for example. OP talks about how the legal profession has a bunch of structures and legalities that might make it hard to offer a robo-lawyer, but these things can change. Consider that Uber essentially broke all the laws around taxi (er, ahem, "rideshare") licensing, and they're all over the world now.
Regardless, I'm still skeptical of AI's future. Not just in the realm of whether or not AGI is possible with current or near-future technology, but also in the realm of financing (will VCs get tired of waiting after a while and stop investing in it) or politics (will AI get legislated to the point of uselessness).