3 ms·
How does knowledge want to be free? We're talking about generating derivatives of other people's art. Instead of hiring an artist I can ask the model to generat
by esafak 3y ago
How does knowledge want to be free? We're talking about generating derivatives of other people's art. Instead of hiring an artist I can ask the model to generate art in the same style for much less. Is that right?
- visarga 3y agoWhat I meant was that knowledge distillation from trained models is a very efficient process. That's why it "wants" to be free. Knowledge is easy to scrape, transform and train on. Once it gets into the open datasets, all models trained on that data will inherit the skills. In language, more recently the most useful training data has been generated with GPT4. Its abilities get transferred very efficiently to lower models. I think the same will happen with images. We're going to generate synthetic datasets that would replace the original copyrighted works, but be more efficient and diverse.
- fallingknife 3y agoYou can already ask artist A to make art in the style of artist B. So if you ask a machine to do the same thing, it's almost certainly going to be ruled legal by the courts. The concept of having copyright over a style is ridiculous anyway. Our courts should have their time taken up by making subjective determinations of whether some art is in the style of another.
- stavros 3y agoInstead of hiring Banksy, I can ask a guy down the hall to draw me something in the style of Banksy.
- esafak 3y agoThe concern is commercial art, not celebrity art, where the artist trumps the art. The way I see it playing out is that potential clients will tell the generator what to emulate and even link to or upload some samples. As tools continue to improve, the market for professional artists is going to shrink. To add insult to injury, the very art they create is being used to take away their livelihoods. That does not strike me as fair.