3 ms·
Most of the world is competing ethnostates, including most if not all Arab states. (I’m certainly glad my parent’s generation secured our ethnostate, at great c
by rayiner 3y ago
Most of the world is competing ethnostates, including most if not all Arab states. (I’m certainly glad my parent’s generation secured our ethnostate, at great cost.) Whether there is a better way is an open question. But anybody would be an idiot to sacrifice their ethnostate for that experiment. It’s never ended well.
- Georgelemental 3y ago> Anybody would be an idiot to sacrifice their ethnostate I'm sure Hamas feels the same way! I'm not going to say whether one or two-state solution is best, that's for Palestinians and Israelis to decide, but something's gotta give.
- rayiner 3y agoThe only workable solution is two states, and Arabs giving up the idea of retaking Jerusalem and rebuilding the caliphate. They got to keep nearly all their territorial gains from their conquest of the Levant, that should be good enough.
- Georgelemental 3y ago> The only workable solution is two states, and Arabs giving up the idea of retaking Jerusalem and rebuilding the caliphate. Yes, I don't think Palestinian Christians would love the idea of a caliphate in any case… > Territorial gains from their conquest of the Levant Again, for the daily life of the average resident of Gaza or the West Bank, this matters not a whit.
- tdeck 3y ago> Most of the world is competing ethnostates, including most if not all Arab states. This is simply not true. Almost none of the world is ethnostates.
- __loam 3y agoCountries like China and Japan are de facto ethnostates. There's also countries with religious majorities like Saudi Arabia, Iran, Pakistan, and India, many of which are associated with an ethnicity. Saudi Arabia is named after the Arabs. You could make the argument that many European states have dominant ethnic groups like the French, though they are nominally secular nations. The biggest cosmopolitan countries are the United States and Brazil if I remember correctly. Maybe Canada too. Europe is moving in that direction. Countries that have a diverse citizenry are more of an exception though. Not that I disagree with your probable view that we should all live in diverse secular democracies, I just think your claim that almost none of the world is ethnostates is somewhat suspect. I agree with the idea that Israel would ideally be a single secular state, but navigating that transition while preserving it as the safest place the Jews of the world can go would be an enormous challenge. The situation sucks and resists simple answers.
- keepamovin 3y agoGood analysis. Any ideas on solutions?
- __loam 3y agoNot a fucking clue man. These people hate each other and they both have reason to. Maybe you need a solution administered by a third party like the UN but no solution is going to leave everyone happy, and the UN itself is pretty flawed. There's plenty of insane people on both sides including Hamas.
- JamesBarney 3y agoI don't really see what the UN can do. Even if you had a solution that no one likes how do you force it on both parties? The UN doesn't have the firepower to force Israel to do anything it doesn't want to do, and doesn't have the desire to force Palestine to do anything it doesn't want to do.
- 3y ago