4 ms·
> Once it's on my machine, I have the moral right to do whatever I please with it. Sure, but Google also has the moral right to do everything possible with the
by crazygringo 3y ago
> Once it's on my machine, I have the moral right to do whatever I please with it.
Sure, but Google also has the moral right to do everything possible with their code to make it as hard as possible for you to skip ads on their videos. You both get to try as hard as you can, so good luck to you both.
There's no brainwashing here. It's just a business trying to make money, and trying to outsmart the users trying to outsmart it.
- aaomidi 3y ago> but Google also has the moral right to do everything possible with their code to make it as hard as possible for you to skip ads on their videos So, like use an entirely different part of the company like Chrome to push for WEI to make adblockers not run? Or maybe use chrome to push for manifest v3? Maybe the __moral right to do everything possible__ isn't actually moral when it's using its leverage in a separate market to protect another one of its assets. Maybe we should see this as something to anti-trust them?
- crazygringo 3y agoI dunno -- you've still got the moral right to use Firefox or Safari or a Chromium fork. Ads and adblockers are always going to be a cat and mouse game, so I don't see any reason to complain. Antitrust doesn't really enter the picture. Chrome doesn't even come preinstalled on PCs or Macs anyways -- you've got to go out of your way to choose to install it. So just don't, if you don't like it.
- aaomidi 3y ago> Antitrust doesn't really enter the picture. I don't think this is true. Google Meet, Youtube, etc all perform worse on non-Chrome/Chromium based browsers. I do think that the world's most popular browser, being owned by the same entity that owns Youtube, actively working to block adblockers (adblockers which, do *not* harm Chrome but do harm Youtube) is something for regulatory bodies to take into consideration.
- I_Am_Nous 3y ago>There's no brainwashing here. Advertising is at least trying to make you think thoughts it feeds you. "Buy Brand X, you'll get women!" If the advertising is effective, you'll associate Brand X with something positive and want to buy it. It's kind of blanket brainwashing with extra steps because it's more indirect. Similar technological brainwashing might be joining an algorithmic social media site and becoming convinced of something the algorithm felt was the most engaging thing that day and spread, regardless of truth. Choosing to believe what social media or advertising tells without healthy skepticism you is willingly accepting some brainwashing. There are people who feel really strongly about ads, and I'm one of them. I hate them, they don't share my values, and they are only trying to extract value from me. I run ad blocker in my browser, but mute and skip any ads I can like a peasant on my TV or phone. So overall I end up watching more ads than not since I don't watch videos on my PC much.
- Nevermark 3y agoI can't say I never see an ad, but I avoid/cancel services with ads, or happily sign up at the no-ad level. When I do see ads its shocking. Car ads have little to do with cars, and everything to do with insecurity and Pavlovian hacks. Idiocracy drip by drip. People expose themselves to crap influences day in and day out, then imagine this or that ad isn't impacting them. The stream has profoundly impacted them or they wouldn't tolerate any of it.
- somenameforme 3y agoI can't really remember the last time I saw an ad. And as a result (probably?) I find I "want" for far fewer things than most people who let themselves be drawn in by ads. If a million dollars just hopped into my bank account, I'd probably just invest it and go back to living, more or less, the same. And I'm in no way whatsoever rich. But contentedness is cheap, and easy, when you don't let yourself get drowned into the endless vacuum of artificial demand. [1] I am absolutely certain that the exponential increase in advertising is probably going to ultimately have been found to be at least partly responsible for so many of the mental and psychological problems that seem to be on the exponential increase in places like America. Humans are not designed to live our lives as donkeys chasing a carrot on a stick. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artificial_demand https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artificial_demand
- kelnos 3y ago> Sure, but Google also has the moral right to do everything possible with their code to make it as hard as possible for you to skip ads on their videos. The person you're replying to acknowledges this, albeit indirectly. But the point still stands: if Google sends me the bits, I am free (morally, and, at least for now, legally) to discard the bits that correspond to the ads if I can figure out how to do so without watching them. If Google can figure out ahead of time that's what I'm planning to do, and refuses to give me the bits, that's of course Google's right. > There's no brainwashing here. It's just a business trying to make money Advertising is psychological manipulation to coerce you to buy whatever product is on offer. The "best" advertising will convince you that you need a product that you'd never consider buying otherwise. "Brainwashing" might be a sensationalized way of putting it, but I don't think that's particularly inaccurate.