6 ms·
Microsoft is holding back the secure web
- zokier 15y agoI think it is completely unrealistic to even think that MS would add SNI to XP anymore. 5 years ago, maybe? But now, that's ridiculous. And I strongly disagree with the title that MS is the one holding secure web back. I'd blame the users (both corporations and personal ones) who won't upgrade, either to modern browser or a modern OS. edit: Additionally those nice graphs are misleading. I bet other (SNI supporting) browsers have significant market share on XP too. Compare the market share of IE <9 (<20%) to XP (33%). And some of those IE8 users probably are on Vista/7. edit2: And if we look at IE8 market share trend, it has been steadily decreasing for the past year. I feel safe to say that in a year it has decreased to a low enough percentage so that it can be ignored.
- mattmanser 15y agoWhile Windows 7 is great and all and I love it compared to XP, what does it actually give you to justify the price? Pretty much sod all. That's why users haven't forked out money. If it comes free with the new computers, fine. I reckon we'll be seeing it for another couple of years. But don't blame the users, blame the utter lack of progress by MS.
- zokier 15y ago>While Windows 7 is great and all and I love it compared to XP, what does it actually give you to justify the price? SNI?
- omh 15y agoBut everyone running servers is dealing with that for me. As an end user, why do I care?
- monkeyfacebag 15y ago"While Windows 7 is great and all and I love it compared to XP, what does it actually give you to justify the price?" I think the UI improvements alone (desktop search, Aero Snap) are worth the price. Isn't this how Apple justifies charging for new versions of OS X? I still use XP from time to time and 7 is far and away a better experience. FWIW, I think it also provides a better experience than OS X, although, sadly, without the benefit of a POSIX layer. "blame the utter lack of progress by MS" It's not like MS has been sitting on their hands of late. Kinect demonstrates this. Windows 8 demonstrates this. I just don't think there's an appetite for MS progress or innovation. What people like about Windows computers isn't (and hasn't been for a long time) Windows. It's pretty hard to innovate when no one wants what you're selling. To be fair, I don't "blame the users" for this. When MS had a tight grip on computing, they did little to make their products more compelling and they are realizing the consequences of this now: Windows' name is mud.
- zokier 15y ago>I just don't think there's an appetite for MS progress or innovation. What people like about Windows computers isn't (and hasn't been for a long time) Windows. It's pretty hard to innovate when no one wants what you're selling. Good point. There is another side in here too: many people want to keep using the old systems they have learnt, instead of new better systems. Eg the backslash of Ribbon. It's pretty hard to innovate when on one wants anything to change.
- bediger4000 15y agoIs an "innovation" that nobody wants really innovation, or merely change-for-changes-sake? I think that if something is better, then people will want it, steal it even. Take those un-skippable previews on some DVDs: people cite them as reasons to scrounge up pirate versions of DVDs. Oh, and how about those abominable "region codes" on DVDs? Are those "innovation" or merely a monopoly-enabled form of price fixing?
- monkeyfacebag 15y ago> Is an "innovation" that nobody wants really innovation, or merely change-for-changes-sake? It's not clear, at least to me, that nobody wants Microsoft's innovations. I think it's more that they don't want them from Microsoft. Windows is a tough beast to change. The near ubiquity of the platform in the 90s and 00s means that there's a lot of people out there who "imprinted" on the Windows UI model. It doesn't just affect Microsoft, though it may affect them disproportionately because of brand association. While OS X is a screaming success now, Apple's transition from OS 9 was anything but. It took 3 major revisions of the software before it was usable and a lot of people hated it at the time. In contrast, Apple's introduction of iOS received a much warmer reception because there was no incumbent. Changing a major technology platform is hard.
- omh 15y agoThat's why users haven't forked out money. If it comes free with the new computers, fine. I reckon we'll be seeing it for another couple of years. It's been coming free with our corporate PCs for years now, and we're still unlikely to switch any time soon. (At least until they stop shipping security patches)
- zokier 15y agoJust curious, why haven't you switched yet or have planned to switch 'anytime soon'?
- AndrewDucker 15y agoMoving a few thousand PCs to a new OS means testing every application you use to make sure it's compatible, and then running a large set of rollouts to desktops. It's very disruptive, and horribly expensive. If at all possible, you don't do it more than once per decade.
- zokier 15y agoI understand that it's expensive, but from my point of view it seems like upgrading is going to happen sooner or later, and I just don't see that many advantages in waiting for later.
- AndrewDucker 15y agoIf we did it every five years then it would have cost twice as much over the last decade, and we'd have ended up stuck with Vista for five years :->
- zokier 15y agoAre you saying that many of those clinging to XP are planning to jump directly to 8?
- 15y ago
- loverobots 15y agoThat's the curse for MS, there are very few legitimate reasons to upgrade, XP works great and MS offered upgrades for 10 years! I cannot think of one thing that I wish they had though, at least not on top of my head. Everything else is offered by third parties
- billpatrianakos 15y agoYou're right but I don't think it's a matter of money. It's convenience. Microsoft seems to be going out of their way to keep users of their older products in the dark ages. The other major OS players (Apple and Linux distros) seem to be able to upgrade users of their older products when it comes to things like SNI. I mean, unless I'm seriously misinformed it shouldn't be a big deal to offer users of XP support for SNI and generally allow them to access upgrades that are in the same kind of class (for lack of a better word) as SNI. That kind of upgrade is very different than giving users the kind of OS upgrades that bring better performance or new UI's, various little wizards to help them connect to wifi, etc. The latter type of upgrade is why an average user upgrades a system, not because of under-the-hood stuff like SNI so giving it to them when they're still such a large portion of MS users isn't going to discourage them from upgrading to Win7 or whatever new thing they come out with. I've been able to upgrade my Mac for about four years now from Leopard to Snow Leopard to Lion without a hitch. If I were using XP I'd probably have to buy new hardware with every upgrade and that's what's stopping people. It's not the money but the inconvenience that stops people. If their XP is doing the bare minimum of what they need it for then they're not going to upgrade to Win7 even if they know about the new ways it makes their life more convenient and how much prettier it is. They don't want to transfer their old important files from one drive to another. That's scary for the average person no matter how easy Microsoft advertises it to be. It feels like Microsoft makes decisions with a heavier focus on marketing than real technical improvements, innovations, or user experience. I mean they make a good product (it's not my cup of tea but I'm not a bigot about it) but they're still operating like they have no competition and it's really screwing with people like us who are trying to move things forward.
- leviathant 15y agoIt's great that you've been able to upgrade from Leopard - released in 2007. Comparing that to upgrading XP is disingenuous, as Windows XP was released in 2001, which puts it in the vintage of OS X Puma. I had a Dual G5 Power Mac from 2006. Consequently, I have not been able to upgrade that machine past Leopard. That's new hardware that had all of a single year of OS upgrades. It's been demonstrated that you can run Windows 7 on Windows XP hardware. I know that when I upgraded from XP to 7 on a several-years-old machine when Win7 first came out, it was notably faster. I had installed the free beta, just to see, and was so surprised at how much better it was, I pre-ordered an operating system for the first time in my life. What version of OSX can you run on a Mac from 2001?
- seanp2k2 15y agoFor it to be ignored, it better be below 1% market share. Try explaining to your invesors that users least likely to understand why they can't do business with your site are unimportant. If your market is "developers"....it might be OK to ignore ie8 at 5% and explain why in some js that detects it. However, for majority of e-commerce sites, even 1% would mean a loss in sales that would be unacceptable to many business owners I know Source: I work in web hosting -- e-commerce mostly.
- zokier 15y agoInstead of explaining that they can't do business with XP users, explain that supporting XP users incurs the additional cost of an IP. Let them decide if it's worth it.
- macarthy12 15y agoAsia is more the issue than XP actually. XP is used in Asia mostly because it is easy to use a cracked version (i.e. free) and it runs most popular windows programs etc. (low hardware reqs too) So if MS just released a cheaper version of their OS in Asia (africa and south america too) of their OSes then we could all move on.
- zokier 15y agoThat's what Starter Edition is.
- HerraBRE 15y agoIf Starter Edition lacks the "easily pirated" feature, then it can't really displace Windows XP in these cases.
- kijin 15y agoI like this idea. MS should drop the price on Win 7 Starter / Home Basic to something like $9.95 after Win 8 is released. Then run a massive campaign to promote the security benefits of the "freshly outdated" version. If they do this well, they could easily rake in a few dozen million dollars without hurting the Win 8 market.
- AndrewDucker 15y agoXP is dead in two years (April 2014 is the end of any kind of support for it). I cannot see how it is in Microsoft's interests to put out new functionality for it at this point. Any large corporation will have switched away from it by then (their risk assessments will force that), so that's the point you can start using the new functionality.
- HerraBRE 15y agoAs a side-note, it is not just IE that is affected, any browser which relies on the bundled OS encryption libraries has the same problem. It has been a while since I checked (I did a fair bit of SNI-related research for the HTTPS support in https://pagekite.net/ https://pagekite.net/), but at the time Chrome and Firefox on XP also lacked SNI support on WinXP for [edit: what I assumed was] this reason. I think Chrome has since bundled their own crypto code so recent versions of Chrome on XP do work, but I am not sure about Firefox. I didn't test Opera. This was also an issue on Linux desktops relatively recently, for alternative browsers like wget and KDE's Konqueror.
- zokier 15y agoI thought Mozilla (and thus Firefox) have always used their own crypto library, NSS: http://www.mozilla.org/projects/security/pki/nss/ http://www.mozilla.org/projects/security/pki/nss/
- HerraBRE 15y agoYou're right, but it still didn't work when I tested it. Looks like I should have dug deeper to figure out why, instead of just "blaming XP".
- pedrocr 15y agoLooking at the Wikipedia page for SNI it's actually Google that's holding back the secure web. Android 2.x doesn't support SNI and according to the Wikipedia webstats that's more than 90% of the Android mobile web users (25% of the total mobile web usage). That's for a product released in 2009, after XP stopped being sold.
- HerraBRE 15y agoHere, let me link that for you: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Server_Name_Indication http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Server_Name_Indication
- seanp2k2 15y agoSee also: the awesome that is WebDAV. Very similar story as SNI.
- AndrewDucker 15y agoBut a product (generally) with a two-year lifespan. Android phones should all be ICS by 2014, hopefully.
- drhowarddrfine 15y agoMicrosoft has always, always held back the web.
- brudgers 15y ago>"It's been around in various incarnations since 2004." XP was released in 2001. [edit for comment] TLS 2.0 which included SNI was released in 2006. Windows Vista which included IE7 was released in 2006/2007. [/edit for comment] Microsoft may be guilty of many sins, this is not one of them.
- zokier 15y agoI don't really see what OpenSSL has to do with anything. I'm pretty sure that MS has its own independent SSL implementation. SSL as a protocol is fully documented and standardized, and has been for a long time.
- zokier 15y agoIE7 and IE8 both support Windows XP, but sans SNI. They could have shipped Vista version of their SSL library with IE7/8 but they didn't.
- brudgers 15y agoGiven the changes between Vista and XP particularly in the area of security, it's not certain that it was simply a matter of shipping the Vista version of Schannel to XP customers. What evidence do you have that implementation would have been trivial?
- zokier 15y agoNo evidence obviously. Just a silly notion that SSL would be a well encapsulated standalone user-space library, and inherently fairly portable. In hindsight, that was naïve from me.
- yuhong 15y agoTLS extensions dates back to 2003: http://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc3546 http://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc3546
- pilif 15y agoThe generally lacking support of SNI is such a shame. Especially when you consider that there are currently two forces in move that clearly work against each other: On one end you have cool stuff like SPDY and more and more pervasive proxies altering HTTP data on the fly which makes SSL more and more interesting. On the other hand, we are running out of IPv4 addresses, making it harder and harder to use one address per virtual host. So even though we are much more motivated to use SSL these days, the growing difficulty of acquiring IP addresses makes it harder and harder.
- zokier 15y agoYou are conveniently ignoring IPv6 which IE on XP actually supports. Maybe instead of buggering MS to add features to a dead OS we should be buggering ISPs to get on the IPv6 train.
- pilif 15y agoI was't buggering MS either. I was just stating the state of affairs (as other comments state, Android is equally broken). I can't tell you what's more likely: To get both XP and Android fixed or to get wide-spread IPv6 deployment. I have a feeling though that it's probably more likely that we see XP dead and Android fixed than we are going to see the current bulk of XP users (Corporations with crazy firewalls and users of pirated XP in Asia) having IPv6 connectivity. I would love to be proven wrong though as I see IPv4 scarcity to be a much bigger threat to a free internet than anything else.
- zokier 15y ago>I was't buggering MS either. I was just stating the state of affairs (as other comments state, Android is equally broken). It wasn't my intention to pick you out specifically. I aimed that comment to the whole community. >I can't tell you what's more likely: To get both XP and Android fixed or to get wide-spread IPv6 deployment. I think that latter is far more likely. While IPv6 adoption has been relatively slow so far, still there has been constantly some progression. So I feel that there is fair chance for wide-spread IPv6 eventually. On the other hand, I'm almost certain that MS will not add SNI to XP ever.
- omh 15y agoThis looks like a precursor to what we can expect with IPv6. A significant minority of users are going to be on old operating systems that can't or won't be upgraded to support IPv6, and servers will have to make the choice about whether to exclude them or not.
- nirvdrum 15y agoWhile I concede this is a problem for those wanting to do mass hosting of SSL, I'd hardly say that's what's holding back the secure web. Way too many devs outright refuse to run on SSL in situations where it would work just fine. Some have old notions of computational overhead of encryption. Many are concerned about what SSL does to caching. It's just hyperbole to blame Microsoft for this. The note about when SNI was released is illustrative of that, since mod_ssl didn't support SNI until quite recently. Prior to that, one had to use mod_gnutls which created a whole raft of different issues.
- zokier 15y agoWell, SSL definitely incurs a performance penalty even these days when actual encrypting is relatively cheap: http://www.semicomplete.com/blog/geekery/ssl-latency.html http://www.semicomplete.com/blog/geekery/ssl-latency.html
- nirvdrum 15y agoTrue. But the argument I hear most often is that they can't run as many processes because of the SSL overhead. But, that aside, even if the latency is the problem, that's certainly not going to be solved by XP supporting SNI.