2 ms·
As a non-circumcised man, I am completely certain that circumcision is completely stupid and abusive, because the skin that is removed is one of the most sensit
by adrian_b 3y ago
As a non-circumcised man, I am completely certain that circumcision is completely stupid and abusive, because the skin that is removed is one of the most sensitive parts of the body and losing it would be as bad as losing any other senses.
Nevertheless, I find it hard to believe that someone circumcised as an infant would be traumatized in any way by this, because they would never know what they have lost, like someone who has been born deaf or without the sense of smell.
Regarding the pain of the procedure, even if it could be somehow remembered, there seems to be no way how it could affect development, because many children may experience even more painful accidents from which they can recover perfectly without any long-term consequences.
As you say, there may be only some indirect correlation, e.g. caused by the differences between the parents who would choose to circumcise their sons and the parents who would make the opposite choice.
- stephen_g 3y agoLoss of sensation is definitely a potential side effect but statistically quite rare - in my experience (fully circumcised for medical reasons as an adult), I definitely didn't lose any sensation. It's a little different, but I was actually surprised at how little things changed after recovery actually.
- smeej 3y agoI do think there's a different emotional response to accidental pain and pain deliberately inflicted by a (previously) trusted person, even for little children. If a child falls off his bunk bed and needs staples in his head, there's no relational harm from the incident. If anything, a caring parental response makes the child feel safer, knowing someone will intervene on their behalf to take care of them when dangerous things happen.
- oliwarner 3y agoSeems dangerously close to arguing that you could do anything to a baby. I think the problem with this sort of surgery is you will one day find out that somebody did this to you, that somebody took something from you that you can never get back. It's a trauma that I'm sure most people get over but some don't.