4 ms·
Care to elaborate? No one's right to speech has been affected here; not pg's nor the IDF's. Free speech has never been the right to not be trolled.
by ceejayoz 3y ago
Care to elaborate? No one's right to speech has been affected here; not pg's nor the IDF's. Free speech has never been the right to not be trolled.
- Tyrek 3y agoFree speech may not be the relevant criticism here, but there's... somewhat of a discomfort of a government (if admittedly foreign) agency calling out specific individuals. I know we're in the era of terminally online politicians, but this crosses some sort of professionalism boundary? EDIT: Which is to say, it's not illegal or anything, but I'm sending a frowning emoji.
- wsgeorge 3y ago> but this crosses some sort of professionalism boundary? I don't know. I assume any organisation interested in directing online discourse about subjects it is vested in does something like this. Especially political organisations. This is politics. Kinda dirty, but that's what it is, I guess. It's probably only noteworthy because the context and persons/groups involved are noteworthy.
- jakelazaroff 3y agoPaul Graham's hasn't, you mean. The IDF is not a person; it has no rights.
- ceejayoz 3y agoThat's not universally true. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commercial_speech https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commercial_speech > In the United States, commercial speech is "entitled to substantial First Amendment protection, albeit less than political, ideological, or artistic speech". Now, the IDF isn't under US jurisdiction, but the idea that only individual humans have rights is... not supported by the facts.
- esalman 3y agoWhat's happening here is plain for everyone to see. IDF has much much more resources, power and influence to suppress the free speech of individuals. You are using IDF's right to free speech as a way to justify the suppression.
- ceejayoz 3y agoAgain, free speech has never been the right to not be trolled, or criticized, or made fun of, or debunked. Swap out the IDF for JK Rowling or Bill Gates sending their followers at someone; there's never been a requirement for equal power between the two speakers for the right to exist. (It's not like pg doesn't have his own resources and connections, anyways.) A "the IDF cannot troll people on Twitter" law would seem to limit free speech, not enhance it.
- esalman 3y agoYou are coming up with some really spectacular arguments. We don't have to go as far as JK Rowling or Bill Gates. There's a billionaire Harvard alumni on Twitter using his "free speech" to harass and doxx Harvard grad students right now. PG cannot detain people or bomb settlements. IDF can and does. They are not merely trolling here.
- esalman 3y agoIDF is not a person. Does 2FA apply to states and corporations? I see this more as manipulation and misinformation rather than free speech.