5 ms·
The proof that it is not wider economic pressures is their profit margin trend: https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/DE/deere/profit-margins https://www.
by lotsofpulp 3y ago
The proof that it is not wider economic pressures is their profit margin trend:
https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/DE/deere/profit-margins https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/DE/deere/profit-ma...
Due to advances in software, they saw an opportunity to increase their profit margins.
The question is, are there insufficient businesses that can sell what Deere sells without the restricting software at a lower price? Based on Deere’s success in increasing its profit margins, it seems like the answer is no.
So then the question is why are there insufficient businesses? Is selling what Deere sells so high barrier to entry that a new seller will not try? Is it possible to lower those barriers to entry?
- wongarsu 3y agoMaybe it just takes longer for the market to react. Selling farming equipment has a local component to it: you need local dealers and a robust service network. Countries also tend have protectionist policies about the market, since farming is of strategic importance. All of this slows down the expansion of competitors. Add to that that the average lifetime of farming equipment is very high. The ~10 years that John Deere has shown this behavior might just be too little for the market to adjust.
- xenadu02 3y agoJD does the hard stuff that others aren't as willing to invest in: a large service network with spare parts and spare machines. Harvest time can be make-or-break for farmers. Stuff you don't expect like a large storm at the end of summer can blow over corn stalks. That makes it a lot slower to run the combine at harvest time. If early fall storms are forecast you might literally need to get everyone available out in the field to harvest the corn in the next 3-4 days or you can expect the value of your crop to drop dramatically - everything will be wet and it's no longer warm or sunny enough for it to dry out. The field turns to mud and the grain elevator ain't gonna pay full price for water-soaked corn. Everyone else is in the same boat so every available truck+driver is booked. Every mechanic is already 5 tractors backlogged from all the other farmers with emergencies. Then your harvester/combine dies. If you're with JD... they have a crews of engineers/mechanics and semi trailers loaded with parts driving around the country following the harvest. They will get you going again in a day or two, not 1-4 weeks later when some other dealer can fit you in or when the spare part you need arrives. From JD's perspective that service network and parts stock costs a lot of money to maintain so it is available during harvest. They don't want customers going the cheap aftermarket route 11 months of the year because one month of sales can't sustain harvest support teams long-term. It's similar to peak electric generation capacity. Generator plants aren't economic if they only run 5% of the year at regular prices. In this analogy peak pricing has a limit: it would very quickly make harvesting the crop unprofitable. FWIW I do think it's mostly a money grab by JD. Same reason Chamberlain closed their garage door opener API and has locked down myIQ: they want to force platforms, automakers, etc to pay for access to "their" customers and turn garage door openers into MRR. It's basically free money that you couldn't even imagine prior to the internet.
- timc3 3y agoGrowing up on a farm 30 years ago - we wouldn't have to wait a day or two. You would start fixing the problem straight away, worse case being someone would have to drive to get a part and then you would install it. And many parts you could fix yourself with a well stocked workshop (think welding gear, cutting equipment, stuff to work on hydraulics, lots of random crap, spare bits of metal and a large space or in the field). Then came the computers...
- tomwheeler 3y agoThat's exactly right. My grandfather owned a fairly large farm and had a workshop so he and the workers could service the equipment on site. Some of the tractors lasted 30 years or more because they were so well maintained. Even in his 70s, the joints he welded when repairing them were far better than the originals.
- bluGill 3y agoAt what cost. I'll bet your grandfather never tracked the cost of his workshop and time. Note too that the scenario is all hands on deck harvesting - skipping one day of harvest can (if there is worst case storm) cost your more in profit than a brand new combine. If you have to pay someone labor the cost of keeping old machines running adds up a lot farther than most people realize. I know one construction company owner who in the 1990s worked it all out - all that 30 year old equipment that he was keeping running. Then he want to a dealer and signed a lease for $25,000/month, as he left the negotiations, reeling from the price tag, his account turned to him and said "you just saved yourself $30,000/month".
- gen220 3y agoWhen you outsource support, that carries costs that are difficult to measure and not carried in the lease. Your "supply chain of business" just became less robust. If you're in a business where a couple of days in lead time for repair can make or break a harvest, (1) having a repairs workshop (2) investing in tools you can reliably repair yourself is essentially an insurance premium that protects your harvest by placing its success squarely within the hands of the part most interested in success. This "insurance" aspect is something that accountants reliably fail to account for, because it doesn't show up in any business ledger. But this way of thinking generally wins because it increases fiscal efficiency, while the side-effect of making systems more fragile is consistently written-off.